In the main Jerome’s
defence was valid. But it demanded considerateness in his judges; and
this quality was absent in himself. He judged Origen’s opinions
harshly, and spoke of his views as poisonous (Letter lxxxiv, 3); and,
when we contrast the lenity of his former judgments on the same points
with his present violence, it becomes evident that he was more
concerned for his own reputation than for truth. Rufinus charges him
(Apol. i. c. 23 to 44) with maintaining, in his Commentaries on the
Ephesians (written twelve years earlier in 388) to which Jerome had
appealed (Ep. lxxxiv, 2) the views which he now denounced; and the
charge, though urged too far, is substantially made out. The opinions
of Origen which he introduced into this Commentary about the fall of
souls out of a previous state of bliss into human bodies are set down
with hardly a word of objection (comm. on ch. i, v. 4), and his
speculations on the Powers and Principalities of the world to come (ib.
v. 21) and on the rise of Lucifer and his angels to be subjects of
Christ’s Kingdom (id. ii, 7) and their part in the final
restoration of all things (id. iv, 16) are adopted as his own, thus
giving some justification for Rufinus’ attack (Apol. i,
34–36. &c.). His defence of himself therefore is hardly
candid. And his allusions to his opponent are exasperating, e.g. when
he speaks (Letter lxxxiv, 1) of some persons “who love me so well
that they cannot be heretics without me.” “I wonder that,
while they speak in detraction of the flesh, they live carnally and
thus cherish and nourish delicately their enemy” (Id. 8). He
hardly argues fairly as to Rufinus’ assertion that Origen’s
works had suffered from falsification: and he is carried so far by his
animosity that he denies the Apology of Pamphilus for Origen to be by
Pamphilus, though he had himself attributed it to him (De Vir. Ill. c.
7. 5) and no one can doubt that it is his. (See Dict. of Christ. Biog.
Art. Pamphilus.)