[85.] Holy Pope Celestine also expresses himself
in like manner and to the same effect. For in the Epistle which he
wrote to the priests of Gaul, charging them with connivance with error,
in that by their silence they failed in their duty to the ancient
faith, and allowed profane novelties to spring up, he says: “We
are deservedly to blame if we encourage error by silence. Therefore
rebuke these people. Restrain their liberty of preaching.” But
here some one may doubt who they are whose liberty to preach as they
list he forbids,—the preachers of antiquity or the devisers of
novelty. Let himself tell us; let himself resolve the reader’s
doubt. For he goes on: “If the case be so (that is, if the case
be so as certain persons complain to me touching your cities and
provinces, that by your hurtful dissimulation you cause them to consent
to certain novelties), if the case be so, let novelty cease to assail
antiquity.” This, then, was the sentence of blessed Celestine,
not that antiquity should cease to subvert novelty, but that novelty
should cease to assail antiquity. Celestine’s
letter will be found in the appendix to Vol. x., Part II., of St.
Augustine’s Works, col. 2403, Paris 1838. See the remarks on
Vincentius’s mode of dealing with Celestine’s letter,
Appendix III.