AGAINST THE PELAGIANS.— BOOK I. 455
can be without sin if he chooses, but that a
man can be what the Apostles were not.
C. Do you think me fool enough to dare
say such a thing ?
A. Although you do not say it in so many
words, however reluctant you may be to ad-
mit the fact, it follows by natural sequence
from your proposition. For if a man can be
without sin, and it is clear the Apostles were
not without sin, a man can be higher than the
Apostles : to say nothing of patriarchs and
prophets whose righteousness under the law
was not perfect, as the Apostle says,1 " For all have sinned, and fall short of the glory of
God : being justified freely by His grace
through the redemption that is in Christ
Jesus : whom God set forth to be a propiti-
ator." 143. C. This way of arguing is intricate
and brings the simplicity which becomes the
Church into the tangled thickets of philosophy. What has Paul to do with Aristotle ? or
Peter with Plato ? For as the latter was the
prince of philosophers, so was the former
chief of the Apostles : on him the Lord's Church was firmly founded, and neither-
rushing flood nor storm can shake it.
A. Now you are rhetorical, and while you
taunt me with philosophy, you yourself cross
over to the camp of the orators. But listen
to what your same favourite orator says :
" Let us have no more commonplaces : we
get them at home."
C. There is no eloquence in this, no bom-
bast like that of the orators, who might be de-
fined as persons whose object is to persuade,
and who frame their language accordingly.
We are seeking unadulterated truth, and use
unsophisticated language. Either the Lord
did not give impossible commands, so that
they are to blame who did not do what was
possible ; or, if what is commanded cannot be
done, then not they who do not things impos-
sible are convicted of unrighteousness, but He
Who commanded things impossible, and that
is an impious statement.
A. I see you are much more disturbed than
is your wont ; so I will not ply you with
arguments. But let me briefly ask what you
think of the well-known passage of the Apostle
when he wrote to the Philippians :' "Not that I have already obtained, or am already made
perfect : but I press on, if so be that I may
apprehend that for which also I was appre-
hended by Christ Jesus. Brethren, I count
not myself to have yet apprehended : but one
thing I do ; forgetting the tilings which are
behind, and stretching forward to the things
which are before, I press on towards the goal
1 Rom. iii. 2}, 24. So R. V. Margin—" To be propitiatory."
* Cic. Lib. iv. Acad. Quzst. J Phil. iii. 12-16.
unto the prize of the high calling of God in
Christ Jesus. Let us, therefore, as many as
be perfect, be thus minded : and if in any-
thing ye are otherwise minded, even this shall
God reveal unto you," and so on ; no doubt you know the rest, which, in my desire to be
brief, I omit. He says that he had not yet ap-
prehended, and was by no means perfect ;
but, like an archer, aimed his arrows at the
mark set up (more expressively called l ffXOiroS in Greek), lest the shaft, turning to one side or
the other, might show the unskilfulness of the archer. He further declares that he
always forgot the past, and ever stretched for- ward to the things in front, thus teaching that
no heed should be paid to the past, but the
future earnestly desired ; so that what to-day
he thought perfect, while he was stretching
forward to better things and things in front,
to-morrow proves to have been imperfect.
And thus at every step, never standing still,
but always running, he shows that to be im- perfect which we men thought perfect, and
teaches that our only perfection and true
righteousness is that which is measured by the
excellence of God. " I press on towards the
goal," he says, " unto the prize of the high
calling of God in Christ Jesus." Oh, blessed Apostle Paul, pardon me, a poor creature who
confess my faults, if I venture to ask a ques- tion. You say that you had not yet obtained,
nor yet apprehended, nor were yet perfect,
and that you always forgot the things behind,
and stretched forward to the things in front,
if by any means you might have part in the
resurrection of the dead, and win the prize of
your high calling. How, then, is it that you
immediately add, " As many therefore as are
perfect, are thus minded " ? (or, let us be thus minded, for the copies vary). And what
mind is it that we have, or are to have?
that we are perfect? that we have appre- hended that which we have not apprehended,
received what we have not received, are per-
fect who are not yet perfect ? What mind
then have we, or rather what mind ought we
to have who are not perfect ? To confess
that we are imperfect, and have not yet ap-
prehended, nor yet obtained, this is true
wisdom in man : know thyself to be imper-
fect ; and, if I may so speak, the perfection
of all who are righteous, so long as they are
in the flesh, is imperfect. Hence we read in
Proverbs:2 "To understand true righteous-
ness." For if there were not also a false
righteousness, the rightousness of God would
never be called true. The Apostle continues :
" and if ye are otherwise minded, God will
also reveal that to you." This sounds strange
1 From <rx«irro/tai, to keep watch.
a Prov. i. 3, Sept.