saving faith.—Certainly the eunuch in making answer to Philip’s inquiry, had no need to
look at any more than Philip inquired after. In p. 50. a. he says, “It does not seem at all
probable, that Philip inquired any thing about the regeneration or sanctification of the eu-
nuch.“ And yet in the next preceding sentence, he refers me over to another judgment, for
representing as though my opposers supposed, that it was no matter whether a person
coming to gospel-ordinances had any grace or not, and had no manner of need to inquire
any thing about his sincerity.
And though he highly blames me for insinuating, as above, that my opposers require a
pretence of no more than common grace and moral sincerity; yet in opposition to my insist-
ing on a profession of saving faith, speaking of the profession which the apostles required,
he says, (p. 58. c.) “It is certain, that a profession in these words, which was wont to be re-
quired, do sometimes import no more than a conviction of the understanding on moral
evidence.” So he says concerning those whose admission into the christian church we have
an account of in Acts ii. (p. 45. e.) “There is not one word said about any other faith, but
believing that Jesus was the Messiah.“ And if so, then certainly no more was professed.
In p. 35. e. he allows, that all visible saints who are not truly pious, are hypocrites; and
yet maintains, that the profession they make is no more than what they may make and speak
honestly and truly. (p. 105. d. and 47. c.) How then are they all hypocrites, if they are honestly
and truly what they profess to be?
In supporting the argument from John’s baptism, he insists, that the profession the
people made, did not imply, that they had savingly repented: and that John openly supposed,
that their profession did not imply it, in what he said to them. (p. 97. a. b. c.)—And (p. 98.
a. b.) he says, “We read not a word of John’s inquiring whether these people made a credible
profession of true piety.” And he there manifestly suggests, that John knew they were not
pious, as he knew they were a generation of vipers. Yet how often elsewhere does Mr. W. insist,
that men in order to come to sacraments must make a credible profession of true piety and
gospel-holiness, and that they must in a judgment of charity be supposed to have real god-
liness?
In answer to my argument from the instance of the converts in Acts ii. Mr. W. speaking
of their convictions, and being pricked in their hearts, (p. 45. c. d. e.) says, “They were con-
vinced that Jesus was the true Messiah and Saviour, whom God had promised to Is-
rael,—whereupon convinced of their sin, they cry out, What shall we do? To which the
apostles reply, Repent and be baptized,—in the name of the Lord Jesus Christ for the remission
of sins.—There is not one word said about any other faith, but believing that Jesus was the
Messiah.“—And in the two next pages Mr. W. insists, that their gladly receiving the word
can by no necessity from the text imply more, than that they now believed that Jesus was
the Messiah, and that it was matter of joy to them that the Messiah was come.—So that we
have this inconsistent account of the matter from Mr. W. that these people are first convinced
1996
SECTION IX. Mr. W. is inconsistent with himself.