This
extract discloses to us (in connexion with the passages from Dionysius
Alex. here and in the de Sent. D.) a remarkable anticipation of
the Arian controversy in the third century. 1. It appears that the very
symbol of ἦν ὅτε οὐκ
ἦν, ‘once He was not,’
was asserted or implied; vid. also the following extract from Origen,
§27. and Origen Periarchon, iv. 28. where mention is also
made of the ἐξ οὐκ
ὄντων, ‘out of
nothing,’ which was the Arian symbol in opposition to ‘of
the substance.’ Allusions are made besides, to ‘the Father
not being always Father,’ de Sent. D. 15. and ‘the
Word being brought to be by the true Word, and Wisdom by the true
Wisdom;’ ibid. 25. 2. The same special text is used in defence of
the heresy, and that not at first sight an obvious one, which is found
among the Arians, Prov. viii. 22. 3. The same texts were
used by the Catholics, which occur in the Arian controversy.
e.g. Deut. xxxii. 6. against Prov.
viii. 22. and such as Ps. cx. 3. Prov. viii. 25. and the two John x.
30. and xiv. 10. 4. The same Catholic symbols and statements are found,
e.g. ‘begotten not made,’ ‘one in essence,’
‘Trinity,’ ἀδιαίρετον,
ἄναρχον,
ἀειγενες, ‘light from light,’ &c. Much might be said on
this circumstance, as forming part of the proof of the very early date
of the development and formation of the Catholic theology, which we are
at first sight apt to ascribe to the 4th and 5th centuries. [But see
Introd. to de Sent. Dion.]