But he says, “Not dividing
His own essence by begetting, and being at once begetter and begotten,
at the same time Father and Son; for He is incorruptible.” Most
cogent conclusion! What do you mean, most sapient sir? Because He is
incorruptible, therefore He does not divide His own essence by
begetting the Son: nor does He beget Himself or be begotten of Himself,
nor become at the same time His own Father and His own Son because He
is incorruptible. It follows then, that if any one is of corruptible
nature he divides his essence by begetting, and is begotten by himself,
and begets himself, and is his own father and his own son, because he
is not incorruptible. If this is so, then Abraham, because he was
corruptible, did not beget Ishmael and Isaac, but begat himself by the
bondwoman and by his lawful wife or, to take the other mountebank
tricks of the argument, he divided his essence among the sons who were
begotten of him, and first, when Hagar bore him a son, he was divided
into two sections, and in one of the halves became Ishmael, while in
the other he remained half Abraham; and subsequently the residue of the
essence of Abraham being again divided took subsistence in Isaac.
Accordingly the fourth part of the essence of Abraham was divided into
the twin sons of Isaac, so that there was an eighth in each of his
grandchildren! How could one subdivide the eighth part, cutting it
small in fractions among the twelve Patriarchs, or among the threescore
and fifteen souls with whom Jacob went down into Egypt? And why do I
talk thus when I really ought to confute the folly of such notions by
beginning with the first man? For if it is a property of the
incorruptible only not to divide its essence in begetting, and if Adam
was corruptible, to whom the word was spoken, “Dust thou art and
unto dust shalt thou return Gen. iii. 19.,” then,
according to Eunomius’ reasoning, he certainly divided his
essence, being cut up among those who were begotten of him, and by
reason of the vast number of his posterity (the slice of his essence
which is to be found in each being necessarily subdivided according to
the number of his progeny), the essence of Adam is used up before
Abraham began to subsist, being dispersed in these minute and
infinitesimal particles among the countless myriads of his descendants,
and the minute fragment of Adam that has reached Abraham and his
descendants by a process of division, is no longer discoverable in them
as a remnant of his essence, inasmuch as his nature has been already
used up among the countless myriads of those who were before them by
its division into infinitesimal fractions. Mark the folly of him who
“understands neither what he says nor whereof he affirms Cf. 1 Tim. i. 7.” For by saying “Since He is
incorruptible” He neither divides His essence nor begets Himself
nor becomes His own father, he implicitly lays it down that we must
suppose all those things from which he affirms that the incorruptible
alone are free to be incidental to generation in the case of every one
who is subject to corruption. Though there are many other
considerations capable of proving the inanity of his argument, I think
that what has been said above is sufficient to demonstrate its
absurdity. But this has surely been already acknowledged by all who
have an eye for logical consistency, that, when he asserted
incorruptibility of the Father alone, he places all things which are
considered after the Father in the category of corruptible, by virtue
of opposition to the incorruptible, so as to make out even the Son not
to be free from corruption. If then he places the Son in opposition to
the incorruptible, he not only defines Him to be corruptible, but also
asserts of Him all those incidents from which he affirms only the
incorruptible to be exempt. For it necessarily follows that, if the
Father alone neither begets Himself nor is begotten of Himself,
everything which is not incorruptible both begets itself and is begotten of
itself, and becomes its own father and son, shifting from its own
proper essence to each of these relations. For if to be incorruptible
belongs to the Father alone, and if not to be the things specified is a
special property of the incorruptible, then, of course, according to
this heretical argument, the Son is not incorruptible, and all these
circumstances of course, find place about Him,—to have His
essence divided, to beget Himself and to be begotten by Himself, to
become Himself His own father and His own son.