Chapter XXXV.
And let any one who peruses the treatise of Celsus observe whether it does not convey
some such insinuation as the above, when he says: “And they attempted to derive their
origin from the first race of jugglers and deceivers, appealing to the testimony of dark and
ambiguous words, whose meaning was veiled in obscurity.” For these names are indeed
obscure, and not within the comprehension and knowledge of many, though not in our
opinion of doubtful meaning, even although assumed by those who are aliens to our religion;
but as, according to Celsus, they do not 3834 convey any ambiguity, I am at a loss to know
why he has rejected them. And yet, if he had wished honestly to overturn the genealogy
which he deemed the Jews to have so shamelessly arrogated, in boasting of Abraham and
his descendants (as their progenitors), he ought to have quoted all the passages bearing on
the subject; and, in the first place, to have advocated his cause with such arguments as he
thought likely to be convincing, and in the next to have bravely 3835 refuted, by means of
what appeared to him to be the true meaning, and by arguments in its favour, the errors
existing on the subject. But neither Celsus nor any one else will be able, by their discussions
regarding the nature of names employed for miraculous purposes, to lay down the correct
doctrine regarding them, and to demonstrate that those men were to be lightly esteemed
whose names merely, not among their countrymen alone, but also amongst foreigners, could
accomplish (such results). He ought to have shown, moreover, how we, in misinterpreting
3836 the passages in which these names are found, deceive our hearers, as he imagines, while
he himself, who boasts that he is not ignorant or unintelligent, gives the true interpretation
513
of them. And he hazarded the assertion, 3837 in speaking of those names, from which the
Jews deduce their genealogies, that “never, during the long antecedent period, has there
been any dispute about these names, but that at the present time the Jews dispute about
them with certain others,” whom he does not mention. Now, let him who chooses show
who these are that dispute with the Jews, and who adduce even probable arguments to show
that Jews and Christians do not decide correctly on the points relating to these names, but
that there are others who have discussed these questions with the greatest learning and ac-
curacy. But we are well assured that none can establish anything of the sort, it being manifest
that these names are derived from the Hebrew language, which is found only among the
Jews.
3834 κατὰ δὲ Κέλσον, οὐ παριστάντα. Libri editi ad oram ὡς παριστάντα.
3835 γενναίως.
3836 παρεξηγούμενοι.
3837 παρέῤῥιψε.
Chapter XXXV
1164
Chapter XXXV