19. If God be, and be called, the Fountain of
wisdom and life—as He says by Jeremiah, ‘They have forsaken
Me the Fountain of living waters Jer. ii. 13.;’ and
again, ‘A glorious high throne from the beginning, is the place
of our sanctuary; O Lord, the Hope of Israel, all that forsake Thee
shall be ashamed, and they that depart from Me shall be written in the
earth, because they have forsaken the Lord, the Fountain of living
waters Ib. xvii. 12, 13.;’ and in the book of Baruch it
is written, ‘Thou hast forsaken the Fountain of wisdom Bar. iii. 12.,’—this implies that life and
wisdom are not foreign to the Essence of the Fountain, but are proper
to It, nor were at any time without existence, but were always. Now the
Son is all this, who says, ‘I am the Life John xiv. 6.,’ and, ‘I Wisdom dwell with
prudence Prov. viii.
12..’ Is it not then irreligious to
say, ‘Once the Son was not?’ for it is all one with saying,
‘Once the Fountain was dry, destitute of Life and Wisdom.’
But a fountain it would then cease to be; for what begetteth not from
itself, is not a fountain Supr.
§15.. What a load of
extravagance! for God promises that those who do His will shall be as a
fountain which the water fails not, saying by Isaiah the prophet,
‘And the Lord shall satisfy thy soul in drought, and make thy
bones fat; and thou shalt be like a watered garden, and like a spring
of water, whose waters fail not Isa. lviii.
11..’ And
yet these, whereas God is called and is a Fountain of wisdom, dare to
insult Him as barren and void of His proper Wisdom. But their doctrine
is false; truth witnessing that God is the eternal Fountain of His
proper Wisdom; and, if the Fountain be eternal, the Wisdom also must
needs be eternal. For in It were all things made, as David says in the
Psalm, ‘In Wisdom hast Thou made them all Ps. civ. 24.;’ and Solomon says, ‘The Lord by
Wisdom hath formed the earth, by understanding hath He established the
heavens Prov. iii. 19..’ And this Wisdom is the Word,
and by Him, as John says, ‘all things were made,’ and
‘without Him was made not one thing John i. 3. See
Westcott’s additional note on the passage.].’ And this Word is Christ; for
‘there is One God, the Father, from whom are all things, and we
for Him; and One Lord Jesus Christ, through whom are all things, and we
through Him 1 Cor. viii.
6..’ And if all things are through
Him, He Himself is not to be reckoned with that ‘all.’ For
he who dares Vid.
Petav. de Trin. ii. 12, §4. to call Him, through whom are things,
one of that ‘all,’ surely will have like speculations
concerning God, from whom are all. But if he shrinks from this as
unseemly, and excludes God from that all, it is but consistent that he
should also exclude from that all the Only-Begotten Son, as being
proper to the Father’s essence. And, if He be not one of the
all De
Decr. §30., it is sin to say concerning Him, ‘He
was not,’ and ‘He was not before His generation.’
Such words may be used of the creatures; but as to the Son, He is such
as the Father is, of whose essence He is proper Offspring, Word, and
Wisdom De
Decr. §17.. For this is proper to the Son, as
regards the Father, and this shews that the Father is proper to the
Son; that we may neither say that God was ever without Word ἄλογον. Vid. note
on de Decr. §§1, 15, where other instances are given
from Athan. and Dionysius of Rome; vid. also Orat. iv. 2, 4.
Sent. D. 23. Origen, supr. p. 48. Athenag. Leg. 10. Tat.
contr. Græc. 5. Theoph. ad. Autol. ii. 10. Hipp.
contr. Noet. 10. Nyssen. contr. Eunom. vii. p. 215. viii.
pp. 230, 240. Orat, Catech. 1. Naz. Orat. 29. 17 fin.
Cyril. Thesaur. xiv. p. 145 (vid. Petav. de Trin. vi. 9).
It must not be supposed from these instances that the Fathers meant
that our Lord was literally what is called the attribute of
reason or wisdom in the Divine Essence, or in other words, that He was
God merely viewed as He is wise; which would be a kind of Sabellianism.
But, whereas their opponents said that He was but called Word
and Wisdom after the attribute (vid. de Syn. 15, note),
they said that such titles marked, not only a typical resemblance to
the attribute, but so full a correspondence and (as it were)
coincidence in nature with it, that whatever relation that
attribute had to God, such in kind had the Son;—that the
attribute was His symbol, and not His mere archetype; that our Lord was
eternal and proper to God, because that attribute was, which was His
title, vid. Ep. Æg. 14, that our Lord was that Essential
Reason and Wisdom,—not by which the Father is wise,
but without which the Father was not wise;—not,
that is, in the way of a formal cause, but in fact. Or, whereas
the Father Himself is Reason and Wisdom, the Son is the necessary
result of that Reason and Wisdom, so that, to say that there was no
Word, would imply there was no Divine Reason; just as a radiance
implies a light; or, as Petavius remarks, l.c. quoting the words which
follow shortly after in the text, the eternity of the Original implies
the eternity of the Image; τῆς
ὑποστάσεως
ὑπαρχούσης,
πάντως εὐθὺς
εἶναι δεῖ τὸν
χαρακτῆρα
καὶ τὴν
εἰκόνα
ταύτης,
§20. vid. also infr. §31, de Decr. §13, p. 21,
§§20, 23, pp. 35, 40. Theod. H. E. i. 3. p.
737., nor that the Son was non-existent. For wherefore a Son, if not
from Him? or wherefore Word and Wisdom, if not ever proper to Him?