53. Even this is sufficient to dissuade you from
blaming those who have said that the Son was coessential with the
Father, and yet let us examine the very term ‘Coessential,’
in itself, by way of seeing whether we ought to use it at all, and
whether it be a proper term, and is suitable to apply to the Son. For
you know yourselves, and no one can dispute it, that Like is not
predicated of essence, but of habits, and qualities; for in the case of
essences we speak, not of likeness, but of identity. Man, for instance,
is said to be like man, not in essence, but according to habit and
character; for in essence men are of one nature. And again, man is not
said to be unlike dog, but to be of different nature. Accordingly while the former are of one nature
and coessential, the latter are different in both. Therefore, in
speaking of Like according to essence, we mean like by participation;
(for Likeness is a quality, which may attach to essence), and this
would be proper to creatures for they, by partaking, are made like to
God. For ‘when He shall appear,’ says Scripture, ‘we
shall be like Him’ (1
John iii. 2), like, that is,
not in essence but in sonship, which we shall partake from Him. If then
ye speak of the Son as being by participation, then indeed call Him
Like-in-essence; but thus spoken of, He is not Truth, nor Light at all,
nor in nature God. For things which are from participation, are called
like, not in reality, but from resemblance to reality; so that they may
swerve, or be taken from those who share them. And this, again, is
proper to creatures and works. Therefore, if this be out of place, He
must be, not by participation, but in nature and truth Son, Light,
Wisdom, God; and being by nature, and not by sharing, He would properly
be called, not Like-in-essence, but Coessential. But what would not be
asserted, even in the case of others (for the Like has been shewn to be
inapplicable to essences), is it not folly, not to say violence, to put
forward in the case of the Son, instead of the
‘Coessential?’