right to come to christian sacraments. But heathen men must turn from their heathenism,
and come: so likewise wicked men must turn from their wickedness, and come.
I endeavoured to prove, that that brotherly love, which is required towards the members
of the christian church in general, is such a love as is required to those only whom we have
reason to look upon as true saints. Mr. W. disputes, through two pages, (p. 66, 67 ) against
the force of my reasoning to prove this point; and yet when he has done, he allows the point.
He allows it (p. 68. d, e.) as an undisputed thing, that it is the image of God and Christ ap-
pearing or supposed to be in others, that is the ground and reason of this love. And so again
(p. 71. d e.) he grants, that there must be some apprehension, and judgment of the mind, of
the saintship of persons, in order to this brotherly love. Indeed he pretends to differ from
me in this, that he denies the need of any positive judgment: but doubtless the judgment or
apprehension of the mind must be as positive as love founded on that apprehension and
judgment of the mind.
In p. 78, 79. he seems to insist, that what the apostle calls unworthy communicating, is
eating in a greedy, disorderly, and irreverent manner: as though men might communicate
without grace, and yet not communicate unworthily, in the apostle’s sense. But if so, the
apostle differed much in his sense of things from Mr. W.—The latter says, in his sermon
on Christ a King and Witness, (p. 77, 78.) “These outward acts of worship, when not per-
formed from faith in Christ, and love to God, are mocking God—in their own nature a
lie—the vilest wickedness;—instead of being that religion, which Christ requires, it is infinitely
contrary to it—the most flagrant and abominable impiety, and threatened with the severest
damnation.“ Is not this a communicating unworthily enough of all reason?
In p. 132, 133. Mr. W. strenuously opposes me in my supposition, that the way of freely
allowing all that have only moral sincerity to come into the church, tends to the reproach
and ruin of the church. On the contrary, he seems to suppose it tends to the establishing
and building up of the church. But I desire that what Mr. Stoddard says, in his sermon on
the danger of speedy degeneracy, may be considered under this head. He there largely insists,
that the prevailing of unconverted men and unholy professors among a people, is the prin-
cipal thing that brings them into danger of speedy degeneracy and corruption. He says, that
where this is the case, there will be many bad examples, that will corrupt others; and that
unconverted men will indulge their children in evil, will be negligent in their education;
and that by this means their children will be very corrupt and ungoverned; 420 that by this
420 If we have reason to expect it will be thus with ungodly parents, with respect to their children, then certainly
such cannot reasonably expect ministers and churches should admit their children to baptism, in a dependence
that they do give them up to God, and will bring them up in the nurture and admonition of the Lord, if they
make no profession that implies more than moral sincerity; and none but what wicked men may as well make
as the godly, and speak true.
2001
SECTION X. Other inconsistencies.