With Luke’s narrative of the Apostolic council at Jerusalem
should be compared Paul’s (Gal. ii.) which gives
additional particulars. The conference marked an epoch in the history
of the church. Here came into decisive conflict two opposing
tendencies—the Pharisaic tendency which insisted that the
Gentiles must enter the Kingdom through the door of the law, and the
catholic spirit which, following the principles of Stephen’s
apology and appreciating the revelations made to Peter, insisted that
adherence to the Mosaic law was not only unnecessary, but was
positively inconsistent with the freedom and completeness of
Christ’s salvation. The decree of the council was, no doubt, of
great service in checking the Judaizing tendencies of the early church.
It was in the line of this decree that the work of Paul was done, as
the champion of catholic Christianity. The chief points to be noted
in v. 1–12 are: (1) The
representatives of the narrower Jewish view came to Antioch on purpose
to antagonize the work of Paul and Barnabas among the Gentiles
(v. 1). (2) They took the
extreme position that salvation depended on circumcision and caused
great anxiety and debate among the Gentile Christians regarding their
relations to the Mosaic law (v.
2).
(3) The Apostles and messengers who were sent to appeal the question to
the leaders of the mother church at Jerusalem answered their objections
by the fact of the Gentiles’ conversion (v. 3–5). (4)
Peter’s position was now clear and pronounced. This is implied
even in his subsequent conduct at Antioch whence he withdrew from the
Gentiles (Gal. ii. 11 sq.) which Paul represents as an inconsistency. (5)
Peter’s view is first given both on account of his prominence
among the Apostles and because he had been the first to bear the gospel
to the Gentiles.—G.B.S.