The following is a summary of the argument: Atticus, the
Augustinian, at once (c. 1) introduces the question: Do you affirm
that, as Pelagius affirms, men can live without sin? Yes, says the
Pelagian Critobulus, but I do not add, as is imputed to us,
“without the grace of God.” Indeed, the fact that we have a
free will is from grace. Yes, replies Atticus, but what is this grace?
Is it only our original nature, or is it needed in every act. In every
act, is the reply (2); yet one would hardly say that we cannot mend a
pen without grace (3), for, if so, where is our free will? But, says
Atticus (5), the Scriptures speak of our need of God’s aid in
everything. In that case, says Critobulus, the promised reward must be
given not to us but to God, Who works in us. Reverting then to the
first point stated, Atticus asks, does the possibility of sinlessness
extend to single acts, or to the whole life? Certainly to the whole as
well as the part, is the answer. But we wish, or will to be sinless;
why then are we not actually sinless? Because (8) we do not exert our
will to the full. But (9) no one has ever lived without sin. Still,
says the Pelagian, God commands us to be perfect, and he does not
command impossibilities. Job, Zacharias, and Elizabeth are represented
as perfectly righteous. No, it is answered (12), faults are attributed
to each of them. John says, “He that is born of God sinneth
not” (13); yet, “If we say we have no sin we deceive
ourselves.” The Apostles, though told to be perfect (14) were not
perfect: and St. Paul says (14a), “I count not myself to have
apprehended.” Men are called just and perfect only in comparison
of others (16), or because of general subjection to the will of God
(18), or according to their special characteristics (19), as we may
speak of a bishop as excellent in his office, though he may not fulfil
the ideal of the pastoral epistles (22).