CIV. To
Flavianus,
1828
Bishop of Constantinople.
I have already in another letter
informed your holiness how openly the calumniators of our teaching are
slandering us.
1829
Now in like
manner by means of the very godly bishops I do the same, having not
only these as witnesses of the orthodoxy of my teaching but also
countless other men who are my hearers in the churches of the East.
Above and beyond all these I have my conscience, and Him who sees my
conscience. And I know too how the divine Apostle often appealed to the
testimony of his conscience, for “our rejoicing is this, the
testimony of our conscience”
1830
and again
“I say the truth in Christ I lie not, my conscience also bearing
me witness in the Holy Ghost.”
1831
Know
then, O holy and godly sir, that no one has ever at any time heard us
preaching two sons; in fact this doctrine seems to me abominable and
impious, for there is one Lord Jesus Christ through whom are all
things. Him I acknowledge both as everlasting God and as man in the end
of days, and I give Him one worship as only begotten. I have learned
however the distinction between flesh and Godhead, for the union is
unconfounded. Thus drawn up as it were in battle array to oppose the
madness of Arius and Eunomius, we very easily refute the blasphemy
hazarded by them against the only begotten, by applying what was spoken
in humility about the Lord, and suitably to
His assumed nature, to man,
and, on the other hand, what becomes the divine and signifies the
divine nature, to God; not dividing Him into two persons, but teaching
that both the former and latter attributes belong to the only begotten,
the latter to Him as God the Creator and Lord of all, and the former as
made man on our account. For divine Scripture says that He was made
man, not by mutation of the Godhead, but by assumption of human nature,
of the seed of Abraham. This the divine Apostle openly says in the
words “For verily He took not on Him the nature of angels, but He
took on Him the seed of Abraham, wherefore in all things it behoved Him
to be made like unto His brethren.”
1832
And again “Now to Abraham and
his seed were the promises made: he saith not and to seeds, as of many;
but as of one, and to thy seed, which is Christ.”
1833
These and similar passages have
been cut out of divine Scripture by Simon, Basilides, Valentinus,
Bardesanes, Marcion, and the man who is named after his maniacal
heresy.
1834
So they style the Master Christ
God only, and describe Him as having nothing human about Him, but
appearing in imagination and appearance as man to men. On the other
hand the Arians and Eunomians say that God the Word assumed only a
body, and that He Himself supplied the place of a soul in the body. And
Apollinarius describes the Master’s body as endued with a soul;
1835
but, deriving, I know not whence, the
idea of a distinction between soul and intelligence,
1836
deprives intelligence of its share in
the achieved salvation.
1837
The teaching
of the divine Apostles lays down on the contrary that a soul both
reasonable and intelligent was assumed together with flesh, and the
salvation of which the hope is held out to them that believe is
complete.
There is yet another gang of
heretics who hold differently. Photinus,
1838
Marcellus,
1839
and Paul of Samosata,
1840
assert that our Lord and God was only
man. When arguing with these we are under the necessity of advancing
proofs of the Godhead, and of shewing that the Master Christ is
everlasting God. When, on the other hand, we are contending with the
former faction, which calls our Lord Jesus Christ God only, we are
obliged to marshal against them the forces of the divine Scripture, and
collect from it evidence of the assumption of the manhood. For a
physician must use remedies appropriate to the disease, and suit the
medicine to the case.
Now, therefore, I beseech your
holiness to scatter the slander raised against me, and bridle the
tongues now vainly reviling me. For, after the incarnation, I worship
one Son of God, one Lord Jesus Christ, and denounce as impious all who
hold otherwise. Deign, sir, to give me too your holy prayers, that, by
God’s grace, I may reach the other side of the ocean of danger,
and drop my anchor in the windless haven of the Lord.
1828
Cf. Letters XI. and LXXXVI. This letter may probably be placed
between the sentence of
internement
and the assembling of the
Latrocinium.
1829
Compare Letter LXXXVI.
1830
2 Cor. i. 12
1831
Rom. ix. 1
1832
Heb. ii. 16,
17
1833
Gal. iii. 16
1834
i.e. Manes.
1835
᾽έμψυχον
1836
ψυχή
and
νοῦς
1837
cf. pp. 132 and 140.
1838
Disciple of Marcellus. cf. Soc. ii. 30. Theodoret, in his
interpretation of the Ep. to the Hebrews, links him with Sabellius.
(Ed. Migne. iii. 547.)
1839
cf. p. 139.
1840
Patriarch of Antioch 260–270. Bp. Wordsworth calls him
“the Socinus of the 3rd c.” Samosata (Samsat) was capital
of the Commagene in Syria.