88. This being the reason why I was sent away
into Gaul, who, I ask again, does not plainly perceive the intention of
the Emperor, and the murderous spirit of Eusebius and his fellows, and
that the Emperor had done this in order to prevent their forming some
more desperate scheme? for he listened to them in simplicity ἐπήκουσε γὰρ
ἁπλῶς. Montfaucon in
Onomast. (Athan. t. 2. ad calc.) points out some passages in his
author, where ἐπακούειν, like ὑπακούειν, means “to answer.” vid. Apol. Const.
§16 init. Orat. iii. 27 fin.. Such were the practices of Eusebius and his
fellows, and such their machinations against me. Who that has witnessed
them will deny that nothing has been done in my favour out of
partiality, but that that great number of Bishops both individually and
collectively wrote as they did in my behalf and condemned the falsehood
of my enemies justly, and in accordance with the truth? Who that has
observed such proceedings as these will deny that Valens and Ursacius
had good reason to condemn themselves, and to write Cf.
§58.
as they did, to accuse themselves when they repented, choosing rather
to suffer shame for a short time, than to undergo the punishment of
false accusers for ever and ever Here
ends the second part of the Apology, as is evident by turning back to
§58. (supr. p. 130) to which this paragraph is an allusion. The
express object of the second part was to prove, what has now been
proved by documents, that Valens and Ursacius did but succumb to plain
facts which they could not resist. It is observable too from this
passage that the Apology was written before their relapse, i.e. before
a.d. 351 or 352. The remaining two sections
are often after 357, as they mention the fall of Liberius and Hosius,
and speak of Constantius in different language from any which has been
found above. [Introd. to Apol. Const. and Hist.
Ar.]?