good things in it, if you can point out its evils, there will still be two good kingdoms, though
the one where there are no evils will be the better of the two. What, then, do you call its
evils? They plundered, and killed, and devoured one another, according to Faustus. But if
they did nothing else than this, how could such numerous hosts be born and grow up to
maturity? They must have enjoyed peace and tranquillity too. But, allowing the kingdom
where there is no discord to be the better of the two, still they should both be called good,
rather than one good and the other bad. Thus the better kingdom will be that where they
killed neither themselves nor one another; and the worse, or less good, where, though they
fought with one another, each separate animal preserved its own nature in health and safety.
But we cannot make much difference between your god and the prince of darkness, whom
no one opposed, whose reign was acknowledged by all, and whose proposals were unanim-
ously agreed to. All this implies great peace and harmony. Those kingdoms are happy
where all agree heartily in obedience to the king. Moreover, the rule of this prince extended
not only to his own species, or to bipeds whom you make the parents of mankind, but to
all kinds of animals, who waited in his presence, obeying his commands, and believing his
declarations. Do you think people are so stupid as not to recognize the attributes of deity
in your description of this prince, or to think it possible that you can have another? If the
authority of this prince rested on his resources, he must have been very powerful; if on his
fame, he must have been renowned; if on love, the regard must have been universal; if on
fear, he must have kept the strictest order. If some evils, then, were mixed with so many
good things, who that knows the meaning of words would call this the nature of evil? Besides,
if you call this the nature of evil, because it was not only evil to the other nature, but was
also evil in itself, was there no evil, think you, in the dire necessity to which your god was
271
subjected before the mixture with the opposite nature, so that he was compelled to fight
with it, and to send his own members to be swallowed up so mercilessly as to be beyond the
hope of complete recovery? This was a great evil in that nature before its mixture with the
only thing you allow to be evil. Your god must either have had it in his power not to be in-
jured and sullied by the race of darkness, in which case his own folly must have brought
him into trouble; or if his substance was liable to corruption, the object of your worship is
not the incorruptible God of whom the apostle speaks. 778 Does not, then this liability to
corruption, even apart from the actual experience, seem to you to be an evil in your god?
15. It is plain, moreover, that either he must have been destitute of prescience,—a great
defect, surely, in the Deity, not to know what is coming; or if he had prescience, he can
never have felt secure, but must have been in constant terror, which you must allow to be
a serious evil. There must have been the fear at every moment, that the time might be come
for that conflict in which his members suffered such loss and contamination, that to liberate
778 1 Tim. i. 17.
461
Faustus denies that Manichæans believe in two gods. Hyle no god. Augustin…