Nestorius, patriarch of
Constantinople, was bound by ties of close friendship both to Theodoret
and to John, patriarch of Antioch. In August, 430, the western bishops,
under the presidency of the Pope Celestine, assembled in council at
Rome, condemned Nestorius, and threatened him with excommunication.
Shortly afterwards a council of Orientals at Alexandria, summoned by
Cyril, endorsed this condemnation and despatched it to Constantinople.
Then John received from Celestine and Cyril letters announcing their
common action. When the couriers conveying these communications reached
Antioch they found John surrounded by Theodoret and other bishops who
were assembled possibly for the ordination of Macarius, the new bishop
of Laodicea. John took counsel with his brother bishops, and a letter
was despatched in their common name to Nestorius, exhorting him to
accept the term θεοτόκος, round which the whole war waged; pointing out the sense in
which it could not but be accepted by every loyal Christian, and
imploring him not to embroil Christendom for a word. This letter has
been generally attributed to Theodoret. But while the conciliatory sage
of Cyrus was endeavouring to formulate an Eirenicon, the ardent
Egyptian made peace almost impossible by the publication of his famous
anathematisms. John and his friends were distressed at the apparent
unorthodoxy of Cyril’s condemnation of Nestorius, and asked
Theodoret to refute Cyril. Vide
the Anathematisms and Theodoret’s refutation in the
Prolegomena. The strong language
employed in Letter CL. conveys an idea of the heat of the enthusiasm
with which Theodoret entered on the task, and his profound conviction
that Cyril, in blind zeal against imaginary error on the part of
Nestorius, was himself falling headlong into the Apollinarian pit. An
eager war of words now waged over Nestorius between Cyril and
Theodoret, each denouncing the other for supposed heresy on the subject
of the incarnation; and, with deep respect for the learning and motives
of Theodoret, we may probably find a solution of much that he said and
did in the fact that he misunderstood Nestorius as completely as he did
Cyril. cf.
Glubokowski p. 98. Cyril, nursed in the synthetic principles of
the Alexandrian school, could see only the unity of the two natures in
the one Person. To him, to distinguish, as the analysis of Theodoret
distinguished, between God the Word and Christ the Man, was to come
perilously near a recognition of two Christs, keeping up as it were a
mutual dialogue of speech and action. But Cyril’s unqualified
assertion that there is one Christ, and that Christ is God, really gave
no ground for the accusation that to him the manhood was an unreality.
Yet he and Theodoret were substantially at one. Theodoret’s
failure to apprehend Cyril’s drift was no doubt due less to any
want of intelligence on the part of the Syrian than to the overbearing
bitterness of the fierce Egyptian.