‘Now this declaration of faith being propounded by
them, we did not neglect to investigate the distinct sense of the
expressions “of the substance of the Father, and consubstantial
with the Father.” Whereupon questions were put forth and answers,
and the meaning of these terms was clearly defined; when it was
generally admitted that ousias (of the essence or substance)
simply implied that the Son is of the Father indeed, but does not
subsist as a part of the Father. To this interpretation of the sacred
doctrine which declares that the Son is of the Father, but is not a
part of his substance, it seemed right to us to assent. We ourselves
therefore concurred in this exposition; nor do we cavil at the word
“homoousios” having regard to peace, and fearing to
lose a right understanding of the matter. On the same grounds we
admitted also the expression “begotten, not made”:
“for made,” said they, “is a term applicable
in common to all the creatures which were made by the Son, to whom the
Son has no resemblance. Consequently he is no creature like those which
were made by him, but is of a substance far excelling any creature;
which substance the Divine Oracles teach was begotten of the Father by
such a mode of generation as cannot be explained nor even conceived by
any creature.” Thus also the declaration that “the Son is
consubstantial with the Father” having been discussed, it was
agreed that this must not be understood in a corporeal sense, or in any
way analogous to mortal creatures; inasmuch as it is neither by
division of substance, nor by abscission nor by any change of the
Father’s substance and power, since the underived nature of the
Father is inconsistent with all these things. That he is consubstantial
with the Father then simply implies, that the Son of God has no
resemblance to created things, but is in every respect like the Father
only who begat him; and that he is of no other substance or essence but of the
Father. To which doctrine, explained in this way, it appeared right to
assent, especially since we knew that some eminent bishops and learned
writers among the ancients have used the term
“homoousios” in their theological discourses
concerning the nature of the Father and the Son. Such is what I have to
state to you in reference to the articles of faith which have been
promulgated; and in which we have all concurred, not without due
examination, but according to the senses assigned, which were
investigated in the presence of our most highly favored emperor, and
for the reasons mentioned approved. We have also considered the
anathema pronounced by them after the declaration of faith inoffensive;
because it prohibits the use of illegitimate
ἀγράφοις: lit.
‘unwritten,’ but defined by Hesychius as above.
terms, from which almost all the distraction and commotion of the
churches have arisen. Accordingly, since no divinely inspired Scripture
contains the expressions, “of things which do not exist,”
and “there was a time when he was not,” and such other
phrases as are therein subjoined, it seemed unwarrantable to utter and
teach them: and moreover this decision received our sanction the rather
from the consideration that we have never heretofore been accustomed to
employ these terms. We deemed it incumbent on us, beloved, to acquaint
you with the caution which has characterized both our examination of
and concurrence in these things: and that on justifiable grounds we
resisted to the last moment the introduction of certain objectionable
expressions as long as these were not acceptable; and received them
without dispute, when on mature deliberation as we examined the sense
of the words, they appeared to agree with what we had originally
proposed as a sound confession of faith.’