TO PAMMACHIUS AGAINST JOHN OF JERUSALEM. 437
the shape of stalk, leaves, and ear ; and thus,
while it is one thing when it dies, it is an-
other thing when it rises from the dead ; for in
the grain of wheat, roots, stalk, leaves, ears,
trunk are as yet unseparated. In the same
manner, in human bodies, according to the
law of their being, certain original principles
remain which ensure their resurrection, and a
sort of marrow, that is a seed-plot of the dead, is fostered in the bosom of the earth. But
when the day of judgment shall have come,
and at the voice of the archangel, and the
sound of the last trumpet, the earth shall
totter, immediately the seeds will be instinct
with life, and in a moment of time will cause
the dead to burst into life ; yet the flesh which
they will reconstitute will not be the same
flesh, nor will it be in the old forms. To give
you the assurance that we speak the truth, let
me quote the words of the Apostle : ' ' But some one says, How shall the dead rise ? and
with what body will they come ? Thou fool,
that which thou sowest, thou sowest not that
body which shall be, but a bare grain, it may
be of wheat, or the seed of a vine and a tree.' And as we have already made the grain of
wheat, and to some extent the planting of
trees, the subject of our reasoning, let us now
take the grape-stone as an example. It is a
mere granule, so small that you can scarcely
hold it between your two fingers. Where are
the roots ? where the tortuous interlacing of
roots, of trunk and off-shoots ? where the shade
of the leaves, and the lovely clusters teeming
with coining wine ? What you have in your
fingers is parched and scarcely discernible ;
nevertheless, in that dry granule, by the power
of God and the secret law of propagation, the
foaming new wine must have its origin. You
will allow all this in the case of a tree ; will
you not admit such things to be possible in the
case of a man ? The plant which perishes is
thus decked with beauty ; why should we
think that man, who abides, will receive back
his former meanness ? Do you demand that
there should be flesh, bones, blood, limbs, so
that you must have the barber to cut your
hair, that your nose may run, your nails must
be trimmed, your lower parts may gender filth
or minister to lust ? If you introduce these
foolish and gross notions, you forget what is
told us of the flesh, namely, that in it we can-
not please God, and that it is an enemy ; you
forget, also, what is told us of the resurrec-
tion of the dead : s ' It is sown in corruption, it shall rise in incorruption. It is sown in dis-
honour, it shall rise in glory. It is sown in
weakness, it shall rise in power. It is sown a
natural body, it shall rise a spiritual body.'
Now we see with our eyes, hear with our
ears, act with our hands, walk with our feet.
But in that spiritual body we shall be all
sight, all hearing, all action, all movement.
The Lord shall transfigure1 the body of our humiliation and fashion it according to His
own glorious body. In saying transfigure
he affirms identity with the members which
we now have. But a different body, spiritual
and ethereal, is promised to us, which is
neither tangible, nor perceptible to the eye,
nor ponderable ; and the change it under-
goes will be suitable to the difference in its
future abode. Otherwise, if there is to be
the same flesh and if our bodies are to be
the same, there will again be males and
females, there will again be marriage ; men
will have the shaggy eyebrow and the flowing
beard ; women will have their smooth cheeks
and narrow chests, and their bodies must
adapt themselves to conception and parturi- tion. Even tiny infants will rise again ; old
men will also rise ; the former to be nursed,
the latter to be supported by the staff. And,
simple ones, be not deceived by the resur- rection of our Lord, because He showed His
side and His hands, stood on the shore, went
for a walk with Cleophas, and said that He
had flesh and bones. That body, because it
was not born of the seed of man and the pleas-
ure of the flesh, has its peculiar preroga-
tives. He ate and drank after His resurrec-
tion, and appeared in clothing, and allowed
Himself to be touched, that He might make
His doubting Apostles believe in His resur- rection. But still He does not fail to manifest
the nature of an aerial and spiritual body.
For He enters when the doors are shut, and
in the breaking of bread vanishes out of sight.
Does it follow then that after our resurrec-
I tion we shall eat and drink, and perform the
offices of nature ? If so, what becomes of the
promise,8 'The mortal must put on im-
mortality.' " 27. Here we have the complete explanation' ! of the fact that in your exposition of the faith,
to deceive the ears of the ignorant, you nine
times make mention of the body, and not even
once of the flesh, and all the while men think
that you confess the body of flesh, and that
the flesh is identical with the body. If it is
the same as the body, it means nothing dif-
ferent. I say this, for I know your answer :
" I thought the body was the same as the
flesh ; I spoke with all simplicity." Why do you not rather call it flesh to signify the body,
and speak indifferently at one time of the flesh,
at another of the body, that the body may be
shown to consist of flesh, and the flesh to be
1 i Cor. xv. 35, 37. 1 i Cor. xv; 42, 44. 1 Phil. iii. 21. * i Cor. xv. 53.