5. But you say “the bishop of Alexandria approved
of my letter.” What did he approve of? Your correct utterances
against Arius, Photinus, and Manichæus. For who, at this time of
day, accuses you of being an Arian? Who now fastens on you the guilt of
Photinus and Manichæus? Those faults were long ago corrected,
those enemies were shattered. You were not so foolish as to openly
defend a heresy which you knew was offensive to the whole Church. You
knew that if you had done this, you must have been immediately removed,
and your heart was upon the pleasures of your episcopal throne. You so
tuned your expressions as to neither displease the simple, nor offend
your own incontestably marked by deceit and slipperiness; what, then,
are we to do with the remaining five, with regard to which, because no
opportunity was afforded for ambiguity, supporters. You wrote well, but
nothing to the purpose. How was the bishop of Alexandria to know of
what you were accused, or what things they were of which a confession
was demanded from you? You ought to have set forth in detail the
charges brought against you, and then have met them one by one. There
is an old story which tells how a certain man, who, when he was
speaking fluently, was carried along by a torrent of words, without
touching the question before the court, and thus drew the wise remark
from the judge, “Excellent! excellent! but to what purpose is all
this excellence?” Quacks have but one lotion for all affections
of the eyes. He who is accused of many things, and in dissipating the
charges passes over some, confesses all that he omits to mention. Did
you not reply to the letter of Epiphanius, and yourself choose the
points for refutation? No doubt, in replying, you rested on the axiom,
that no man is so brave as to put the sword to his own throat. Choose
which alternative you like. You shall have your choice: you either
replied to the letter of Epiphanius, or you did not. If you did reply,
why did you take no notice of the most important, and the most
numerous, of the charges brought against you? If you did not reply,
what becomes of your “Apology,” of which you boast amongst
the simple, and which you are scattering broadcast amongst those who do
not understand the matter?