4. There is an entire lack of genuine analytical
criticism; the love of allegory (i. 1, ii. 1), the credence given to
the Christic sections of Josephus (i. 1), the unquestioning acceptance
of Eusebius’ turgid statements about Constantine’s life,
are proofs enough of its absence; and yet Sozomen was careful to
present the variety of accounts, so that one might have all points of
view, if he did not carefully sift the evidence. This is indeed quite a
marked feature of his method. Thus concerning the death of Arius, he
gives five different views (ii. 29, 30). He states carefully the
varying shades of opinion concerning Marcellus (ii. 33). The two
classes of views of the election of Macedonius are recorded and
skillfully weighed (iii. 3). The divisions of sentiment after the
Synods of Sardica and Philippopolis are accurately grouped (iii. 13).
Other instances occur in iii. 14, 18, 23, v. 2, 22, vi. 2, 12, 26, vii.
5, 22. These are but a selection of what is habitual with him, and show
a desire to present all sides of a question, and to reflect the
divergent convictions of his time about men and measures; but he does
not always try to find the just opinion and weigh the testimony; he
never tests the validity of his documents, and only a few times tries
to decide between clashing judgments, as to which of them rests on a
solid foundation of testimony. It is, however, to his credit, when he
confesses that his research is baffled, as in iv. 2, with respect to
the manner of Paul’s death, or suspends his judgment, because the
data are insufficient, as in the application to the empress, of
Chrysostom’s homily on female peccadilloes (viii. 6). Such
language shows that he not only sought to ascertain the truth, but to
elicit the facts out of conflicting testimony. We may not always think
the game worth the powder, but the temper and intent are
commendable.