8. οἱμαθηταί ] Judas alone is mentioned, John 12:4. It may have been that some were found ready to second his remark, but that John, from his peculiar position at the table,—if, as is probable, the same as in John 13:23,—may not have observed it. If so, the independent origin of the two accounts is even more strikingly shewn.
ἀπώλεια ] Bengel remarks, ‘Immo tu, Juda, perditionis es ( ὁυἱὸςτῆςἀπωλείας, John 17:12).’