Part II.—Sozomen as
Author.
When
seized with a desire to
write history, Sozomen says: “I at first felt strongly inclined
to trace the course of events from the very commencement, but on
reflecting that similar records of the past, up to their own time, had
been compiled by those wisest of men, Clemens and Hegesippus,
successors of the Apostles, by Africanus, the historian, and by
Eusebius, surnamed Pamphilus, a man intimately acquainted with Sacred
Scriptures and the writings of the Greek
poets and historians, I merely drew up an
epitome in two books, of all that is recorded to have happened to the
churches, from the ascension of Christ to the deposition of
Licinius.” This work is unfortunately lost. It was not a simple
chronicle, but an abbreviated account of these events; the abridgment
was probably from the authors mentioned above. The habit of succinct
narration is quite in his later vein. He doubtless commingled secular
with the sacred detail. It may be suggestingly asked, whether his words
in ix. 1 do not give a hint of another work: “But I willingly for
awhile pass over the many separate manifestations of divine favor, that
were granted to the sister of the emperor, as proofs that she was loved
of God, lest anybody should blame me, for having set out to do other
things, and yet had turned to the use of encomiums.” This sudden
arrest could not be owing to an intended resumption of such matters at
a later portion of the history; for the method was already regarded as
irrelevant, and the very reason for citing no more in that vein; is it
not likely that he at least purposed an encomium of Pulcheria?
The attempt of Hieronymus, Wolf, Lambec, and Fenzel to
ascribe Hermias’
Διασυρμὸς
τῶν ἔξω
φιλοσόφων
(
Irrisio gentilium philosophorum
) to Sozomen, because of
identity of name, is now held by none.
1048
The work by which we know him, is the Ecclesiastical History in nine
Books. When did he write it? In trying to determine the time of its
production, let us look at the data suggested in his work.
(1) In the dedication, the delineation of the
emperor’s culture and character discloses a man of fixity and
repose; these qualities could not be ascribed to the time of his
imperial majority, in his fifteenth year, nor to the time of his
marriage (421); they are rather the features of settled experience;
hence we would expect in general a period nearer the end of his reign,
than one in the beginning or middle; certainly somewhere beyond his
thirtieth year, and therefore beyond
a.d.
438.
(2) Sozomen says that poets and authors, even those of
prefectural dignity, as well as other subjects, celebrated the emperor.
The usual literary incense was burned. Olympiodorus dedicated his
history to him. Socrates was magniloquent; and more particularly did
Cyrus, the friend of Eudocia, who attained the highest offices of the
state from 439–441, write epigrams in praise of his monarch.
1049
This would make a date after 441.
1050
(3) In illustration of the practiced self-control of his
sovereign, he narrates an incident of the royal journey in the summer
heat, through Bithynia, to the fallen city of Heraclea, in Pontus,
1051
with the view of restoring it. This journey took place in June of
a.d.
443.
1052
This incident is introduced with
πρώην
, which would place the
writing quite definitely as not very soon after June 443.
(4) The reign of Theodosius is described as above all
others bloodless and pure from slaughter. This could only be moderately
just, before the judicial murders connected with the jealous fits of
Theodosius, from 442 on, and the united movement of outlying nations
upon the East and West, as projected by the political sagacity of
Attila.
(5) The professed terminus of his history is the
seventeenth consulate of Theodosius: this was the year 439; hence the
whole work was written after that time.
(6) The prayer at the conclusion of the proëmium
may have in it a point of light; he hopes that through the favor of
Christ, the imperium may be transmitted to Theodosius’ sons and
grandsons. The only child born to Eudocia was a daughter, Eudoxia, who
was married to Valentinian III. It was because of the lack of
succession, that Pulcheria married General Marcianus. Eudocia withdrew
from the court somewhere between 441–443, but that would not have
had to impede the succession, had Theodosius chosen to be divorced; and
this prayer rather intimates the desirability of another marriage.
This, therefore, must have been written
before the hope of sons was removed; certainly,
therefore, before the closing years of the emperor’s reign.
(7) In Book ix, Pulcheria’s inclination to
virginity is spoken of as expressed in the most solemn way, and with
the consecrated gift of a table to signalize it. There is no hint in
the work of the marriage with Marcian, suggested by Theodosius on his
death-bed, and carried out after his demise. This would indicate that
the work was completed before 450.
(8) In ix. 1, he affirms: “That new heresies have
not prevailed in our times, we shall find to be due especially to her,
as we shall subsequently see.” The heresies are those connected
with Nestorianism, 428–444, and possibly the return of the
Johannists to full communion by the triumphal restoration of
Chrysostom’s remains in 438; these were to fall within the limits
of his work. The Eutychean heresy in its first stage was hostile to
Pulcheria’s views, while its overthrow was not effected until a
year after the death of Theodosius. The close of the Nestorian
controversy through the compromise was in 444, and that date would suit
well with the fact of mastering the heresy at the very time he was
writing this account of Pulcheria.
(9) In ix. 2, he recounts the transfer of the forty
martyrs, after a public festival had been appropriately celebrated with
fitting honor and pomp, with psalms, “at which I myself was
present; and others who were present can also bear testimony that these
things were done in the way described, for almost all of them still
survive. And the event occurred much later, when Proclus governed the
church of Constantinople.” Proclus was elected 434, and continued
in office until his death in 447. This transfer must have taken place
before 439, the proposed terminus of the history, and very likely a
little while after the accession of this long-tried candidate. The time
of the writing was at some considerable remove from the event itself,
because of his appeal to the survivors as witnesses to the truth of his
portrayal, and yet not so far, but that the most of the participants
and spectators could still be appealed to. This would correspond very
well with the date connected with 443, suggested by the incident in
Bithynia, if we allow some interval between the writing of the
dedication and Book ix.
(10) In ix. 6, the overthrow of Uldis, 406, is narrated.
The settlement of the conquered Sciri as slaves and colonists is
enlarged upon. Sozomen himself saw these imperial farmers at their
tilling in Bithynia. This may connect itself, possibly, as to the time
of the year, and place, with the emperor’s progress to Heraclea
Pontica. There is evidently an interval between the capture of the
Sciri, and their settled work as colonists, when Sozomen visited that
region, and between that visit and the writing of the fact. If it
corresponded with the imperial progress, it would of course be 443.
Taking all these points together, it would seem that the work was begun
about the latter part of 443; and that the dedication was written
first, because that states the plan of the whole work, including the
ninth book, whose record does not meet the intention, there expressed;
moreover, some of the events in Book ix. indicate a considerable
interval between the fact and the account of it. When he finished what
he wrote, it is not so easy to tell; it would certainly take him a few
years, and the end was reached before any considerable outbreak of the
Eutychean heresy; therefore probably in 447, or 448, for the reason
that Pulcheria did not conquer that heresy until after her marriage
with Marcian; this date is supported by the fact that the breaking of
her vow was unknown to the writer of ix. 1, 3; also because the Emperor
Theodosius was still alive. The work was the fruit and employment of
old age; the style is certainly that of an elderly man, and not that of
youth or early maturity.
What were the main objects he had in view in his
history?
1. He desired to present the truth with regard to the
facts and their results. In i. 1, he affirms: “I will readily
transcribe fully from any work that may tend to the elucidation of
truth.” “Still, as it is requisite, in order to maintain
historical accuracy, to pay the strictest attention to the means of
eliciting truth, I felt myself bound to examine all writings of this
class, according to my ability.” This is his professed purpose;
however subjective or churchly his view of truth may be, we must give
him the credit for the intention. In i. 1, he appeals
to his readers in this wise: “Let not an
impertinent or malignant spirit be imputed to me, for having dwelt upon
the disputes of ecclesiastics among themselves, concerning the primacy
and pre-eminence of their own heresy. In the first place, as I have
already said, a historian ought to regard everything as secondary in
importance to truth.” And we shall see evidences of his
fairness.
2. His history is designed to be a demonstration of
Christianity as from God. The vastness of the change wrought by God in
the introduction and success of Christianity and the insignificant and
mythical themes upon which literature had been wont to exercise itself,
prompted him, with his confessed inefficiency, to undertake this line
of evidence, in the conviction that God would help his believing
incapacity. Hence his work is a record of immediate divine
interventions, and extraordinary gifts of the Holy Spirit; it abounds
in visions, miracles, and prophecy. The celestial agents visibly direct
affairs; the flow of vaticination does not cease; the power to reverse
the expected order of events is not suspended. Thus, as to epiphanies
of divine, angelic, or sainted beings: In i. 3, is recounted the
appearance of the cross unto Constantine; and in the night during
sleep, the manifestation of Christ with a cross, and the instructions
given to the emperor. In ii. 1, we have a series of divine
interpositions to discover the true cross, and Sozomen remarks in
refutation of one explanation, “I do not think that human
information is requisite, when God thinks it best to make manifest the
same.” In ii. 3, the old name, Hestiæ, is changed to
Michaelium, because of the reported appearance of the archangel there.
The monks are favored with such direct counselors; Pachomius obeys an
angel, who directs him to assemble young men for instruction; “he
was frequently admitted to intercourse with the holy angels.”
Apollonius yielded to direct divine advice, and withdrew from the
desert to a populous region. The cross reappeared in the days of
Constantius (iv. 5); Julian’s life is filled with portents (v. 1,
20, 22; vi. 2). A curious bit of speculation occurs in vi. 2; in
interpreting Julian’s alleged use of his blood, he says: “I
know not whether the approach of death, as is wont to be the case, when
the soul is in the act of being separated from the body, and when it is
enabled to behold diviner spectacles than is allotted to men, that
Julian might then have beheld Christ. Few allusions have been made to
this subject; and yet I dare not reject this hypothesis as absolutely
false, for God often suffers still more improbable and astonishing
events to take place, in order to prove that the religion named after
Christ is not sustained by human energy.” Of Theodore’s
confession (v. 20) he remarks: “It is said that he was afterwards
asked whether he had been sensible of any pain on the rack; and that he
replied he had not been entirely free from suffering, but had his pain
assuaged by the attentions of a young man who had stood by him, and had
wiped off the perspiration with the finest linen cloth, and supplied
him with coolest water, by which he eased the inflammation and
refreshed his labors. I am convinced that no man, whatever magnanimity
he may possess, is capable without the special assistance of divine
Power, of manifesting such entire indifference about the body.”
In vi. 29, Piammon sees an angel standing near the holy table, and
writing down in a book the names of the monks who were present, while
he erased the names of those who were absent. Mark had the elements of
the holy table administered to him by an angel (vii. 29). Malachion,
while journeying with his brothers, was made invisible, and then
reappeared, and pursued his way with them (vi. 32). So the portent at
Hebdomas was a sign of divine favor to Theodosius the Great (vii. 24);
the heavenly hosts were the real overthrowers of Gaïnas (viii. 4);
Basiliscus the martyr appears to Chrysostom (viii. 28).
Pulcheria’s celestial directors helps her to find the forty
martyrs (ix. 2). The appearance of Zechariah to the serf pointed out
the way to the discovery of the prophet’s remains (ix. 17). The
demoniacal agencies are equally operant, some of which are alluded to
in the above passages, but readily yield to prayer and exorcism, if not
immediately overthrown by God.
For a demonstration of the same truth, miracles are
wrought to effect physical cures, mental troubles, threatened dangers,
casting out of demons, silencing philosophers and wordy ecclesiastics,
vindicating orthodoxy, reading the thoughts of hypocrites defeating
enemies, sanctifying
the
sacraments’ raising the dead; and they are the mighty agents for
converting philosophers, Jews, pagans, and heretics. They are wrought
by the hands of the eminently excellent only; the gift is associated
with a high measure of grace; for example the bishops Paphnutius (i.
10) and Spyridion (i. 11) are so endowed; Alexander of Constantinople
(i. 14), Eusebius of Emesa (iii. 6), Martin of Tours (iii. 14),
Arsacius of Nicomedia (iv. 16), Donatus (vii. 26), Gregory of
Neocæsarea (vii. 26), Theotimus of Scythia (vii. 26), Epiphanius
of Salamis (vii. 27). In like manner, the monks Antony (i. 13), Amun
(i. 14), Eutychianus (i. 14), Macarius the Egyptian, Apollonius,
Hilarion, Julian (iii. 14), John, Copres, Helles, Apelles, Eulogius
(vi. 28); Apollos, John of Diolchus, Benjamin and Pior (vi. 29). The
united prayer of a congregation could effect them (vii. 5). The statue
of Christ at Paneas, the fountain at Emmaus, the tree at Hermopolis (v.
21), were all miraculous centers. The spot where the Archangel Michael
appeared (ii. 3), the places where the head of John the Baptist reposed
(vii. 21), the tombs of monks, martyrs, and bishops,—as of
Hilarion (iii. 14), Martyrius and Marcianus (iv. 3), Epiphanius (vii.
27),—were replete with restorative virtues. Sozomen had such a
miracle wrought upon himself; he believed thoroughly in an
uninterrupted stream of charismata; he deemed it necessary for the
maintenance of the faith. He was no more credulous than Socrates, or
Theodoret, or Evagrius, or Theodore. To criticise him for his belief in
this respect is to forget the Christian consciousness of the age. And
the historic school which seeks to eliminate the volume of testimony,
in the assumption that miracles do not fall within the province of
history, ignores the first law of that science, which requires the
reproduction of all facts, in time and place, whatever they may be,
that are affiliated with the evolution of the human will; that other
older school which dismisses all ecclesiastical miracles on the
a
priori
assumption that these energies ceased at a time co-ordinate
with the death of the Apostles, or at a point not far removed from
their age, violates the spirit of induction. These miracles must be
tested by evidence, and the laws of supernatural energy, and in no
other way. To Sozomen and all his contemporaries the miracle appeared
essential both to the proof of the divine origin of Christianity, and
to offset and withstand the influence of the theurgic arts of the
philosophers, such as Julianus and many of the Neoplatonists. As he
remarks concerning the reply made by Alexander, bishop of
Constantinople, when he silenced the philosopher by the simple
authority of Christ, “It is then right to consider whether it is
a greater miracle, that a man, and he a philosopher, should so easily
be silenced by a word, or that a stone wall should be cleft by the
power of a word, which miracle I have heard some attribute with pride
to Julian, surnamed the Chaldean” (i. 18). The gift of prophecy
is also represented as sustained throughout this period, and with the
same logical aims in view. The monks are especially thus endowed:
Antony (i. 13, vi. 5, 6), the two Macarii, Pachomius (iii. 14),
Arsacius (iv. 16), John (vi. 28, vii. 22, vii. 28), Theon (vi. 28),
Isaac (vi. 40); so the bishops Athanasius (iv. 10), Chrysostom and
Epiphanius, rather abusively (viii. 15); so royal persons, such as the
wife of Valens, passively (vi. 16), Pulcheria, directly and passively
(ix. 3). The perpetuation of this charism was deemed inherently
necessary for the sake of historical continuity, and to prove as well
that the faith he loved had been established by God; equally was it
requisite as a holy parallel whereby to gainsay the mantic spirit of
Paganism; as is best illustrated in the silencing of the oracle at
Daphne (v. 19), and by his reflections upon the philosopher’s
tripod devised for finding the successor of Valens (vi. 35). Nor are
Socrates, Theodoret, Evagrius, and others any more moderate than
Sozomen in this respect.
3. Another aim of his history is to prove that
Providence or the divine government is promoting the Christian faith
directly. The universal order must be interpreting itself distinctly
through the Church. The Father must be vindicating the good and
punishing the wicked, according to the orthodox category.
Sozomen’s history is as insistent in this regard as Eliphaz and
his philosophic confreres. One must be able to decide infallibly in
each case as to cause and effect; it is a very realistic pragmatism,
and is not the exclusive property of Sozomen; it is a characteristic of
all these Church historians.
There is properly
enough a recognition of God in history; the sovereign will and the
human will are jointly working out the world’s order, but it is
the attempt to trace the cause and effect immediately and in each case,
which is so repulsive and absurd. Some illustrations will show how he
brings out this view. In i. 7 the comment made on Constantine’s
overthrow of Licinius: “From many facts it has often appeared to
me that the teaching of the Christians is supported, and its
advancement secured, by the Providence of God, and not the least from
what then occurred; for at the very moment that Licinius was about to
persecute all the churches under him, the war in Bithynia broke out,
which ended in a war between him and Constantine, and in which
Constantine was so strengthened by Divine assistance, that he was
victorious over his enemies by land and by sea.” More of detail
comes out in the life of Athanasius. Thus in ii. 17, of his election he
says: “Alexander, bishop of Alexandria, when about to depart this
life, left Athanasius as his successor, in accordance, I am convinced,
with the Divine will, directing the vote upon him.” And again:
“He fled to escape the honor, but he was discovered in his place
of concealment by the help of God, who had forecast by Divine
manifestations to his blessed predecessors, that the succession was to
devolve upon him.” His whole career is so viewed in v. 6. There
is a large discussion of this subject in vi. 35, where he argues
against the plan of pagan philosophers to foretell the future of the
empire: “The philosophers, on the other hand, acted as if the
deposition and restoration of emperors had depended solely on them; for
if the imperial succession was to be considered dependent on the
arrangement of the stars, what was requisite but to await the accession
of the future emperor, whoever he might be? Or, if the succession was
regarded as dependent on the will of God, what right had man to meddle?
For it is not the function of human foreknowledge or zeal to understand
God’s thought; nor if it were right, would it be well for men,
even if they be the wisest of all, to think that they can plan better
than God.” He persists in tracing a connection between God and
every event in favor of mechanical goodness or orthodoxy. He follows
many opponents, whether heretical or pagan, with the Divine wrath; all
these historians do this,—Philostorgius, as well as Evagrius.
Sozomen is not nearly so bitter or uncharitable as either of these. He
is most atrabilious in the case of Julian, under whom his own family
had suffered. As a consequence of this arbitrary pious pragmatism, the
most deplorable incompetents are treated as the express favorites of
heaven, while the larger-minded pagan or Arian is loaded with contempt.
Under this law, too, the evil sides of the orthodox, and the
excellences of the pagan, or Arians, are suppressed. The defeats of the
Nicene emperors are not mentioned; the victories of the Anti-Nicene are
passed by or belittled, while their humiliations are evidence of the
impending anger of heaven. In the survey of Helena’s life (ii. 2)
he says: “It seems to me that so many holy actions demanded a
recompense, and indeed even in this life she was raised to the summit
of magnificence.” As to Constantine, in ii. 34 he dares say:
“He was more successful than any other sovereign in all his
undertakings; for he formed no design, I am convinced, without
God.” When Bishop Felix of Rome died, and Liberius became sole
occupant of the see, he construes the fact thus: “This event was
no doubt ordained by God, that the seat of Peter might not be
dishonored by the occupancy of two bishops; for such an arrangement is
a sign of discord, and is foreign to ecclesiastical law” (iv.
15). In all the features of Julian’s life, God is visiting him
with his unappeasable anger (vi. 35, v. 21, 22, vi. 1, 2). The election
of Nectarius, though it was in violation of ecclesiastical order and an
accumulation of ignorant blunders, did not take place without the
interposition of Divine strength (vii. 8). Theodosius is portrayed as
the prime delight of heaven; thus his simple reliance upon God wins him
a hopeless battle with Eugenius (vii. 24). It is so with the whole
Theodosian line (viii. 1, ix. 1). Pulcheria has Divine love manifested
to her in manifold ways, as does her brother, Theodosius the Younger
(ix. 1, 3, 16). Even Alaric is driven by an inexplicable impulse to
rebuke the luxury, debauchery, and injustice of the Romans (ix. 6). In
ix. 1, he says of his own sovereign: “It appears to me that it
was the design of God to show by the events of this period, that piety
alone suffices for the salvation of
princes; and that without piety, armies, a
powerful empire, and every other resource, are of no avail. The Divine
power, which is the guardian of the universe, foresaw that the emperor
would be distinguished by his piety, and determined that Pulcheria, his
sister, should be the protector of him and of the government.” In
ix. 16, he explains his secular details in the paragraph: “This
is not the proper place to enter into details concerning the deaths of
the tyrants; but I considered it necessary to allude to the
circumstance in order to show, that to insure the stability of imperial
power, it is sufficient for an emperor to serve God with reverence,
which was the course pursued by Honorius.” While of his patron he
says: “It seems as if God openly manifested His favor towards the
present emperor, not only by disposing of warlike affairs in an
unexpected way, but also by revealing the sacred bodies of many persons
who were of old most distinguished for piety.” The whole history
is full of this sort of philosophy of its personages. Similarly all
natural calamities and the irruption of barbarians are ethically
explained, which is correct enough as a general principle; but these
phenomena are punitive or vindicatory of particular deeds.
Constantius’ course toward Athanasius was heralded by an invasion
of the Franks, and by an earthquake in the East (iii. 6). Of Julian he
says: “It is, however, very obvious that throughout the reign of
this emperor, God gave manifest tokens of His displeasure and permitted
many calamities to befall several of the provinces of the Roman Empire.
He visited the earth with such fearful earthquakes, that the buildings
were shaken, and no more safety could be found within houses than in
the open air.” Then follow the inundations of the Nile; the
drought and the famine in the empire, and on their heels the
pestilences (vi. 2). Under Valens we read: “In the meantime
although hail-storms of extraordinary magnitude fell in various places,
and although many cities, particularly Nicæa in Bithynia, were
shaken by earthquakes, yet Valens the emperor and Eudoxius the bishop
paused not in their career, but continued to persecute all Christians
who differed from them in opinion” (vi. 10). He does not make the
same reflection upon Constantius, when the earthquake at Nicomedia
intercepted the meeting of a council (iv. 16); Gaïnas’
attempted revolution is “pre-announced by the appearance of a
comet directly over the city; this comet was of extraordinary
magnitude, larger, it is said, than any that had previously been
seen” (viii. 3). After Chrysostom’s exile,
“hailstones of extraordinary magnitude fell at Constantinople and
in the suburbs of the city. Four days afterwards, the wife of the
emperor died. These occurrences were regarded by many as indications of
Divine wrath, on account of the persecutions that had been carried on
against John” (viii. 27).
But the earthquakes and famines and invasions that
happened under Theodosius the Great and Theodosius Junior are not
mentioned directly. By such unfair pragmatism Sozomen, as all his
fellow-historians, sought to answer the allegations, now more directly
affirmed, in the period of barbarian irruption, that the calamities
were due to the desertion of the gods. Sulpicius Severus, Augustine,
and Orosius built up a somewhat better apology.
4. Another object he kept before him, we will let him
state in his own words: “The doctrine of the Catholic Church is
shown to be especially the most genuine, since it has been tested
frequently by the plots of opposing thinkers; yet, the disposal of the
lot being of God, the Catholic Church has maintained its own
ascendancy, has re-assumed its own power, and has led all the churches
and the people to the reception of its own truth” (i. 1).
Catholicity and Orthodoxy, as defined at Nicæa, are synonymous.
The creed of the fathers is final. The Church which spoke in 325 and
381 is the historic and Catholic Church, and the Theodosian line is the
Divinely appointed instrument for laying its foundations immovably, the
others having failed. Church and State are to be indissolubly wedded.
This faith is made mechanically the test of goodness and badness, and
this expresses his personal belief.
He speaks of the Scriptures with uniform reverence, and
holds to the
θεωρία
as the method of
interpretation, as we see in v. 22, where he says of the Jews:
“They were only acquainted with the mere letter of Scripture, and
could not, like the Christians and a few of the wisest among the
Hebrews, discover the hidden meaning (
πρὸς
θεωρίαν
)”; yet he
speaks with respect (viii. 2)
of
Chrysostom’s way of expounding the sacred records and of his
“teacher Diodorus’ method, employed in the many books of
that bishop,” in which he explained the significance of the
sacred words and avoided allegory (
θεωρία
). But when bishops
and monks are declared to be skilled in the Scriptures, it is in this
mystical sense. His own grandfather was a solver of the amphibolies of
the Word, doubtless by this convenient key (v. 5).
The dogmatic standpoint, as we have seen, was
traditionalism, toward which the Church gravitated under the dictation
of the councils, the influence of bishops like Athanasius, the almost
uniform ictus of the Roman see, Ambrose, the Gregories, Basil the
Great, Ephraim, Eusebius, and Epiphanius, the majority of monks, and
finally the whole force of the State. He opposes all shades of
Arianism, as also Apolinarianism; had he completed his work, from what
he says of Pulcheria’s conquest over heresies, he would have
opposed the Nestorian views of the Theotokos. But of Donatism and
Cyprianism he has not a word. Of the anthropological struggles of the
West there is not a syllable. Here is the place, also, to consider his
attitude toward heresies. Sozomen does not assail any phase of Arianism
with the intemperate epithets which Eusebius employed to condemn the
earlier innovators, or such as abound in Theodoret and Evagrius and
later historians. Indeed, he sometimes calls them Christians and
members of the Catholic Church. His treatment of the Novatians, while a
little offish, is yet generous as compared with other writers, except
Socrates, from whom he obtains almost all their history; he devotes
much space; he is generally courteous in tone; and when he speaks of
the proposed union (iv. 2) between the Catholic Church and that body of
believers, he omits the cause of the failure; viz., the reluctance of
some legalistic Novatians to acquiesce,—a point which Socrates
does not fail to expose. He mentions Montanism (Phrygianism) several
times, but with no new facts, save that they were numerous in Phrygia
in his day, and had peculiar Paschal usages (i. 6, ii. 18, 32, vii. 18,
19). Of the Gnostic sects, he alludes to the Valentinians only, whose
conventicles were repressed by an edict of Constantius (ii. 32). The
Manichæans are mentioned only as they are one of the three sects
excepted from Gratian’s law of toleration (vii. 1). Of the
Pricillianists, whose attempt at a world religion falls so wholly
within his time, he says nothing. The Quartodecimanians are still
numerous and tenacious (vii. 18). He has a bare allusion to the
Encratites (v. 11). Of the Origenistic controversy, he has no more to
say than he is compelled to, in order to state correctly the conflict
between Theophilus and Chrysostom. Over against the Origenists he
places the Anthropomorphists (viii. 12). Of Lucifer’s separatism,
he gives only the rise (iii. 15). With all his emphatic adherence to
the current orthodoxy, he must be regarded as the most charitable of
historians next to Socrates. Mention has already been made of his
kindly disposition toward the Novatians. When writing fully and
favorably, as was his duty, about Aëtius (iii. 15), he is
constrained to make an apology: “Let it not be accounted strange
if I have bestowed commendations upon the leaders or enthusiasts of the
above-mentioned heresies. I admire their eloquence and their
impressiveness in discourse: I leave their doctrines to be judged by
those whose prerogative it is.”
On the one hand, we find him insisting on the right of
private judgment, as when he discusses the overruling Providence in
Julian’s life, and especially on the infatuation which led the
emperor to Persia in spite of Sallust (vi. 1): “This observation,
however, is only inserted lest I should be blamed for omitting it. I
leave every one to form his own opinion.” So, after discussing
the use of penance, he remarks in the following chapter (vii. 17):
“Such subjects as the above, however, are best left to the
decision of individual judgment.” He would also allow latitude in
ceremonials (vii. 19), as we shall see. On the other hand, he dreads
the progressive and unsettling outcome of the private judgment in
exercise. He expresses this fear in iv. 27: “The spirit of
innovation is self-laudatory; hence it advanced farther and farther,
and crept along to greater novelties. With increasing self-conceit, and
in scorn of the fathers, it enacted laws of its own. Nor does it honor
the doctrine of the ancients concerning God, but is always excogitating
strange dogmas and restlessly adds novelty to novelty, as the events
now show.”
Of the threatening
strategies of free thought in his own day, he devoutly exclaimed:
“That new heresies have not prevailed in our times, we shall find
to be due especially to her” (Pulcheria) (ix. 1). Consequently he
deprecates the deleterious influence of polemics. On the accession of
Jovian, he says: “The presidents of the churches now resumed the
agitation of doctrinal questions and discussions. They had remained
quiet during the reign of Julian, when Christianity itself was
endangered, and had unanimously offered up their supplications for the
mercy of God. It is thus that men, when attacked by foreign enemies,
remain in accord among themselves; but when external troubles are
removed, then internal dissensions creep in” (vi. 4 and in vi.
25).
“Thus do the private animosities of the clergy
from time to time greatly injure the Church and divide religion into
many heresies! And this is a proof; for had George, like Theodotus,
received Apolinarius, on his repentance, into communion, I believe that
we should never have heard of the heresy that bears his name. Men are
prone, when loaded with opprobrium and contempt, to resort to rivalries
and innovations; whereas, when treated with justice, they become
moderate and remain in the same position.” More emphatic still is
his protest in vi. 26: “Those varying dogmas are the source of
innumerable troubles to religion, and many are deterred from embracing
Christianity by the diversity of opinion which prevails in matters of
doctrine.” In the beginning of this same chapter, in speaking of
the Eunomians, he delineates them thus: “They do not applaud a
good course of life or manner of conduct, or mercy towards the needy,
unless exhibited by persons of their own sect, so much as skill in
disputation and the power of triumphing in debates.” This is a
great blow at the
sectores cymini
, and at pride in polemics; the
whole tone is much more liberal than that of the ecclesiastic
Theodoret, or even the lawyer Evagrius. Sozomen, like Socrates,
represents a generous feeling current among the laymen of
Constantinople in court and among the trades and professions. The
attitude of the Catholic Church with regard to baptism he sets forth
adequately as trivial, and argues against the Eunomian innovation of
one baptism and a change in the formula (vi. 21): “But whether it
was Eunomius or any other person who first made these innovations upon
the tradition of baptism, it seems to me that such innovators, whoever
they may have been, were alone in danger, according to their own
representation, of quitting this life without having received Divine
baptism.” The argument here is an unusually long one; with his
generation he held to the magical efficacy of the rite. The theory of
the sacraments as mysteries or arcane, was one which controlled him
throughout, and even limited his fidelity as a historian. Thus in i.
20: “I thought it necessary to reproduce the very document (the
Nicene Creed) concerning these matters, as an example of the truth, in
order that posterity might possess in a fixed and clear form, the
symbol of that faith which proved pacifying at the time; but since some
pious friends who understood such matters, recommended that these
truths ought to be spoken of and heard by the initiated and their
initiators only, I agreed with their counsel: for it is not unlikely
that some of the uninitiated may read this book: while I have concealed
such of the prohibited material as I ought to keep silent about, I have
not altogether left the reader ignorant of the opinions held by the
Synod.” Nor will he repeat the symbol as subjoined to the letter
of the council of Antioch (vi. 4); and when the Macedonian commission
to Liberius make their statement, and the text is given to show their
entire acceptance of the Nicene view, Sozomen will not reproduce it.
Again in vi. 29, Mark was a monk of “such eminent piety, that
Macarius himself, the presbyter of Celliæ, declared that he had
never given to him what priests present to the initiated at the holy
table; but that an angel, administering it to him, whose hand up to the
forearm, he declared himself to have seen.” In viii. 5, in giving
the account of a marvelous judgment wrought on a Macedonian wife, who
pretended to be a convert to the Nicene views, and thus frequented the
orthodox ceremony of the Supper, he remarks, “At the time of the
celebration of the mysteries (the initiated will understand what I
mean), this woman kept what was given her, and held down her head as if
engaged in prayer.” In reciting the disturbances at the Easter
celebration over the decree of exile against Chrysostom (viii. 21), he
says: “They
were charged with
the commission of such disorderly acts as can be readily conceived by
those who have been admitted to the mysteries, but which I consider it
requisite to pass over in silence, lest my work should fall into the
hands of the uninitiated.” Here we have a glimpse of the scope of
the arcane as well as the weakness of the historian in submitting to
the advice of narrow friends; no other historian felt bound to restrict
himself in such matters. Sozomen here joined the most extreme
sacramentarians of his day. On the weighty matter of discipline, he
believes with the Catholic Church in receiving back the penitent into
the Church, against Novatian and Donatistic practices. He expresses his
opinion at some length, though not so fully as Socrates, in the chapter
which relates to the abolition of the penitential presbyter (vii. 16):
“Impeccability is a Divine attribute, and belongs not to human
nature; therefore God has decreed that pardon should be extended to the
penitent even after many transgressions. As in supplicating for pardon,
it is requisite to confess the sin, it seems probable that the priests,
from the beginning, considered it irksome to make this confession in
public, before the whole assembly of the people. They appointed a
presbyter of the utmost sanctity and the most undoubted prudence, to
act on those occasions: the penitents went to him and confessed their
transgressions; and it was his office to indicate the kind of penance
adapted to each sin, and then when satisfaction had been made, to
pronounce absolution.” He deplores the abolition of the office as
the occasion of laxity. The deterrent force of public confession was
now lost, and that to the danger of Christian conduct. He sympathizes
also with that form of martyrdom which wantonly and ruthlessly assails
paganism and is slain in the attempt. The system of relic-worship, so
characteristic of any decline of opportunity for heroic action, had set
in overwhelmingly, and he believed in it vigorously. Our own age
reproduces the same tendency not only in religious, but in secular
forms, and among Protestants as well. Thus he commemorates: of Old
Testament prophets, Micah and Habakkuk (vii. 29), Zechariah (ix. 17);
of the preparatory period, the head of John the Baptist (vii. 21); of
the Apostolic Church, St. Stephen (vii. 29, ix. 16); of the martyrs,
Babylas (v. 19), Forty Soldiers (ix. 2); of the monks, Hilarion (iii.
14), the four brothers (vii. 9). The most prominent of secondary relics
is the cross with its inscriptions and nails (ii. 1). The discovery of
these is mainly through prayer and heavenly signs; their possession is
an object of imperial ambition; the removal and transportation of them
are effected with most gorgeous and reverent pomp; and the sacred
treasures become the agents of endless miracles.
Sozomen, like Socrates and Chrysostom, believes in
freedom as to old-time ceremonials. He has a chapter on the varieties
of religious usage (vii. 19); and the record is largely the result of
his own inquiry. He remarks in conclusion: “Many other customs
are still to be observed in cities and villages; and those who have
been brought up in their observance would, from respect to the great
men who instituted and perpetuated these customs, consider it wrong to
abolish them. Similar motives must be attributed to those who observe
different practices in the celebration of the fast, which has led us
into this long digression.” From his point of view, uniformity
may not encroach upon individualism beyond a certain point. He is
certainly quietly and with dignity attacking a party of narrow
uniformitarians, who are already pressing for a harmony of all
ceremonials in Christendom.
Another feature of the Catholic system that he traces
carefully, is the relation between Church and Empire. He devotes more
attention to this aspect of polity than to its internal development;
this latter he touches upon incidentally, and not at all carefully. We
have seen how painstakingly he cites the imperial edicts with regard to
the Church. The state laws, which at first expressed conciliar
decisions, were followed by independent imperial enactments. These,
indeed, are at first sporadic, but become more and more the rule. The
personal views of Sozomen appear in the narrative, but they are
fluctuating. He acquiesces in the imperial convocation of councils, as
do all his cotemporaries. On the death of Constantine, in commenting
upon the hereafter fixed Christian character of the state, he says:
“The sacerdotal dignity
is
not only equal in honor to imperial power, but in sacred places even
takes the ascendancy” (ii. 34). With the plan of producing
uniformity of religion in the empire, he seems to sympathize (iv. 11).
He is indignant at Julian’s indifference to the murder of Zeno by
the inhabitants of Gaza, and at the deprivations of the Christians,
when all their political and personal rights were taken from them (v.
9). To the charge of Libanius, that the man who aimed the dart at
Julian was a Christian, and belonged to the race of habitual
transgressors of the law, Sozomen replies by defending the regicide:
“In the documents above quoted, Libanius clearly states that the
emperor fell by the hand of a Christian; and this probably was the
truth. It is not unlikely that some of the soldiers who then served in
the Roman army might have conceived the idea, since Greeks and all men
until this day have praised tyrannicides, for exposing themselves to
death in the cause of liberty, and spiritedly standing by their
country, their families, and their friends. Still less is he deserving
of blame, who for the sake of God and of religion, performed so bold a
deed” (vi. 2). This is the highest stand that a lawyer could take
in support of individualism. In his view of the exalted prerogatives of
the Church, the reply of Valentinian to the bishops, who desired to
hold a council, would seem happy. “I am but one of the laity, and
have, therefore, no right to interfere in these transactions; let the
priests, to whom such matters appertain, assemble where they
please” (vi. 7). Theodosius’ compulsory course with regard
to paganism and orthodoxy, and the choice of Nectarius, are approved.
On the other hand, he selected two instances out of many from the life
of Ambrose, for the purpose of illustrating how, in God’s behalf,
that bishop conducted himself towards those in power (vii. 25).
Throughout we find him recognizing the practical
headship of Rome; he expresses himself unconsciously in vi. 22,
“The question having been thus decided by the Roman Church, peace
was restored and the inquiry ended.” This ignores the action of
the Synod of Alexandria and that of Constantinople itself, for both had
decreed the consubstantiality of the Holy Spirit and opposed the
christology of Apolinarius, prior to the action of the Roman Synod. The
power delegated to Julius by the council of Sardica (iii. 8), the
conflict between the East and the West conducted in mutually arrogant
epistles (iii. 10), the subordination of new to old Rome (vii. 9), show
the drift toward concentration. Sozomen does not seem to understand the
rival movements of Alexandria under Athanasius and Theophilus; nor the
Eastern imperial attempts to elevate Constantinople to the supremacy,
nor the mutterings of Antiochan jealousy.
The Church’s servility toward the orthodox rulers
is fairly expressed, and yet with comparative moderation, by Sozomen.
He is an apologist for Constantine, and reflects, as do all the
historians, and especially Evagrius in his criticism of Zosimus, the
adulations and subterfuges of Eusebius. The religious fluctuation of
that emperor is masked; his crimes are suppressed; he is made to appear
orthodox, even when at his worst Eusebian stage. No wonder that
Philostorgius charged the Homoöusians with worshiping Constantine
as a god in the ceremonies connected with his image! Constantius, a
vacillating, cruel, incompetent, is also apologized for, but to the
damage of his intelligence. Julian, for his years in some respects, one
of the most promising and earnest rulers of ancient times, is loaded
with obloquy, his highest motives and ideals ridiculed, his victories
belittled, his death savagely exulted in. Jovian’s and
Valentinian’s toleration are not understood, but their personal
orthodoxy is in so far praised. Valens is looked at through the eyes of
his two fierce Cappadocian assailants. His excellences are entirely
ignored; the most inconsequent views are imputed to him while
attempting to glorify Basil; in the sad story of the emperor’s
dying son, that bishop appears as a brute in his treatment of the
agonized father. The stories of heroism attributed to the orthodox are
only examples of insufferable insolence; one must marvel at the
patience of Valens, if there be any truth in them. Gratian, that
beau-ideal of Western orthodoxy, was really a nose of wax in the hands
of Ambrose; he was esteemed more moderately by the East, and that
rather for having called Theodosius to a share in the throne, than for
any quality in himself; but his utter moral collapse, after the
magnificent promise of his youth, is wholly veiled from sight.
Theodosius the Great is glorified, not for his superior statecraft and
generalship, but for his efforts to
suppress paganism and heresy. The charges against his private life such
as Eunapius and Zosimus suggest, are not hinted at. He is a man of
prayer and visions, a relic-worshiper, and a persecutor of pagans and
Arians. Great as he certainly was, his distinguishing and conspicuous
qualities are passed by. His pitiful children, Arcadius and Honorius,
the sorriest quidnuncs of those stormy times, are heroes of piety.
Pulcheria, excellent as she was, was not worthy of the excessive
flattery poured out upon her; while Anthemius, Troïlus,
Valerianus, and other noble figures of the day are passed by. The
younger Theodosius, with his good training and generally fair endeavor,
is delineated in the dedication as the consummate man of all time,
while he is a very third-rate soul at best. The eulogies by Socrates
(vii. 22 and 42) are just as fulsome. This was the grave sin of the
State Church; the Arian State Church did the same for Constantius and
Valens; more and more as history reveals the truth concerning many of
those idols, does the revulsion increase against a union of two
functions which could so degrade both.
The relation of Church and State involves the question
of persecution. It is not the history of the endeavor to enforce
uniformity, with which we shall concern ourselves, but rather the views
Sozomen sets forth, as to the policy of repression. The laws of
Constantine suppressing heretics did not affect the Novatians (ii. 32),
concerning which justice, he remarks: “The emperor, I believe,
willingly relaxed the rigor of the enactment in their favor, for he
only desired to strike terror into the minds of his subjects, and had
no intention of persecuting them.” The punishments inflicted in
Constantius’ time on the orthodox in Constantinople, both by
Macedonius (iv. 23) and Eudoxius (iv. 26), call forth this reflection:
“For, if the persecution did not occasion such tortures to the
body as preceding ones, it appeared more grievous to all who reflected
aright, on account of its disgraceful nature, for both the persecutors
and the persecuted belonged to the Church; and the one was all the more
disgraceful in that men of the same religion treated their fellows with
a degree of cruelty which the ecclesiastical laws prohibit to be
manifested towards enemies and strangers.” He spares himself the
pain of registering all who were ejected from their sees (iv. 27), for
no province was without its list of sufferers. The cruelties inflicted
by George on pagan and orthodox, furnish a mournful narrative (iv. 30).
On the elevation of Julian, a great dread fell upon the Christian
world, intensified by the portents which befell him. The series of
edicts soon wrought mutual dissension in the Christian ranks, as well
as suffering from without. But while Sozomen attributes the refinements
of cruelty to Julian, and lays the miseries of the saints at his door
as parts of a subtle plan, he nevertheless cannot conceal from himself
the absence of direct interference on the part of the State; these
calamities were the results of a restoration of the old religion to its
ancient union with the State; it was an imperial act; and he is
compelled to confess the seeming magnanimity of Julian in certain
cases, but even then maligns his motives. The imperial clemency did not
arise from any feeling of compassion, but because persecution would
only increase the number of Galilean adherents; because he was envious
of their glory, did he resort to argument instead of cruelty, and
manifest an unexpected benevolence instead of proceeding to rigorous
measures (v. 4, 5). “It may be concluded from what has been said,
that if Julian shed less blood than preceding persecutors of the
Church, and that if he devised fewer punishments for the torture of the
body, yet that he was severer in other respects.” Nevertheless,
this statement is followed by a record of suffering in all quarters of
the empire and the impression of purposed directness is given, as if
the State had inflicted them, especially when we read that the emperor
would not listen to the cautions of Sallust (v. 20). He does not
comment on Jovian’s toleration, but only rejoices in the return
of the Church to ascendancy. Unsparing is his picture of the dastardly
measures of Valens against the professors of the faith; he regards that
persecutor as the special victim of Divine wrath; while, on the other
hand, he does not hesitate to call the Arian Goths, who fell under the
anger of Athanaric, martyrs (vi. 37). He does not express an opinion as
to the partial toleration of Gratian’s edict (vii. 1); but in
explanation of Theodosius’ law forbidding heretics, i.e. all
anti-Nicenists, from holding churches and from exercising any clerical
function, he says: “Great as were the punishments
adjudged by the laws against heretics, they
were not always carried into execution; for the emperor had no desire
to persecute his subjects; he only desired to enforce uniformity of
view about God’ through the medium of intimidation. Those who
voluntarily renounced heretical opinions, received commendation from
him.” And it is true that the court practice of persecuting
emperors, orthodox or Arian, was utterly in the teeth of their own
edicts, and their most intimate counselors were elected without regard
to religion. When Justina sought to revive the Arian standard in the
West, her treatment of Ambrose is called persecution (vii. 13); but
Ambrose’s intolerant procedures against the Arians are not even
noticed. No quizzical wrinkle disturbs the flow of his narrative in
vii. 15, when Theodosius I. gives a heathen temple to the Christians,
and the pagans resolve to defend their rights, and do so effectually;
but the Christians who perish in that hateful conflict are crowned as
martyrs by an imperial edict! For the religious tyranny of Theodosius
the Great he is a warm apologist, and disguises the perversion of that
principle of freedom for which he pleads most earnestly, when the
Arians hold the reins of power, and abuse their opportunity. The
contradictions are perfectly apparent and irreconcilable, because
uniformity by force has always been impossible. Yet logical men will
state the most contradictory reasons, which no quidnunc can refrain
from laughing at. Themistius’ plea for toleration (vi. 36) in
matters of intellectual belief, on the ground of secular diversities in
philosophy and from the incomprehensible nature of God, shows the
existence of a party who believed in this principle. While Sozomen
gives it place, and hailed the Gothic Arians who compelled Valens to
cease his oppressions, he has no word of approbation for the
proposition or the argument.
5. Another design of his history is stated in i. 1:
“I have had to deliberate whether I ought to confine myself to
the recital of events connected with the Church under the Roman
government; but it seemed more advisable to include, as far as
possible, the record of transactions relative to religion among the
Persians and barbarians.” He regards Christianity as the
universal and sole religion, and would trace its extension in all
directions. Hence he is the first historian to give us a larger account
of religion in Syria and Palestine, introducing us especially to some
aspects of Christian life and suffering in Edessa; we are all the more
surprised to have no mention of the Church in Africa, and so very
little of the Church in the West, except when it comes into close
relations with the East, as in the larger controversies, and especially
after Arianism threatened to keep its hold upon the Byzantine section
of the empire; and the Orient had to cry to the cold and unsympathetic
Occident for help, and often in vain. He is also careful to give us
some, if not a very original, account of the work of missions. He
repeats the story of the Iberians, Armenians, Indians, Saracens, and
Goths. He gives us a larger insight into Persia; the errors with which
he is charged as swarming, are no more numerous than those of his
cotemporaries. Of the large work of Theophilus of Dhu, or the extension
of Arianism among the Germanic tribes, he says nothing.
Chrysostom’s real missionary enterprises are passed by, excepting
his expenditure of the funds furnished by Olympias for the redemption
and restoration of Isaurian captives (viii. 27). His reflections on the
methods of Church extension are more interesting and numerous. Thus, in
ii. 5, of the attempt of Constantine to abolish idolatry and introduce
the faith, Sozomen says, “Soldiers were not necessary; the
courtiers effected it”; he does not consider it advisable to give
all the details as to all the lands then won to the state religion. The
barbarians he notices as converted through the instrumentality of
Christian captives (ii. 6, 7). Armenian influence carried Christianity
into Persia (ii. 8). Prodigies, too, are helpful agents (vi. 5, v. 22).
The hieroglyphs and crux-symbols discovered in the Egyptian temples led
to the repentance of pagans (vii. 15). Sometimes a kingdom will solicit
the instruction of an orthodox monk, as in the case of the Saracens
(vi. 38). The legal suppressions of paganism facilitate a change of
sentiment on the part of many (vii. 15). The very ambitions of their
clergy led numbers of the Arians to embrace Nicene views (vii. 17); and
the doctrinal discussions among heretics constrain others to embrace a
more uniform system of belief (viii. 1). The
efficiency of the monks as evangelists is found
in nearly all the biographies of them. On the other hand, he makes
confession to the baleful effects of incessant indulgence in polemics.
“These varying dogmas are the sources of innumerable troubles to
religion; and many are deterred from embracing Christianity by the
diversity of opinion which prevails in matters of doctrine” (vi.
26). This thought of universality, then, is a feature of his
history.
6. Another design is to dignify monasticism as the true
ethical ideal and goal of Christianity,—as the philosophy which
is to supplant all the ancient intellectual strivings of
reason,—and he announces this purpose as follows: “Nor is
it foreign to ecclesiastical history to introduce in this work an
account of those who were the fathers and originators of what is
denominated monachism, and of their immediate successors, whose
celebrity is well known to us either by observation or report. For I
would neither be considered ungracious towards them, nor willing to
consign their virtue to oblivion, nor yet be thought ignorant of their
history; but would wish to leave behind me such a record of their
manner of life that others, led by their example, might attain to a
blessed and happy end” (i. 1). He is here quietly resisting a
school of Christians and politicians who were opposed to the absorbing
and destructive qualities of this manner of life; Athanasius, Basil the
Great, Jerome, Chrysostom, had to write in its defense for the same
reason, and he sided with these supporters of its virtues, very
naturally. He is a full believer in the Divine philosophy which
nurtured him; monasticism with its practical strivings after conformity
to the Divine-human Pattern, and its attempt to enthrone the spiritual
over the material has a zealous defender in him, of all its rapt and
grotesque forms. He determined therefore to make it a unique portion of
his history. The discussion of its aims in i. 12 will give us a clue to
his own desire to represent it as almost the resultant force in the
progress of the Divine kingdom; one reads the historian’s
responsive feeling between the lines. This philosophy was the most
useful thing received by man from God; it was superior to all other
knowledge, and warranted the neglect of all worldly science; it strove
to eliminate the
adiaphora
from ethics,
and to make everything have a moral complexion; one must be doing good,
or else he is doing evil. Its great duties are the discipline of self,
the worship of the Creator, and the cultivation of a spirit of
other-worldness. These canons and goals are the life of the system. It
is the philosophy which is to take the place of the old theoretical
schemes; and it is the great school to fill up the gap made by the
decay of the Hellenic universities. The Christian university founded by
Theodosius in Sozomen’s day, was indeed a blow to this
educational ideal. While we may have no accord with his view of this
ethical phenomenon, we must concede him the merit of discerning its
significance and intent, and allow that he was wise to give us so full
an account of its elaboration, and so much detail and scrap of
biography; for it was a dominant element in the history of this time.
It formed men and measures. The reproach of Sozomen on this score is
wholly a mistake; he has done us capital service in not neglecting this
element, otherwise we could have but little conception of its
historical setting, of its patience, its tireless devotion, and we
would have to resort to Palladius or Rufinus and the individual
biographies. Moreover, it is an uncritical spirit which recoils from
dissecting the awful and often repulsive details of legalistic
self-denial. After discoursing on the local origin of monasticism and
the forms it assumed, we have chapters containing brief sketches of
hermits, laurists, and cœnobites (i. 12, 13, 14, iii. 14). The
people looked to the monks for the color of their theology (iv. 10).
Arianism felt its weakness without them and ineffectually sought their
suppression (vi. 20). The Nicene faith uniformly received the support
of these communities (vi. 27), to which they remained devoted under all
persecutions. Another series of biographies follows in vi. 28–34:
Theophilus (viii. 12) has a preliminary struggle with them to carry
forward his plots against John. The royal court itself under
Pulcheria’s leadership reflected its severe discipline (ix. 13).
Sozomen seems also to have studied the rules of various bodies, some of
whose details he gives, and indulges in a sort of comparative study of
their regulations (vi. 30). Yet with all his implied admiration of the
heroes of this system, who went to the almost extreme of abstinence, he
remarks in reviewing the
discipline
of Theotimus (vii. 26): “I consider it to be the part of the
philosopher to yield to the demand of these appetites from necessity,
and not from the love of sensual gratification.” It is to be
noted that he omits for the most part the immoral forms of monasticism,
such as Evagrius gives us a highly rhetorical account of.
7. A more subordinate aim is to present selected secular
matters so-called; he does not consider these to be wholly foreign to
the scope of his work. He handles such with considerable largeness in
Constantine’s life, and keeps up a thread under Constantius and
Julian. He is more sparing until he reaches Arcadius and Honorius, and
the chapters 3–15 of Book ix. are largely devoted to the Western
struggles with usurpers.
8. A final and subordinate aim is the development of
imperial law with regard to the Church; he gives little of purely
synodical canons, but remarks, “I consider it necessary, however,
to mention the laws enacted for the honor and consolidation of
religion, as they constitute a considerable portion of ecclesiastical
history.” And in the next chapter, “Having arrived at this
point of my history, it would not be right to omit all mention of the
laws passed in favor of those individuals in the churches, who had
received their freedom” (i. 9). We have already seen how
continuously this plan is sustained.
His Method. 1. He is conscious of certain limitations,
and expresses them frankly. (
a
) A modest estimate of his own
powers (Proemium, i. 1). (
b
) The excess of material compels him
to a constant process of selection (ii. 3, 5, 14, iii. 14, 15, 16, iv.
4, 27, vii. 17, 28, ix. 1. (
c
) A sense of incapacity to handle
some aspects of doctrine (vii. 17). (
d
) An occasional
insufficiency of data to state a positive conclusion (iv. 2, viii.
16).
2. He acknowledges the need of research, and presents
his ideal purpose in i. 7: “I shall record the transactions with
which I have been connected, and also those concerning which I have
heard from persons who knew or saw the affairs in our own day, or
before our own generation. But I have sought for records of events of
earlier date amongst the established laws appertaining to religion,
amongst the proceedings of the Synods of the period, amongst the
innovations that arose, and in the epistles of kings and
priests.” His recurring intention was to reproduce the documents
just as they were, but he finally decided to epitomize their contents
and to present the entire instrument, only when the state of
controversy compelled it in order to fairness. The difficulty in the
way of consulting these sources lay in the fact of their dispersion in
palaces, churches, and the private libraries of the erudite. He
anticipates criticism by acknowledging that contradictions are likely
to appear in his work, not from any fault of his own, but because of
the partisan and arbitrary nature of the documents; he ingenuously
confesses that men’s passions and conceptions have shaped many of
these writings, and that the factious spirit has often been guilty of
the willful omission of material, which was not of its side. He
distinctly avers that he felt it his duty to examine all writings of
this class according to his ability. Such was his intention. If now we
turn to his actual methods, we can group his ways of accumulating
material, somewhat as follows:—
(
a
) His own observation by hearing or sight, and
hence knowing, as in ii. 3; vii. 19, 28.
(
b
) By obtaining a personally clear knowledge,
the medium being undefined, as in the election of Maximus to be bishop
of Jerusalem, and Macarius’ sympathy therewith; here his better
information was probably due to his Palestinian origin.
᾽Ιστέον
μέντοι ὡς οἱ
τάδε
ἠκριβωκότες,
κατὰ γνώμην
Μακαρίου
γενέσθαί τε
καὶ
σπουδασθῆναι
τῷ πλήθει
ταῦτα,
ἰσχυρίζονται
(ii. 20). As to Serapion and Severianus
τὰ
μὲν ὧδε
ἔγνων
(viii. 10). As to Zechariah,
where the same phrase occurs (ix. 17). At the close of a universal
review of monasticism
τάδε
ἔγνων ὡς
συνέγραψα
(iii.
14). As to the Syrian and Persian monks
εἰς γνῶσιν
ἐμὴν ἦλθον
(vi.
34).
᾽Αλλὰ τὰ μὲν
ἀφηγησάμην
ἐφ᾽ ὅσον μοι
μαθεῖν
ἐξεγένετο,
περὶ τῶν τότε
ἐκκλησιαστικῶν
φιλοσόφων
(vi.
35).
(
c
) By hearing from those who knew the facts
ἅπερ
παρὰ ἀκριβῶς
ἐπισταμένων
ἀκήκοα
(ii. 21). As to Arsacius:
οἳ παρὰ
τῶν
᾽Αρσάκιον
αὐτὸν
θεασαμένων
ἀκηκοέναι
ἔφασαν
(iv. 16). As to the mutual
prophecies of Epiphanius and John
κἀκεῖνον δὲ
εἰσέτι νῦν
πολλῶν ὄντα
τὸν λόγον
ἐπυθόμην
(viii. 15).
As to Atticus:
καὶ τὸν
μὲν τοιόνδε
γενέσθαι
φασὶν, οἵ γε
τὸν ἄνδρα
ἔγνωσαν
(viii. 27).
(
d
) The
correction of a false story by inquiring of trustworthy persons. Thus
as to the origin of the Apocalypse of Paul.
᾽Ερομένῳ δέ
μοι περὶ
τούτου,
ψεῦδος
ἔφησεν εἶναι
Κίλιξ
(vii. 19). As to an accusation
against John:
τούτου
δὲ πρόφασιν
ἑτέραν
λέγειν οὐκ
ἔχω, πλὴν ὅτι
ἀψευδής τις
οἶμαι
πυθανομένῳ
περὶ τούτου
ἔφη, κ.τ.λ
. (viii. 9). The true
and twofold causes of difficulty between Theophilus and Isadore:
τῶν γε μὴν
συγγενομένων
τούτοις τότε
τοῖς
μοναχοῖς
ἀνδρὸς οἵου
πιστεύεσθαι
ἐπυθόμην,
κ.τ.λ
(viii. 12).
(
e
) To these may be added the very frequent usage
of
πυνθάνομαι
as a means of expressing his knowledge acquired in any form whatsoever,
by hearing, by inquiry, by tradition (i. 21, ii. 8, iii. 14, iv. 25, v.
2, 9, vi. 2 bis, 17, 34 bis, 37, vii. 8, 15, 17, 20, 21, 25, viii. 2,
7, 9, 19).
(
f
) Also his use of
ἀκριβόω
, showing his effort
to attain accurate information, and
ἰσχυρίζομαι
less frequently, to indicate the strongest confirmation. Both these are
used with reserve, and not lightly. Several times he acknowledges his
resort to tradition, when he uses the word
παρειλήφαμεν,
but we cannot always be sure of the form of
transmission (iii. 15, 30, vi. 38).
(
g
) Also his reference to those who had more
accurate information, or to works whose detail he could not reproduce,
or which lay without the province of history (iv. 3).
We see then an ideal and actual plan of research, and a
real effort at personal investigation; to deny his frequently iterated
language, is to accuse him of deliberate falsehood; and this is
palpably unfair; this his honest purpose and work must be borne in
mind, in the discussion of his relation to Socrates.
3. As to method in textual criticism, there is none; we
find variations in the texts quoted from those of Socrates, Athanasius,
and Theodoret, but no more in him than in the rest from one another.
When he reports Constantine’s speech, he treats it as Thucydides
did the orations of his worthies, and as the high-flying Eusebius and
the indiscriminating Theodoret do. When he copies a translation from
the Greek, he simply says that he gives it just as he found it. On the
whole, one is surprised at so fair an agreement in the readings of the
documents.
4. There is an entire lack of genuine analytical
criticism; the love of allegory (i. 1, ii. 1), the credence given to
the Christic sections of Josephus (i. 1), the unquestioning acceptance
of Eusebius’ turgid statements about Constantine’s life,
are proofs enough of its absence; and yet Sozomen was careful to
present the variety of accounts, so that one might have all points of
view, if he did not carefully sift the evidence. This is indeed quite a
marked feature of his method. Thus concerning the death of Arius, he
gives five different views (ii. 29, 30). He states carefully the
varying shades of opinion concerning Marcellus (ii. 33). The two
classes of views of the election of Macedonius are recorded and
skillfully weighed (iii. 3). The divisions of sentiment after the
Synods of Sardica and Philippopolis are accurately grouped (iii. 13).
Other instances occur in iii. 14, 18, 23, v. 2, 22, vi. 2, 12, 26, vii.
5, 22. These are but a selection of what is habitual with him, and show
a desire to present all sides of a question, and to reflect the
divergent convictions of his time about men and measures; but he does
not always try to find the just opinion and weigh the testimony; he
never tests the validity of his documents, and only a few times tries
to decide between clashing judgments, as to which of them rests on a
solid foundation of testimony. It is, however, to his credit, when he
confesses that his research is baffled, as in iv. 2, with respect to
the manner of Paul’s death, or suspends his judgment, because the
data are insufficient, as in the application to the empress, of
Chrysostom’s homily on female peccadilloes (viii. 6). Such
language shows that he not only sought to ascertain the truth, but to
elicit the facts out of conflicting testimony. We may not always think
the game worth the powder, but the temper and intent are
commendable.
5. Sozomen has a marked zeal for interpreting the events
of history; and we can gather these hints of histories, although they
do not seem to have been defined as principles in his own mind.
(
a
) He criticises by the rules of traditionalism
and monasticism; we find small men given undue prominence, and large
ones put far below their proper place (iv. 6, 9, 28, v. 7, 12, vi. 17,
26, vii. 12).
(
b
) He seems
to have regarded it his occasional duty to explain the moral intent of
a period, of the lives of men, of a special incident; in other words,
he used history reflectively and ethically (viii. 4, 12, 17).
(
c
) He is fertile in suggesting motives for which
he has no documentary warrant. The entire history of Julian is replete
with the insinuation of mean motives (
ὥς συμβάλλω
). The
solitary commendation of him for lowering the price of provisions in
Antioch (v. 19) is only a ground for holding him up to ridicule for
want of judgment (iii. 5, 15, v. 2, 4, 5, 11, 19, 15, 22, vi. 12).
(
d
) He deems it necessary to apologize for his
favorites if they are in a questionable position (iii. 18, v. 6, viii.
1).
(
e
) He thinks it right to give recognition to men
or measures who have enlisted his admiration (vii. 10).
(
f
) He traces cause and effect in a pragmatic way
(vi. 16, 38).
(
g
) He delights in taking prominent figures of a
period as the remarkable men who have created a remarkable time, and
are Divine instruments, or as objects of Divine protection on account
of their piety (iii. 13, 19, iv. 16, v. 13, vi. 17, 26, 27, viii. 3, 4,
6).
(
h
) He dwells at times on characteristics of
human nature at play (vi. 4, 26).
(
i
) He gives a favorable explanation of the bad
actions of the orthodox (iv. 16).
(
j
) He sometimes introduces speculative
explanations or reflections (vi. 2, 4, 37, viii. 5).
6. Chronological method. (1) The imperial reigns are
taken as the great periods for the books, and the material is
distributed under them; no dates are given, only the names of the
emperors. This is stated in the proëmium, and is carried out in
the history. (2) He uses the consulates—
(
a
) To mark the beginning and the end of the
entire history.
(
b
) Also occasionally to indicate the synchronous
occupants of the apostolic sees (i. 2); the convocation of a council
(iii. 12, 19, iv. 6, 17, vii. 12); the enthronement of a bishop (iv.
26); the death of an emperor (vii. 29, ix. 1); some general but
important event (vii. 5, viii. 4).
(
c
) With this the corresponding year of the
emperor is sometimes but rarely given.
(
d
) Another conspicuous chronological system with
Sozomen, as in Eusebius, Socrates, and the church historians in
general, is to keep up the roll of succession in the greater sees. This
had become an essential note of the visible and Catholic Church.
(
e
) Occasionally intervals are indicated as so
many years after such and such an event (iii. 5, 11, 12, iv. 1, ix.
1).
(
f
) The length of a reign or of an episcopate,
the duration of the life of an emperor or bishop, and of a tendential
period are stated, but not often, and without uniformity (iv. 11, v. 1,
vii. 5).
(
g
) An unusual number of particles for indefinite
time occur as substitutes for an exact method. Nevertheless, one of his
main purposes was to narrate his history in strict chronological order,
so as to contain the virtue of a chronicle together with a more
developed presentation of events. This is almost entirely forgotten,
except that the sequence of occurrences is fairly kept up. Yet he does
not hesitate to break through even this sequence, when he thinks the
collocation of later facts, under the head that he is writing of, may
contribute to clearness and completeness, as he directly avers in iii.
3, 14, iv. 10, 11, 12, v. 11, ix. 2. It is no easy task to make a
Regesta of Sozomen’s history; moreover, he often blunders in the
very few dates he gives, as well as in the arrangement of the events
themselves; these errors are due to the lack of a fixed system.
7. The contributions to geography are mainly confined to
Palestine. Passing more familiar ones, we have a list as follows:
Helenopolis (ii. 2), Majuma (ii. 5, v. 3, vii. 28), Anthedon,
Bethagathon, Asalea, Thabatha (iii. 14), Diocæsarea (iv. 17),
Bethelia (v. 15, vi. 32), Besan
duca, Capharchobia, Gerara (vi. 32), Botolium
(vii. 28), Ceila, Berathsabia with its tomb, Nephsameena (vii. 29),
Chaphar Zacharia (ix. 17). Most of these terms are Hebraic or Syrian.
Scythopolis is mentioned as abundant in palms (viii. 13). There is no
direct, and very little indirect light on the political or
ecclesiastical geography of the time; of course the seats of the
bishops and of the monks that are enumerated yield a few new names of
places. There are equally few hints in the physical features of the
empire; the great rains, or hail-storms, or earthquakes are recorded
chiefly with regard to their special ethical bearing. The topography of
Constantinople has been indicated previously; outside of these, details
of Alexandria, Antioch, Cæsarea, Cappadocia are given, but none of
them new.
8. Statistics. There is of course no method in the
presentation of statistics; there are general proportions, as in ii. 6,
iv. 27, v. 15, vi. 20; and special detail, as in the enumeration of
monks, iii. 14, vi. 29–34. The best illustration one finds in the
account of the Persian martyrs, where there was a distinct effort at
registration by Persian, Syrian, and Edessan authorities (ii. 13,
14).
9. Biography is one of the chief constituents of his
history. He gives us an account of most of the distinguished Christian
masters in theology, in monasticism, martyrdom, oratory, scholarship,
administration; and he is refreshingly fair in giving a place to those
who were not friendly to his view of the faith. Athanasius may be a
chief hero, but Arius is not neglected. Here we may observe that
Sozomen makes Aëtius the second head of rationalism, and the man
who gave it breadth of culture by building the system on the basis of
Aristotle (iii. 15, iv. 12); he regards Eunomius as but a reflection of
Aëtius (vi. 29). This position accorded to Aëtius is one
deserving special note and study. Philostorgius exalted Eunomius both
in his special encomium and in the history. Of course the two
Cappadocians, as well as Epiphanius and Chrysostom, are liberally
sketched. The imperial biography is fairly full, and a large space is
accorded Julian. In every book parts are devoted to the vitæ
sanctorum, as the best way to set before us the inner life of the
Church and the fairest exhibition of Christian character; these
monastic sketches are, for the most part, mere glimpses of individuals
(a line or two suffices); whereas the more conspicuous founders and
organizers, such as Antony, Hilarion, Pachomius, the Macarii, Evagrius,
receive a larger recognition. He feels the need of selection in the
multiplicity of illustrious characters, and after a sketch of Acacius,
Zeno, and Ajax, he says: “I have mentioned these as examples of
those who served as priests at this period. It would be a task to
enumerate all, when the major part of them were good, and God bore
testimony to their lives by readily hearing their prayers and by
working many miracles” (vii. 28). Prominent as is the
biographical element, and earnestly as he endeavors to substantiate its
claims, he confesses, as to Ephraim (iii. 16), “it would require
a more experienced hand than mine to furnish a full description of his
character and that of the other illustrious men, who, about the same
period, had devoted themselves to a life of philosophy; and it is to be
regretted that Ephraim did not enter upon this undertaking. The attempt
is beyond my powers, for I possess but little knowledge of those great
men, or of their exploits.”
10. In ecclesiastical culture we have many and important
incidental hints, but no direct general chapter except vii. 19; and on
special topics, those on the Easter controversy (i. 16, 21, vi. 24,
vii. 18, viii. 17) on the penitential presbyter (vii. 16), and on relic
worship, are the most significant.
11. Nor is there any methodical statement of growth in
the acquisition and exposition of truth; his traditionalism in a
measure precluded that, and his acknowledged incapacity to go deeply
into the differentiation of these discussions prevented any system;
there is no real history of dogma and ethics, except on the external
side. He is frank to say: “I leave their doctrines to be judged
by those whose right it is. For I have not set forth to record such
matters, nor is it befitting in history” (iii. 15); that he does
“not profess easily to understand or to expound these
matters” (vi. 27); and again, “I should be prolix were I to
enter into further particulars,
and
under the subject would be by no means an easy one to me, since I have
no such dialectic skill” (vii. 17). He furnishes us only with
such a statement of doctrine, as sprang out of polemics and councils
and the variety of creeds.
12. And so with the history of literature there is no
such sustained account of Christian writers and works as in Eusebius;
the second stage of historians did not see fit to be as complete and
accurate as their exemplar in this particular, and Photius was left to
gather up the fragments for us. What strikes us as peculiar is his
confessed ignorance of the works of the greatest theologians. He passes
by all the technical writings of Athanasius; he has no direct knowledge
of the works of Hilary, though that might be excused. Of the purely
theological works of Basil and Gregory Nazianzen, whom he regards as
the pillars of the Nicene faith, he makes no mention; and indeed makes
but the slightest use of their letters and special orations. Of the
Arian theologians of all shades, he has no closer knowledge; he
confesses at the outset that he had not read the Thalia (i. 21), but
condemns it on Socrates’ authority; and he speaks of Diodorus,
bishop of Tarsus, in language that displays unfamiliarity with his
treatises (viii. 2).
13. There are no conceptions of the philosophy of
history or of histories in general, other than those which have been
discussed before.
14. If we pass to the stylistics of Sozomen, we find the
quality of the Greek to be excellent; the dedication is especially
studied and rhetorical; the first chapter of the first book is scarcely
inferior in these traits, after which the form becomes more abrupt,
after the fashion of an epitomizer, and it is obviously affected by his
authorities. The likeness to Xenophon is not continuous, any more than
Socrates sustainedly imitates Thucydides, although in elevated
conception, Socrates is more in the vein of that philosophic master of
history, than Sozomen is a reflection of the writer of the Hellenics.
The vocabulary, too, is quite meager; the same forms of expression
occur again and again, yet Photius considers him superior in diction to
Socrates,
1053
which only one who admires mere form above spirit, can affirm.
Certainly it would not be the view of this more subjective age. Of
course he reflects the decline of meaning in particles and
prepositional prefixes and participial constructions. He does not begin
his books with formal prefaces, such as Socrates indulges in; chapter 1
of Book i. may, however, be regarded as introductory; and it serves to
link Christianity with Judaism. In the distribution of his material
there is no system agreeing with his own outline of aims or any other
order that is discoverable. The main topics are: Secular affairs,
relations of the emperor to Christianity, laws and privileges, missions
and persecutions, polemics and irenics, biographies ; but there is no
regular discussion of these, either under the reigns or in the books.
None of the historians are any better in this regard.
A characteristic of our historian is the admirable
generalization and the summaries he pauses to make here and there. The
most notable are in iii. 17, a generalized description of the period of
the Constantines. iii. 18, a doctrinal summary. iv. 17–19,
conciliar movement in the West. iv. 20–22, conciliar movement in
the East. iv. 23–25, united results. vi. 6, a succinct comparison
of Valens with Valentinian. vi. 10, geographical centers of Nicenism.
vi. 21, geographical centers of Arianism and Orthodoxy. vi. 22,
geographical distribution of Macedonianism. vi. 26, genesis of
Aëtianism (Eunomianism). vi. 27, geographical distribution of
beliefs. vi. 28–34, geographical grouping of the monks. vii. 2,
geographical supremacy of Arianism in the East. vii. 4, geographical
survey of religion. vii. 17, divisions of Arianism. viii. 1, summary of
Apostolic succession. The selective process is often alluded to (ii. 3,
iii. 14, 15, iv. 3, 23, 27, vii. 25, 28, ix. 1); and we must confess
that he has kept a very just proportion in this way among the subjects
he has elected for his narrative.
The Period described.
The work was to have covered the time from 323 to 439, a
period of 116 years; whereas, in fact, he writes continuously only to
the death of Honorius as the latest event, 423, and the
accession of Valentinian III. in 425; beyond
that in time, but mentioned anticipatively in the narrative (ix. 2), is
the transfer of the forty martyrs, which happened certainly after 434,
the year of the election of Proclus, therefore probably not far from
the proposed limit of his work, say 437 or 438; this would give a
period of about 114 or 115 years. He divides the record of this time
into nine books, distributed among the emperors.
i. and ii. To Constantine, 323–337=14.
iii. and iv. His sons, 337–361=24.
v. and vi. Julian, Jovian, Valentinian I., Valens,
361–375=17.
vii. and viii. Gratian and Valentinian II., Theodosius
I., Arcadius (and Honorius), 375–408=33.
ix. (Honorius) and Theodosius II., 408–437=25.
A noticeable feature, save in the case of Book ix., is
the grouping of books by twos, in which the intervals discussed vary
from fourteen to thirty-three years. This grouping seems entirely
arbitrary.
For whom he wrote.
The question for whom he wrote has been somewhat
obscured by those who regard him simply as a plagiarist. He evidently
turned himself to this task under the conviction that there was need of
some such work as his. He addressed himself chiefly to Christians and
not only to monks, because he defers to the narrow views of some
friends about the mysteries,—and represses creeds and sacraments,
for fear the book might fall into the hands of the uninitiated. He
moreover designed his record, not for the more learned classes, but for
the instruction of ordinary believers, since he professes uniformly a
great modesty in treating the profounder themes of theology and the
characters of the more eminent men. Yet he did not hesitate to submit
it to the criticism of his emperor and invited the most erasive and
final judgment. This is probably as far as we may go in the absence of
any direct address to specific readers.
The Sources
I. Those enumerated in his ideal plan (i. 1).
1. The transactions in which he was engaged.
2. The transactions in which others were engaged, who
either knew or saw the events in his day, or in prior generations.
3. Laws established concerning religion.
4. Acts of Synods.
5. Record of innovations.
6. Imperial letters.
7. Clerical letters.
II. The sources actually mentioned. (1) Documents.
a. Documents actually quoted with text.
The retractation, by Eusebius and Theognis (ii. 16).
The confession of Arius and Euzoïus to Constantine
(ii. 27).
The Epistle of Constantine to the Synod of Tyre (ii.
28).
Constantine Cæsar to the people of the Catholic
Church of the city of Alexandria (iii. 2).
Epistle of the Synod of Jerusalem in behalf of
Athanasius (iii. 22).
Ursacius and Valens to Julius (iii. 23).
Ursacius and Valens to Athanasius (iii. 24).
George of Laodicea to Macedonius, Basilius, Cecropius,
and Eugenius (iv. 13); new.
Epistle of Constantius to the church at Antioch (iv.
14); new.
Epistle of the Synod of Ariminum to the Emperor
Constantius (iv. 18).
Epistle of Julian to Arsacius, the high-priest of
Galatia (v. 16).
Epistle of Julian to the bishops, only a phrase quoted
(v. 18); new.
Synod at Antioch, to Jovian (vi. 4).
Eustathius,
Silvanus, and Theophilus to Liberius (vi. 11).
Synod of Rome to bishops of Illyricum (vi. 23); first
with Sozomen; repeated by Theodoret (
H. E
. ii. 22).
Innocent to John (viii. 26); also in Palladius’
Dial.
Innocent to the presbyters, deacons, all the clergy, and
the people of the church of Constantinople (viii. 26); also in
Palladius’ Dial.
There are five imperial letters, four synodical letters,
seven episcopal letters, one presbyterial letter, making seventeen in
all. This is not nearly so large a number as is given by Socrates, but
we must remember the expressed purpose of Sozomen, that, as a rule, he
would give abstracts only, and text when in his judgment fairness made
it necessary. Of these documents, there are at least three found in no
earlier author. In them all, there is only one symbol transcribed, and
that is from Arius and Euzoïus!
b. Documentary acts of Synods which are mentioned by
name.
Acts of the Synod of Tyre (ii. 25).
Acts of the Synod of Seleucia, taken down by
tachygraphists (iv. 22).
c. Acts of those Synods only, of which an abstract is
recorded.
Alexandria............................... i. 15.
Seleucia..................................... iv. 22,
23.
Bithynia................................... i. 15.
Constantinople........................... iv. 24,
25.
Palestine.................................. i. 15.
Alexandria................................. v. 12.
Egyptian.................................. i. 16.
Macedonian Council, s.l............. v. 14.
Nicæa..................................... i.
17–23.
Antioch...................................... vi. 4.
Antioch................................... ii. 19.
Lampsacus................................. vi. 7.
Tyre........................................ ii. 25.
Nicæa........................................ vi.
8.
Jerusalem................................ ii. 27.
Macedonian, s.l.......................... vi. 10,
11.
Constantinople......................... ii. 29, 33.
Sicily.......................................... vi.
12.
Constantinople......................... iii. 3.
Tyana........................................ vi.
12.
Antioch................................... iii. 2.
In Caria..................................... vi.
12.
Antioch................................... iii. 8.
Rome......................................... vi.
23.
Philippopolis............................ iii. 11.
Pazucomen................................ vi. 24.
Sardica.................................... iii. 11,
12.
Rome......................................... vi.
25.
Jerusalem................................ iii. 21,
22.
Antioch (Caria).......................... vii. 2.
Alexandria............................... iv. 1.
Constantinople........................... vii.
7–9.
Sirmium................................... iv. 6.
Sangurum................................... vii. 18.
Antioch................................... iv. 8.
Constantinople........................... viii. 2.
Milan....................................... iv. 9.
Cyprus....................................... viii.
14.
Antioch................................... iv. 12.
Of the Oak at Chalcedon........... viii. 17.
Ancyra.................................... iv. 13.
Constantinople........................... viii. 19.
Ariminum................................. iv.
16–19, 23.
Constantinople........................... viii. 20.
d. Letters of which an abstract is given, or the general
object is stated.
Constantine’s Letter to Alexander and
Arius.............................................................. i.
16.
Imperial Letters about the Nicene
Council.................................................................
i. 21, 25.
Constantine to
Sapor................................................................................................
ii. 15.
Constantine to the people of
Alexandria....................................................................
ii. 22.
Constantine to
Athanasius.........................................................................................
ii. 23.
Synod of Tyre to the
bishops....................................................................................
ii. 25.
Antony’s letters to the
Emperor.................................................................................
ii. 31.
Constantine’s letter to the
Alexandrians.....................................................................
ii. 31.
Eusebius to
Julius......................................................................................................
iii. 7.
Julius, bishop of Rome, to the bishops of the
East...................................................... iii. 8.
Synod of Antioch to
Julius.........................................................................................
iii. 8.
Constantius to Philip, prefect of
Constantinople.........................................................
iii. 9.
Bishops of Egypt in favor of
Athanasius.....................................................................
iii. 10.
Julius to the bishops of
Antioch.................................................................................
iii. 10.
Constans to
Constantius............................................................................................
iii. 10.
Constans to
Constantius............................................................................................
iii. 11.
Athanasius to
Constans.............................................................................................
iii. 11.
Paul, bishop of
Constantinople..................................................................................
iii. 11.
The bishops of Philippopolis to the bishops of the
West............................................. iii. 11.
Constans to
Constantius............................................................................................
iii. 20.
Constantius to
Athanasius.........................................................................................
iii. 20.
Constantius to the
Alexandrians.................................................................................
iii. 20.
Julius to clergy and people of
Alexandria...................................................................
iii. 20.
Constantius to the bishops, presbyters, and to the
people of the
church of
Alexandria...........................................................................................
iii. 21.
Cyril of Jerusalem to
Constantius...............................................................................
iv. 5.
Constantius to
Athanasius.........................................................................................
iv. 9.
Constantius to Basil of
Ancyra..................................................................................
iv. 16.
Basil of Ancyra to
Constantius..................................................................................
iv. 16.
Constantius to
Basil..................................................................................................
iv. 16.
Basil to all the
bishops...............................................................................................
iv. 16.
Athanasius to a
friend................................................................................................
iv. 17.
Constantius to the Synod of
Ariminum.......................................................................
iv. 19.
Reply of the
bishops.................................................................................................
iv. 19.
Julian to the
Alexandrians..........................................................................................
v. 7.
Titus of Bostra to
Julian.............................................................................................
v. 15.
Julian to Jewish patriarchs, leaders, and
people.......................................................... v.
22.
Reply of the
Jews.....................................................................................................
v. 22.
Julius to Arsacius, king of
Armenia............................................................................
vi. 1.
Jovian to the governors of the
provinces....................................................................
vi. 3.
Basil of Ancyra, Silvanus of Tarsus, Sophronius of
Pompeiopolis
et al
., to
Jovian...................................................................................................
vi. 4.
Liberius and the Western bishop to the
East.............................................................. vi.
12.
Memorial of grievances presented by eighty ecclesiastics
to Valens............................ vi. 13.
Damasus in behalf of Peter of
Alexandria...................................................................
vi. 39.
Synodical epistles of Rome to Paulinus, bishop of
Antioch......................................... vii. 11.
Western bishops and Gratian to the Eastern
bishops.................................................. vii. 11.
Irenic letters to the adherents of Flavian from the
priests of Egypt and the West.......... viii. 3.
Theophilus of Alexandria, paschal
letter.....................................................................
viii. 11.
Theophilus of Alexandria to
Epiphanius.....................................................................
viii. 14.
Epiphanius to the bishops and the bishop of
Constantinople against Origenism............ viii. 14.
2. Authors.
(
a
) Authors from whose works a textual quotation
appears.
Apolinarius, the Syrian, on the succession of
Athanasius.......................................... ii. 17, new.
Extract from Athanasius’
Epistola ad Episcopos
Ægypti et Libyæ
........................ ii. 30.
Extract from Libanius, the Sophist;
in oratione
funebri de laudibus Juliani
........... vi. 1.
Gregory Nazianzen to Nectarius, on Apolinarius;
Ep
. ccii....................................... vi. 27.
The first extract alone is known through no other
source.
(
b
) Authors and works directly referred to as
used.
The
Sibyl.........................................................................................................
i. 1, ii. 1.
Josephus.........................................................................................................
i. 1.
Clemens
(Romanus).........................................................................................
i. 1.
Hegesippus......................................................................................................
i. 1.
Julius
Africanus................................................................................................
i. 1.
Eusebius Pamphili,
Historia
Ecclesiastica
.......................................................
i. 1.
Vita
Constantini
.............................................................................................
i. 3, extract.
Philo
(Pythagorean).........................................................................................
i. 12.
Biographies of
Monks......................................................................................
i. 14.
Eusebius’
Oration............................................................................................
i. 19.
Address of
Constantine....................................................................................
i. 19.
Collection of Nicene
Canons............................................................................
i. 22.
Syrians’ Account of the actions and life of Bishop
Milles................................... ii. 14.
Persian, Syrian, Edessan, martyrology of
Persians............................................. ii. 14.
Discourse of Eudoxius, extract
from.................................................................
iv. 26.
Meletius’ first discourses at
Antioch.................................................................
iv. 28.
Athanasius, on his
flight....................................................................................
v. 12.
(
c
) Authors and their works mentioned, but not
used.
Arius, the Thalia, not
read................................................................................
i. 21.
Eustathius, bishop of
Antioch...........................................................................
ii. 19.
Marcellus (
de Subjectione Filii
Dei
)...............................................................
ii. 33.
Asterius, a treatise on the defense of the Arian
doctrine..................................... ii. 33.
Acacius, bishop of Cæsarea,
works.................................................................
iii. 2.
Eustathius, bishop of Sebaste, an ascetic treatise, also
attributed
to Basil the
Great.......................................................................................
iii. 14.
Eusebius, bishop of Emesa,
works...................................................................
iii. 14.
Titus, bishop of Bostra,
works.........................................................................
iii. 14.
Serapion, bishop of Ancyra,
works..................................................................
iii. 14.
Eudoxius, bishop of Germanicia,
works............................................................ iii.
14.
Acacius, bishop of Cæsarea,
works.................................................................
iii. 14.
Cyril, bishop of Jerusalem,
works.....................................................................
iii. 14.
Didymus,
works..............................................................................................
iii. 15.
Lucifer, bishop of Calaris,
works......................................................................
iii. 15.
Hilary, bishop of Pictavium,
works...................................................................
iii. 15, v. 13.
Aëtius,
works..................................................................................................
iii. 15.
Ephraim Syrus, works and
translations.............................................................
iii. 16.
Bardasanes,
poems..........................................................................................
iii. 16.
Harmonius,
poems...........................................................................................
iii. 16.
Photinus, a work before Constantius, and many
works..................................... iv. 6.
Acacius, literary
works....................................................................................
iv. 23.
Apolinarius, works, with those against
him........................................................ v. 18, vi.
27.
Julian,
Misopogon............................................................................................
v. 19.
Eunomius, works, especially Exercises for the Mind,
with those against
him................................................................................
vi. 27, vii. 17.
Evagrius,
works...............................................................................................
vi. 30.
Themistius, oration,
outline...............................................................................
vi. 36.
Ulfilas, translation of Bible into
Gothic..............................................................
vi. 37.
Sisinnius, bishop of the Novatians in Constantinople,
works.............................. viii. 1.
Diodorus, bishop of Tarsus,
works...................................................................
viii. 2.
Theodore, bishop of Mopsuestia,
works.......................................................... viii.
2.
Chrysostom,
Ep
. to
Theodore..........................................................................
viii. 2.
——on
Eutropius............................................................................................
viii. 7.
——Vices of
females......................................................................................
viii. 16.
——Extempore discourse after his
return......................................................... viii.
18.
——About the Silver
Statue............................................................................
viii. 20.
Origen, works; especially the one from which Bishop
Theotimus read............... viii. 14.
An unecclesiastic but ancient Hebrew
document............................................... ix. 17.
(
d
) Hymns of which a line or thought is
given.
Refrain of the odes at
Antioch..........................................................................
iii. 20.
At procession of Babylas,
Antioch...................................................................
v. 19.
To Dionysos, by Epiphanius the
Sophist........................................................... vi.
25.
Arian
hymns....................................................................................................
viii. 8.
Unmentioned
Authorities.
Sozomen has refrained in large measure from indicating
directly his chief authorities for political or ecclesiastical affairs;
he has indicated, indeed, some minor springs, as we have seen, but the
major ones are passed by. He imitated neither Eusebius, nor Socrates,
nor Evagrius in this omission. He does abound in phrases indicative of
authorities; thus of the forms of
λέγω,
λέγουσι,
λέγονται,
ἔλεγον,
ἐλέγετο
are used somewhat
sparingly, while
λέγεται
occurs over
eighty times, and
λόγος
about twenty; of
φήμι,
ἔφησεν
and
φήμη
occasionally, while
φησί
or
φασί
introduces about thirty
statements;
εἰρήσθω
and
εἰρήται
also
appear in a few cases. One has no assurance of either the method or the
validity of the sources from such vague terms, and it is this uncertain
and incautious manner that has so often led critics to impeach his
general worth, and it must be conceded with some degree of justice; the
endless iteration of such words savors of gossip rather than history;
this obscurity is not diminished by his persistent
οἶμαι
and less frequent
εἰκάζω
.
1. In the discussion of his unmentioned authorities, the
first to be considered is Socrates. He is nowhere hinted at, unless
under an indefinite “some say,” when Sozomen presents a
group of opinions.
Socrates preceded Sozomen by a few years, writing his
history not long after 439.
1054
Sozomen undoubtedly produced his record later, as we have already seen,
and it would be just as likely that Socrates should be in the hands of
Sozomen as that Philip of Side’s contemporary Christian History
should have been open to the criticism of Socrates; indeed, the
predecessor’s work was quite probably an incentive to the task
proposed by Sozomen to himself. The internal evidence makes the use
sure. We have only to note how Socrates derived his statements about
the Novatians from members connected with that body of believers; these
very facts are reproduced by Sozomen as Socrates gives them, with the
slightest of differences; there is no refutation of this possible.
Socrates, therefore, manifestly preceded, and Sozomen employed the
material thus amassed.
There are three views of the connection: (1) that
Sozomen, excepting a few and not very valuable additions of his own,
plagiarized Socrates; (2) that he used the same authorities as Socrates
independently, and the points of identity arose from the language of
the original in the hands of both; (3) that Socrates was his guide to
the chief writers from whom he drew directly with more or less freedom;
and when no other light presented itself or was to be found, he would
use his path-finder. There is scarcely a more fascinating and genuine
field for analytical criticism than this. It should be remarked at the
outset that we cannot justly apply this term plagiarism, in its modern
sense, to the use of material current in these earlier days of history.
There was no more intention to appropriate the work of another in
Sozomen, than there was in Socrates, when he fails to note his
authority, and yet very evidently has followed him closely; or when
Theodoret has taken his stuff from Sozomen, and says nothing about the
original. To assail Sozomen as if he were a deliberate thief, and
stigmatize him as a feeble reviser of Socrates, is wholly unfair and
unwarranted by the general usage of his day and by the facts of the
case. In no way can it be proved that Sozomen was a general plagiarist
in the opprobrium and iniquity conveyed by the modern use of that term.
That Socrates was the finer mind, that he had larger sympathies, that
he was concerned to reproduce documents in an ampler degree, that he
follows the development of the Church with a sharper and brighter
criticism, no one can doubt; he is conspicuously superior in almost
every quality of a historian, and confined himself more nearly to the
modern idea of which the science should aim to do; but that does not
set aside the distinct and supplemental value of Sozomen and his
fullness in lines, however zigzag, which had been neglected by others.
The acknowledged precedence of Socrates does not warrant us in
assailing the fidelity of the lesser light. Since the notes are
designed to indicate the relationship between
the two, the passages need not be anticipated
here. (2) The second view, that Sozomen made an independent use of the
same source which Holzhausen revived, Stäudlin supported, Hefele
and Nolte have espoused, seems less tenable than the first. The
Novatian material cannot, under any possible conditions, be so
explained; the arrangement of the details in eight of the books will
not permit view. The very corrections of that arrangement require us to
be convinced that Socrates was in the corrector’s eye; the close
resemblance of language in many places where he might easily have
expanded from the originals, but preferred to confine himself to the
equally meagre tracings of his predecessor, leave no basis for this
solution. (3) The third explanation of the interrelation seems thus far
the most accurate.
1055
Sozomen took Socrates for a guide in the main, (
a
) as to
consecution of events, (
b
) as to sources, much as students would
use a Church history to base their own studies upon. Socrates was a
director to the authorities; these Sozomen would use freely; when they
failed him, he would take the facts given by Socrates, precisely as he
did those which Eusebius or Sabinus furnished, because he had nothing
better, and in spite probably of his own inquiries; for let us remember
how he insists that he has investigated the originals, and that he had
been conscientious in his researches. Now it must be said in further
modification of this statement:
(
a
) That some of the sources obviously consulted
by both were doubtless known to Sozomen without Socrates to point them
out. Rufinus and Eusebius and Sabinus were known to everybody. In all
such cases we may concede an independent reading of those authors, and
yet the order in which the subject-matter is arranged is at times more
that of his guide-book than of his original.
(
b
) Moreover, he introduces many new outlines and
abstracts, particularly in the transactions of the synods.
(
c
) He also has independent sources of
biography.
(
d
) His ninth book is wholly unique and entirely
out of the leading-strings of the master, for unexplained reasons.
The notes also try to indicate in a measure these more
independent traits.
2. The next unmentioned source is Rufinus, in his
continuation of Eusebius in two books; this Sozomen certainly read
independently of Socrates, very likely in a Greek translation. That
author’s
Historia Monachorum
also was sifted for a few of
the monastic biographies; in these cases there is a closer resemblance
to Rufinus than to the parallel sketches of Palladius.
3. Eusebius’ Life of Constantine is a primary
source for Books i. and ii. In all the events pertaining to that
emperor, it is drawn upon freely, just as freely as Socrates employs
it, or as Sozomen handles Socrates.
4. Athanasius is also used independently, although in
collocating the events, Socrates is followed. There is direct reference
to one work only (v. 12), as we have seen. The unmentioned are as
follows:—
The Life of St. Antony:
Antonii Vita
.
Epistola de Synodis Arimini in Italia et
Seleuciæ in Isauria celebratis
.
Epistola ad Serapionem, de morte Arii
.
Synodicon
; lost.
Tomus ad Antiochenses
.
Epistola ad Episcopos Ægypti et Libyæ; ep.
encyclica contra Arianos
.
Epistola Encyclica ad Episcopos
.
Historia Arianorum ad Monachos
.
Apologia contra Arianos
.
Apologia ad Constantium imperatorem
.
Epistolæ heortasticæ
.
5. Philostorgius:
Historia Ecclesiastica
, also
furnished occasional material, as even the excerpts remaining to us
indicate.
6. Sabinus:
Collection of Synods (
Συναγώγη
τῶν
συνόδων
), which is lost;
this book was written in the Macedonian and Arian interest; the author
is mentioned by Socrates and criticised for his partiality. We can
observe how Sozomen used it, where he adds to the statements of
Socrates, which the latter had borrowed from that work. These additions
are quite frequent in the transactions of the synods; and again a few
records of councils, otherwise unknown, are thus preserved for us. We
have here a proof of how Sozomen improved on his guide in the
details.
7. Philippus of Side; the Christian History (
χριστιανικὴ
ἱστορία
); a few fragments
are preserved; Socrates criticises him severely.
1056
8. For the laws, outside of the records alluded to, he
probably used the
Codex Gregorianus
and the
Codex
Hermogenianus
, his old text-books, and not unlikely the
Codex
Theodosianus
(438).
9. Basil the Great: the limited use is indicated by the
notes.
10. Gregory Nazianzen:
Orationes contra Julianum
.
Other occasional citations are indicated in the notes.
11. Sulpicius Severus:
vita S. Martini
was
undoubtedly the source, possibly through a Greek translation of the
same, for the summary of that saint’s life in iii. 14.
Historia sacra
: sometimes there is a hint as if
this work had been before him.
12. Palladius:
Historia Lausica
was not so
constant a companion as some have suggested; Sozomen has rather
borrowed from the sources out of which the bishop of Helenopolis
gathered his sketches of the monks.
Dialogus de vita S. Joannis Chrysostomi
was used
in narrating the incidents of John’s life in Book viii. There is
no indication of any large draught of Chrysostom’s own writings:
they may have been used for a few suggestions, contained in the
orations before mentioned.
One does not feel sure that Hieronymus or Orosius came
under his eye.
He does not seem to have made any direct use of Ammianus
Marcellinus (
Res gestæ
), nor of the earlier Latin
chroniclers. The points of resemblance with Eutropius (
Breviarium
Historiæ Romanæ
) are very doubtful in my judgment;
Eunapius (
ex historia excerpta et fragmenta
) seems to have been
used in his full form; Zosimus (
Historia
) pretty surely; and for
the ninth book, hardly with a doubt the full Olympiodorus, of whom
fragments only remain, and yet in that same ninth book there are
entirely independent political chapters whose source cannot yet be
determined.
The Ninth Book.
The most curious feature of all is Book ix., in the
entire change of its method; even were the ecclesiastical affairs to
have been presented, he has given here in remarkable excess the events
affecting the Western state; he has done it nowhere else; to be sure,
he proposes it as a demonstration of the value of imperial piety, and
of the ever-present Divine grace, but nowhere else has he done this in
so cumulative a form. Some wonderful change came over his purpose,
whether that were a fuller view of the relation between state and
church, or the desire to deepen the impression of his philosophy of
history; or did some imperial domestic catastrophe make him reluctant
to dwell upon the sad events which darkened the court he had so
glorified?
The grave question arises, Is anything of Book ix.
lost?
That it is unfinished cannot be doubted; for (a) In the
Proëmium he announces his purpose to carry it to the year
a.d.
439, or the seventeenth consulate of
Theodosius; but this is not done with any of his ordinary fullness,
although his hints reach beyond, as we have seen. (b) In lauding
Pulcheria (ix. 1) he remarks, “That new heresies have not
prevailed in our time, we shall find to be due especially to her, as we
shall subsequently see.” Here is the declared purpose of
delineating the history of Nestorianism and its overthrow, but there is
no appearance of the struggle in the record itself; he altogether
passes by Nestorius, as bishop of Constantinople. (c) The
record of the forty martyrs he purposely took
out of its normal order, to illustrate the excellence of Pulcheria; a
late event is anticipated, but the whole of what would have been its
normal setting is not there. (d) One would naturally expect that a book
which had thus far treated mainly of state difficulties would have the
usual balance, at least, and that ecclesiastical affairs would have
preponderated in the remaining chapters; but there is only an initial
chapter. Seventeen chapters are not his usual tale for a book; there is
an evident break; the discussion of Nestorianism is not written. Most
of all would one expect some allusion to the restoration of Chrysostom
under Proclus. (e) In ix. 16, he says, “Among other relics, those
of Zechariah, the very ancient prophet, and of Stephen, who was
ordained deacon by the Apostles, were discovered; and it seems
incumbent upon me to describe the mode, since the discovery of each was
marvelous and divine;” but he gives only the invention of
Zechariah (c. 17). The story of Stephen fails us, and would doubtless
have followed immediately. It was his purpose to narrate the
story,—this story which Theophanes and Marcellinus mention and
Lucianus wrote a book about. (f) In c. ix. 17, this is confirmed; for
he says, “I shall first speak of the relics of the
prophet”; to his second he does not come. (g) The close is
abrupt; one feels instinctively that something is amiss. Hence the
work, as we have it, is obviously not complete.
Did he finish it, and is the conclusion lost?
The mistake into which Gregory I. fell in ascribing to
Sozomen the commendation of Theodore of Mopsuestia, with which
Theodoret really closes his history, led Baronius to maintain that we
did not have the whole of Sozomen; and others have asserted the same
for reasons which are indeed sufficient to prove that the history is
unfinished, but not that anything is lost. That we have all that
Sozomen wrote is more likely, because the Tripartite History at x. 24
makes the last use of Sozomen at viii. 25; it would surely have gone
further in its dependence upon him had the later controversy been
treated of, since he had been already a chief authority. Nicephorus
Callistus,
Historia Ecclesiastica
, xiv. 8, gives the account of
the finding of Zechariah in c. 9; the story of Stephen in c. 10; then
the story of the forty martyrs. His source beyond is Socrates, until
Evagrius takes up the thread of affairs. If Sozomen had written the
more recent events parallel with Socrates, Nicephorus would undoubtedly
have followed him as before. Of Theophanes, one cannot speak so
confidently. Moreover, we cannot help asking, since we have Socrates,
Theodoret, and Evagrius complete, why should Sozomen, who was so
admired an author, have suffered any loss? Now, if we have Sozomen
entire so far as he wrote, why did he stop where he did? There are no
sufficient subjective reasons to be offered. It could scarcely have
been in any unfavorable criticism of his prince, for the work seems to
have been accepted by his imperial patron; and there was certainly
nothing as objectionable in Sozomen, as in Socrates or in Olympiodorus.
Nor is it likely that the unhappiness which invaded the court, the
domestic jealousies, which rent its religious as well as connubial
peace, or the quarrels over Cyrus or Paulinus or Chrysaphius, in any
way restrained him; for he was beyond some, if not all of these
agitations, at the time of his writing, and he had deliberately chosen
to ignore such noble personages as Anthemius, Troïlus, Synesius,
Aurelianus, and Eudocia, so that we can argue little from his silence,
save his manifest jealousy for Pulcheria, and his hostility to certain
more liberal tendencies developed under Eudocia. The Nestorian
controversy would have been a choice field wherein to exalt the
influence of Pulcheria, as he himself suggested. On the whole, one is
constrained to believe that Sozomen died before he had completed the
record which he had proposed to himself. He must have been nearing his
seventieth year when thus suddenly arrested in his chosen study.
The Major uses made of his Work.
The major uses of him subsequently were by:
(a) Epiphanius Scholasticus, who made a translation into
Latin, which Cassiodorus abbreviated, polished, and incorporated in the
Historia Tripartita
.
1057
(b) The deacon
Liberatus, in his
Historia Nestorianorum
, used the
Tripartita
.
(c) Theophanes, in his
Chronographia
.
(d) Theodorus Lector in his
Historia
Tripartita
.
(e) Nicephorus Callistus, in his
Historia
Ecclesiastica
incorporating Theodorus’
Tripartita
.
The Errors.
The errors are numerous, as already suggested by
Possevin, on dogmatic grounds; Du Pin, and more recently by Harnack,
for historic reasons. They are due to the lack of a systematic
chronology, and the blind copying of his authority, especially
Socrates, and occasionally to his attempts to correct the order given
by his authority.
1048
Otto,
Corp. App
. Vol. ix. (Migne,
P.
G.
vi.).
1049
See his epigrams in
Anth. Gr
.
1050
Güldenpinning thinks there may be a suggestion
of the fatal apple in Sozomen’s praise of his sovereign’s
abstemiousness. I would like to agree, but cannot.
Die Kirchengesch.
des Theodoret von Kyrrhos
, pp. 12, 13.
1051
Heraclea Pontica of the maps.
1052
Marcell.
Am. Chron. s. d
.;
Chron. Pasch.
s. d
.;
Novell. Theod
. xxiii. 5, 21.
1053
Myrobib. cod. XXX.
1054
H. E
. vii. 48.
1055
Jeep:
Quellenuntersuchungen zu den griechischen
Kirchenhistorikern
, pp. 137–147.
1056
H. E
. vii. 27.
1057
See preface of that work.