12. Our position is this: Every only begotten son is a
first-born son, but not every first-born is an only begotten. By
first-born we understand not only one who is succeeded by others, but
one who has had no predecessor. Numb. xviii. 15.“Everything,” says the Lord to
Aaron, “that openeth the womb of all flesh which they offer unto
the Lord, both of man and beast, shall be thine: nevertheless the first
born of man shalt thou surely redeem, and the firstling of unclean
beasts shalt thou redeem.” The word of God defines
first-born as everything that openeth the womb. Otherwise, if
the title belongs to such only as have younger brothers, the priests
cannot claim the firstlings until their successors have been begotten,
lest, perchance, in case there were no subsequent delivery it should
prove to be the first-born but not merely the only begotten. Numb. xviii. 16. “And those that are to be redeemed
of them from a month old shalt thou redeem, according to thine
estimation for the money of five shekels, after the shekel of the
sanctuary (the same is twenty gerahs). But the firstling of an ox, or
the firstling of a sheep, or the firstling of a goat, thou shalt not
redeem; they are holy.” The word of God compels me to dedicate to
God everything that openeth the womb if it be the firstling of clean
beasts: if of unclean beasts, I must redeem it, and give the value to
the priest. I might reply and say, Why do you tie me down to the short
space of a month? Why do you speak of the first-born, when I cannot
tell whether there are brothers to follow? Wait until the second is
born. I owe nothing to the priest, unless the birth of a second should
make the one I previously had the first-born. Will not the very points
of the letters cry out against me and convict me of my folly, and
declare that first-born is a title of him who opens the womb, and is
not to be restricted to him who has brothers? And, then, to take the
case of John: we are agreed that he was an only begotten son: I want to
know if he was not also a first-born son, and whether he was not
absolutely amenable to the law. There can be no doubt in the matter. At
all events Scripture thus speaks of the Saviour, S. Luke ii. 22 sq. “And when the days of her
purification according to the law of Moses were fulfilled, they brought
him up to Jerusalem, to present him to the Lord (as it is written in
the law of the Lord, every male that openeth the womb shall be called
holy to the Lord) and to offer a sacrifice according to that which is
said in the law of the Lord, a pair of turtle-doves, or two young
pigeons.” If this law relates only to the first-born, and there
can be no first-born unless there are successors, no one ought to be
bound by the law of the first-born who cannot tell whether there will
be successors. But inasmuch as he who has no younger brothers is bound
by the law of the first-born, we gather that he is called the
first-born who opens the womb and who has been preceded by none, not he
whose birth is followed by that of a younger brother. Moses writes in
Exodus, Exod. xii. 29. “And it came to pass at
midnight, that the Lord smote all the first-born in the land of Egypt,
from the first-born of Pharaoh that sat on his throne unto the
first-born of the captive that was in the dungeon: And all the
first-born of cattle.” Tell me, were they who then perished by
the destroyer, only your first-born, or, something more, did they
include the only begotten? If only they who have brothers are called
first-born, the only begotten were saved from death. And if it be the
fact that the only begotten were slain, it was contrary to the sentence
pronounced, for the only begotten to die as well as the first-born. You
must either release the only begotten from the penalty, and in that
case you become ridiculous: or, if you allow that they were slain, we
gain our point, though we have not
to thank you for it, that only begotten sons also are called
first-born.