Chapter X.
What words indeed could possibly express the greatness of that loss in falling away from
the possession of real goodness? What consummate power of thought would have to be
employed! Who could produce even in outline that which speech cannot tell, nor the mind
grasp? On the one hand, if a man has kept the eye of his heart so clear that he can in a way
behold the promise of our Lord’s Beatitudes realized, he will condemn all human utterance
as powerless to represent that which he has apprehended. On the other hand, if a man from
the atmosphere of material indulgences has the weakness of passion spreading like a film
over the keen vision of his soul, all force of expression will be wasted upon him; for it is all
one whether you understate or whether you magnify a miracle to those who have no power
whatever of perceiving it1395. Just as, in the case of the sunlight, on one who has never from
the day of his birth seen it, all efforts at translating it into words are quite thrown away; you
cannot make the splendour of the ray shine1396 through his ears; in like manner, to see the
beauty of the true and intellectual light, each man has need of eyes of his own; and he who
by a gift of Divine inspiration can see it retains his ecstasy unexpressed in the depths of his
consciousness; while he who sees it not cannot be made to know even the greatness of his
loss. How should he? This good escapes his perception, and it cannot be represented to him;
it is unspeakable, and cannot be delineated. We have not learnt the peculiar language ex-
pressive of this beauty. An example of what we want to say does not exist in the world; a
comparison for it would at least be very difficult to find. Who compares the Sun to a little
spark? or the vast Deep to a drop? And that tiny drop and that diminutive spark bear the
same relation to the Deep and to the Sun, as any beautiful object of man’s admiration does
to that real beauty on the features of the First Good, of which we catch the glimpse beyond
any other good. What words could be invented to show the greatness of this loss to him
who suffers it? Well does the great David seem to me to express the impossibility of doing
this. He has been lifted by the power of the Spirit out of himself, and sees in a blessed state
of ecstacy the boundless and incomprehensible Beauty; he sees it as fully as a mortal can see
who has quitted his fleshly envelopments and entered, by the mere power of thought, upon
355
the contemplation of the spiritual and intellectual world, and in his longing to speak a word
worthy of the spectacle he bursts forth with that cry, which all re-echo, “Every man a liar1397!”
I take that to mean that any man who entrusts to language the task of presenting the ineffable
Light is really and truly a liar; not because of any hatred on his part of the truth, but because
of the feebleness of his instrument for expressing the thing thought of1398. The visible beauty
1395 ἀναισθήτως ἐχόντων; Reg. Cod.
1396 αὐγάζειν; intrans. in N.T.
1397 Ps. cxvi. 11.
1398 οὐχὶ τῷ μίσει τῆς ἀληθείας ἀλλὰ τῇ ἀσθενεί& 139· τῆς διηγήσεως, the reading of Codd. Vatican & Reg.
Chapter X
656
Chapter X