Such is, in brief, the evidence which the Ecumenical
Councils give on the subject of what, for lack of a better designation,
may be called the Papal claims. Under these circumstances it may
not be deemed strange that some extreme ultramontanists have arrived at
the conclusion that much of the acts and decisions as we have them is
spurious, or at least corrupted in an anti-papal direction.
Vincenzi, who is the most learned of these writers, argues somewhat
thus “if the members of the Ecumenical Synods believed as we do
to-day with regard to the Papacy it is impossible that they should have
acted and spoken as they did, but we know they must have believed as we
do, ergo they did not so act or speak.” The logic is
admirable, but the truth of the conclusion depends upon the truth of
the minor premise. The forgeries would have been very extensive,
and who were they done by? Forgeries, as the false decretals, to
advance papal claims we are unfortunately familiar with, but it is hard
to imagine who could have forged in Greek and Latin the acts of the
Ecumenical Synods. It is not necessary to pursue the matter any
further, perhaps its very mention was uncalled for, but I wish to be
absolutely fair, that no one may say that any evidence has been
suppressed. The reader may easily
satisfy himself on this matter by reading the somewhat extensive works
of Aloysius Vincenzi, published in Rome in 1875 and thereabouts.