11. O. If you remember what has been said you would know
that you have been already answered; but in yielding to the love of
contradiction you have wandered from the subject, like those persons
who are talkative rather than eloquent, and who, when they cannot
argue, still continue to wrangle. On the present occasion it is not my
aim to either accuse or defend the Arians, but rather to get safely
past the turning-post of the race, and to maintain that we receive a
bishop for the same reason that you receive a layman. If you grant
forgiveness to the erring, I too pardon the penitent. If he that
baptizes a person into our belief has had no injurious effect upon the
person baptized, it follows that he who consecrates a bishop in the
same faith causes no defilement to the person consecrated. Heresy is
subtle, and therefore the simple-minded are easily deceived. To be
deceived is the common lot of both layman and bishop. But you say, a
bishop could not have been mistaken. The truth is, men are elected to
the episcopate who come from the bosom of Plato and Aristophanes. How
many can you find among them who are not fully instructed in these
writers? Indeed all, whoever they may be, that are ordained at the
present day from among the literate class make it their study not how
to seek out the marrow of Scripture, but how to tickle the ears of the
people with the flowers of rhetoric. We must further add that the Arian
heresy goes hand in hand with the wisdom of the world, and “The
philosophical relations of Arianism have been differently stated. Baur,
Newman (The Arians, p. 17), and others, bring it into connection with
Aristotle, and Athanasianism with Plato; Petavius, Ritter, and Voigt,
on the contrary, derive the Arian idea of God from Platonism and
Neo-Platonism. The empirical, rational, logical tendency of Arianism is
certainly more Aristotelian than Platonic, and so far Baur and Newman
are right; but all depends on making either revelation and faith, or
philosophy and reason, the starting point and ruling power of
theology.” Doctor Schaff in Dict. of Chris. Biog. borrows its streams of argument from the
fountains of Aristotle. And so we will act like children when they try
to outdo one another—whatever you say I will say: what you
assert, I will assert: whatever you deny, I will deny. We allow that an
Arian may baptize; then he must be a bishop. Baptism was at this
time, as a rule, administered by the bishop alone.
If we agree that Arian baptism is invalid, you must reject the layman,
and I must not accept the bishop. I will follow you wherever you go; we
shall either stick in the mud together, or shall get out together.