11. Another of your arguments is also intolerable, one
which runs thus: “To be sinless is one thing, to be able to be so
is another. The first is not in our power, the second generally is. For
though none ever has been sinless, yet, if a man wills to be so, he can
be so.” What sort of reasoning, I ask, is this? that a man can be
what a man never has been! that a thing is possible which according to
your own admission, no man has yet achieved! You are predicating of man
a quality which, for aught you know, he may never possess! and you are
assigning to any chance person a grace which you cannot shew to have marked patriarchs, prophets, or
apostles. Listen to the Church’s words, plain as they may seem to
you or crude or ignorant. And speak what you think; preach publicly
what secretly you tell your disciples. You profess to have freedom of
choice; why do you not speak your thoughts freely? Your secret chambers
hear one doctrine, the crowd around the platform hear another. The
uneducated throng, I suppose, is not able to digest your esoteric
teaching. Satisfied with the milk-diet of an infant it cannot take
solid food. cf. 1 Cor. iii. 2.