28. Will any one say that incense is given to the celestials, for this reason, that it has a
sweet smell, and imparts a pleasant sensation to the nose, while the rest are disagreeable,
and have been set aside because of their offensiveness? Do the gods, then, have nostrils with
which to breathe? do they inhale and respire currents of air so that the qualities of different
smells can penetrate them? But if we allow that this is the case, we make them subject to the
conditions of humanity, and shut them out from the limits of deity; for whatever breathes
and draws in draughts of air, to be sent back in the same way, must be mortal, because it is
sustained by feeding on the atmosphere. But whatever is sustained by feeding on the atmo-
sphere, if you take away the means by which communication is kept up,4897 its life must be
crushed out, and its vital principle must be destroyed and lost. So then, if the gods also
breathe and inhale odours enwrapt in the air that accompanies them, it is not untrue to say
that they live upon what is received from others,4898 and that they might perish if their air-
holes were blocked up. And whence, lastly, do you know whether, if they are charmed by
the sweetness of smells, the same things are pleasant to them which are pleasant to you, and
charm and affect your different natures with a similar feeling? May it not be possible that
the things which give pleasure to you, seem, on the contrary, harsh and disagreeable to
them? For since the opinions of the gods are not the same, and their substance not one, by
what methods can it be brought about that that which is unlike in quality should have the
same feeling and perception as to that which touches it.4899 Do we not every day see that,
even among the creatures sprung from the earth, the same things are either bitter or sweet
to different species, that to some things are fatal which are not pernicious to others, so that
the same things which charm some with their delightful odours, give forth exhalations
deadly to the bodies of others? But the cause of this is not in the things which cannot be at
one and the same time deadly and wholesome, sweet and bitter; but just as each one has
been formed to receive impressions from what is external,4900 so he is affected:4901 his
condition is not caused by the influences of the things, but springs from the nature of his
own senses, and connection with the external. But all this is set far from the gods, and is
separated from them by no small interval. For if it is true, as is believed by the wise, that
they are incorporeal, and not supported by any excellence of bodily strength, an odour is of
no effect upon them, nor can reeking fumes move them by their senses, not even if you were
4897 Lit., “the returns by which the vital alternation is restored and withdrawn.”
4898 So the ms., Hild., and Oehler, reading suffec-tionibus alienis, for which the rest read suffi-—“the fumig-
ations of others.”
4899 Lit., “feel and receive one contact.”
4900 Lit., “as each has been made for the touching of a thing coming from without.”
4901 So Gelenius and later edd., reading afficiturfor the unintelligible reading of ms. and Roman edd., effi-
cit—“effects.”
Chapter XXVIII.
1291
Chapter XXVIII.