189
prophet testifies, before all ages798? See you not what confusion you bring upon the matter,
turning, as the phrase goes, things upside down? It was the fiftieth day after the Passion,
when Peter preached his sermon to the Jews and said, “Him Whom ye crucified, God made
Christ and Lord.” Do you not mark the order of his saying? which stands first, which second
in his words? He did not say, “Him Whom God made Lord, ye crucified,” but, “Whom ye
crucified, Him God made Christ and Lord”: so that it is clear from this that Peter is speaking,
not of what was before the ages, but of what was after the dispensation.
How comes it, then, that you fail to see that the whole conception of your argument on
the subject is being overthrown, and go on making yourself ridiculous with your childish
web of sophistry, saying that, if we believe that He who was apparent to the senses has been
made by God to be Christ and Lord, it necessarily follows that the Lord once more “emptied
Himself” anew to become Man, and underwent a second birth? What advantage does your
doctrine get from this? How does what you say show the King of creation to be created? For
my own part I assert on the other side that our view is supported by those who contend
against us, and that the rhetorician, in his exceeding attention to the matter, has failed to
see that in pushing, as he supposed, the argument to an absurdity, he is fighting on the side
of those whom he attacks, with the very weapons he uses for their overthrow. For if we are
to believe that the change of condition in the case of Jesus was from a lofty state to a lowly
one, and if the Divine and uncreated Nature alone transcends the creation, he will, perhaps,
when he thoroughly surveys his own argument, come over to the ranks of truth, and agree
that the Uncreated came to be in the created, in His love for man. But if he imagines that
he demonstrates the created character of the Lord by showing that He, being God, took part
in human nature, he will find many such passages to establish the same opinion which carry
out their support of his argument in a similar way. For since He was the Word and was God,
and “afterwards,” as the prophet says, “was seen upon earth and conversed with men799,”
He will hereby be proved to be one of the creatures! And if this is held to be beside the
question, similar passages too are not quite akin to the subject. For in sense it is just the
same to say that the Word that was in the beginning was manifested to men through the
flesh, and to say that being in the form of God He put on the form of a servant: and if one
of these statements gives no help for the establishment of his blasphemy, he must needs give
up the remaining one also. He is kind enough, however, to advise us to abandon our error,
and to point out the truth which He himself maintains. He tells us that the Apostle Peter
declares Him to have been made Who was in the beginning the Word and God. Well, if he
were making up dreams for our amusement, and giving us information about the prophetic
interpretation of the visions of sleep, there might be no risk in allowing him to set forth the
798 Ps. lxxiv. 12 (LXX.).
799 Bar. iii. 37.
363
Then returning to the words of Peter, “God made Him Lord and Christ,” he…