2. It is charged against me that I have sometimes
praised Origen. If I am not mistaken I have only done so in two places,
in the short preface (addressed to Damasus) to his homilies on the Song
of Songs and in the prologue to my book of Hebrew Names. In these
passages do the dogmas of the church come into question? Is anything
said of the Father, the Son, and the Holy Ghost? or of the resurrection
of the flesh? or of the condition and material of the soul? I have
merely praised the simplicity of his rendering and commentary and
neither the faith nor the dogmas of the Church come in at all. Ethics
only are dealt with and the mist of allegory is dispelled by a clear
explanation. I have praised the commentator but not the theologian, the
man of intellect but not the believer, the philosopher but not the
apostle. But if men wish to know my real judgement upon Origen; let
them read my commentaries upon Ecclesiastes, let them go through my
three books upon the epistle to the Ephesians: they will then see that
I have always opposed his doctrines. How foolish it would be to
eulogize a system so far as to endorse its blasphemy! The blessed
Cyprian takes Tertullian for his master, as his writings prove; yet,
delighted as he is with the ability of this learned and zealous writer
he does not join him in following Montanus and Maximilla. Of these the two
founders of Montanism the first was a Phrygian of the second century
who professed to be the special organ of the Holy Ghost while the
second was a female disciple who claimed to exercise the gift of
prophecy in furtherance of his aims. Apollinaris is the author of a most
weighty book against Porphyry, and Eusebius has composed a fine history
of the Church; yet of these the former has mutilated Christ’s
incarnate humanity, Dimidiatam Christi
introduxit œconomiam. Apollinaris taught that in Christ the divine
personality supplied the place of a human soul. In his view, therefore,
Christ ceased to be “very man.” while the latter
is the most open champion of the Arian impiety. Eusebius, although
he sided with the Arians, always claimed to be orthodox. However, as
Newman says, “his acts are his confession.”
“Woe,” says Isaiah, “unto them that call evil good
and good evil; that put bitter for sweet and sweet for bitter.” Isa. v. 20. We must not detract from the virtues of our
opponents—if they have any praiseworthy qualities—but
neither must we praise the defects of our friends. Each several case
must be judged on its own merits and not by a reference to the persons
concerned. While Lucilius is rightly assailed by Horace Hor. S. 1. x.
1–4. for the unevenness of his verses, he is
equally rightly praised for his wit and his charming style.