The Epistle of Cyril to Nestorius with the XII. Anathematisms.
(Labbe and Cossart, Concilia, Tom. III., col. 395; Migne, Patr. Græc., Tom. LXXVII.
[Cyril, Opera, Tom. X.], col. 105 et seqq.)
To the most reverend and God-loving fellow-minister Nestorius, Cyril and the synod
assembled in Alexandria, of the Egyptian Province, Greeting in the Lord.
When our Saviour says clearly: “He that loveth father or mother more than me is not
worthy of me: and he that loveth son or daughter more than me is not worthy of me,” what
is to become of us, from whom your Holiness requires that we love you more than Christ
the Saviour of us all? Who can help us in the day of judgment, or what kind of excuse shall
we find for thus keeping silence so long, with regard to the blasphemies made by you against
him? If you injured yourself alone, by teaching and holding such things, perhaps it would
be less matter; but you have greatly scandalized the whole Church, and have cast among the
people the leaven of a strange and new heresy. And not to those there [i.e. at Constantinople]
only; but also to those everywhere [the books of your explanation were sent]. How can we
any longer, under these circumstances, make a defence for our silence, or how shall we not
be forced to remember that Christ said: “Think not that I am come to send peace on earth:
I came not to send peace, but a sword. For I am come to set a man at variance against his
father, and the daughter against her mother.” For if faith be injured, let there be lost the
honour due to parents, as stale and tottering, let even the law of tender love towards children
and brothers be silenced, let death be better to the pious than living; “that they might obtain
a better resurrection,” as it is written.
Behold, therefore, how we, together with the holy synod which met in great Rome,
presided over by the most holy and most reverend brother and fellow-minister, Celestine
the Bishop, also testify by this third letter to you, and counsel you to abstain from these
mischievous and distorted dogmas, which you hold and teach, and to receive the right faith,
handed down to the churches from the beginning through the holy Apostles and Evangelists,
who “were eye-witnesses, and ministers of the Word.” And if your holiness have not a mind
to this according to the limits defined in the writings of our brother of blessed memory and
most reverend fellow-minister Celestine, Bishop of the Church of Rome, be well assured
then that you have no lot with us, nor place or standing (λόγον) among the priests and
bishops of God. For it is not possible for us to overlook the churches thus troubled, and the
people scandalized, and the right faith set aside, and the sheep scattered by you, who ought
to save them, if indeed we are ourselves adherents of the right faith, and followers of the
devotion of the holy fathers. And we are in communion with all those laymen and clergymen
cast out or deposed by your holiness on account of the faith; for it is not right that those,
who resolved to believe rightly, should suffer by your choice; for they do well in opposing
you. This very thing you have mentioned in your epistle written to our most holy and fellow-
bishop Celestine of great Rome.
The Epistle of Cyril to Nestorius with the XII. Anathematisms.
385
The Epistle of Cyril to Nestorius with the XII. Anathematisms.