How comes it, then, that you
fail to see that the whole conception of your argument on the subject
is being overthrown, and go on making yourself ridiculous with your
childish web of sophistry, saying that, if we believe that He who was
apparent to the senses has been made by God to be Christ and Lord, it
necessarily follows that the Lord once more “emptied
Himself” anew to become Man, and underwent a second birth? What
advantage does your doctrine get from this? How does what you say show
the King of creation to be created? For my own part I assert on the
other side that our view is supported by those who contend against us,
and that the rhetorician, in his exceeding attention to the matter, has
failed to see that in pushing, as he supposed, the argument to an
absurdity, he is fighting on the side of those whom he attacks, with
the very weapons he uses for their overthrow. For if we are to believe
that the change of condition in the case of Jesus was from a lofty
state to a lowly one, and if the Divine and uncreated Nature alone
transcends the creation, he will, perhaps, when he thoroughly surveys
his own argument, come over to the ranks of truth, and agree that the
Uncreated came to be in the created, in His love for man. But if he
imagines that he demonstrates the created character of the Lord by
showing that He, being God, took part in human nature, he will find
many such passages to establish the same opinion which carry out their
support of his argument in a similar way. For since He was the Word and
was God, and “afterwards,” as the prophet says, “was
seen upon earth and conversed with men Bar. iii. 37.,” He will hereby be proved to be one of
the creatures! And if this is held to be beside the question, similar
passages too are not quite akin to the subject. For in sense it is just
the same to say that the Word that was in the beginning was manifested
to men through the flesh, and to say that being in the form of God He
put on the form of a servant: and if one of these statements gives no
help for the establishment of his blasphemy, he must needs give up the
remaining one also. He is kind enough, however, to advise us to abandon
our error, and to point out the truth which He himself maintains. He
tells us that the Apostle Peter declares Him to have been made Who was
in the beginning the Word and God. Well, if he were making up dreams
for our amusement, and giving us information about the prophetic
interpretation of the visions of sleep, there might be no risk in
allowing him to set forth the riddles of his imagination at his
pleasure. But when he tells us that he is explaining the Divine
utterances, it is no longer safe for us to leave him to interpret the
words as he likes. What does the Scripture say? “God made Lord
and Christ this Jesus whom ye crucified Acts ii. 36..” When everything, then, is found to
concur—the demonstrative word denoting Him Who is spoken of by
the Name of His Humanity, the charge against those who were stained
with blood-guiltiness, the suffering of the Cross—our thought
necessarily turns to that which was apparent to the senses. But he
asserts that while Peter uses these words it is the pretemporal
existence that is indicated by the word “made” Altering Oehler’s punctuation, which here seems certainly
faulty: some slighter alterations have also been made in what precedes,
and in what follows.. Well, we may safely allow nurses and old
wives to jest with children, and to lay down the meaning of dreams as
they choose: but when inspired Scripture is set before us for
exposition, the great Apostle forbids us to have recourse to old
wives’ tattle Cf. 1 Tim. iv. 7. The quotation is not verbal.. When I hear
“the Cross” spoken of, I understand the Cross, and when I
hear mention of a human name, I understand the nature which that name
connotes. So when I hear from Peter that “this” one was
made Lord and Christ, I do not doubt that he speaks of Him Who had been
before the eyes of men, since the saints agree with one another in this
matter as well as in others. For, as he says that He Who was crucified
has been made Lord, so Paul also says that He was “highly
exalted Cf. Phil. ii. 9,” after the Passion and the
Resurrection, not being exalted in so far forth as He is God. For what
height is there more sublime than the Divine height, that he should say
God was exalted thereunto? But he means that the lowliness of the
Humanity was exalted, the word, I suppose, indicating the assimilation
and union of the Man Who was assumed to the exalted state of the Divine
Nature. And even if one were to allow him licence to misinterpret the
Divine utterance, not even so will his argument conclude in accordance
with the aim of his heresy. For be it granted that Peter does
say of Him Who was in the beginning, “God made Him Lord and
Christ, this Jesus Whom ye crucified,” we shall find that even so
his blasphemy does not gain any strength against the truth. “God
made Him,” he says, “Lord and Christ.” To which of
the words are we to refer the word made? with which of those
that are employed in this sentence are we to connect the word? There
are three before us:—“this,” and “Lord,”
and “Christ.” With which of these three will he construct
the word “made”? No one is so bold against the truth as to
deny that “made” has reference to “Christ” and
“Lord”; for Peter says that He, being already whatever He
was, was “made Christ and Lord” by the Father.