Dr.
H. Schmidt has an admirable note here, pointing out the great and
important difference between S. Paul’s use of this analogy of the
grain of wheat, and that of our Saviour in S. John xii. 23, whence S. Paul
took it. In the words, “The hour is come that the Son of man
should be glorified. Verily, verily I say unto you, Except a corn of
wheat fall into the ground and die, it abideth alone: but if it die, it
bringeth forth much fruit” (A.V.), the fact and the similitude
exactly correspond. To the corn with its life-engendering shoot,
answers the man with his vivifying soul. The shoot, when the necessary
conditions are fulfilled, breaks through the corn, and mounts up into
an ear, exquisitely developed: so the soul, when the due time is come,
bursts from the body into a nobler form. Again, through the death of
the integument a number of new corns are produced: so through the death
of the body that encases a perfect soul (i.e. that of Jesus), an
abundance of blessings is produced for mankind. Everything here exactly
corresponds; the principle of life, on the one hand in the corn, on the
other hand in the human body, breaks, by dying, into a more beautiful
existence. But this comparison in S. Paul becomes a similitude
rather than an analogy. With him the lifeless body is set over
against the life-containing corn; he does not compare the lifeless body
with the lifeless corn: because out of the latter no stalk and ear
would ever grow. The comparison, therefore, is not exact: it is not
pretended that the rising to life of the dead human body is not a
process transcendently above the natural process of the rising of the
ear of wheat. But the similitude serves to illustrate the form
and the quality of the risen body, which has been in question
since v. 35 (1 Cor. xv.), “with
what body do they come?” and the salient point is that the risen
body will be as little like the buried body, as the ear of wheat
is like its corn. The possibility of the Resurrection has been
already proved by S. Paul in this chapter by Christ’s own
Resurrection, which he states from the very commencement as a fact: it
is not proved by this similitude.