In answer to this question the Fathers in order give their judgment—“that the Nicene
Creed, and the letter of Cyril, in all things agree and harmonise.” Here is inquiry and exam-
ination, and then judgment. The Acts speak for themselves—we say not here a word.
Next that letter of Nestorius was produced, which Celestine had pronounced blasphem-
ous and impious. It is read: then at the instance of Cyril it is examined, “whether this, too,
be agreeable to the Faith set forth by the holy Council of the Nicene Fathers, or not.” It is
precisely the same form according to which Cyril’s letter was examined. The Fathers, in
order, give judgment that it disagreed from the Nicene Creed, and was, therefore, censurable.
The letter of Nestorius is disapproved in the same manner, by the same rule, by which that
of Cyril was approved. Here, twice in the same proceeding of the Council of Ephesus, a
judgment of the Roman Pontiff concerning the Catholic Faith, uttered and published, is
reconsidered. What he had approved, and what he had disapproved, is equally examined,
and, only after examination, confirmed.
In the mean time, the bishops Arcadius and Projectus, and the presbyter Philip, had
been chosen by Celestine to be present at the Council of Ephesus, with a special commission
from the Apostolic See, and the whole Council of the West. So they come from Rome to
Ephesus, and appear at the holy Council, and here the second procedure commences.
After reading the letter of Celestine, the Legates, in pursuance, say to the bishops: “Let
your Holiness consider the form of the letters of the holy and venerable Pope Celestine the
Bishop, who hath exhorted your Holiness, not as instructing those who are ignorant, but
as reminding those who are aware: in order that you may command to be completely and
finally settled according to the Canon of our common Faith, and the utility of the Catholic
Church, what he has before determined, and has now the goodness to remind you of.” This
is the advantage of a Council; after whose sentence there is no new discussion, or new
judgment, but merely execution. And this the Legates request to be commanded by the
Council, in which they recognise that supreme authority.
It behoved, also, that the Legates, sent to the Council on a special mission, should un-
derstand whether the proceedings against Nestorius had been pursued according to the re-
195
quisition of the Canons, and due respect to the Apostolic See. This we have already often
said. Wherefore, with reason, they require the Acts to be communicated, “that we, too,”
say they, “may confirm them.” The proceedings themselves will declare what that confirm-
ation means. After that, at the request of the Legates, the Acts against Nestorius were given
them, they thus report about them at the third procedure: “We have found all things judged
canonically, and according to the Church’s discipline.” Therefore judgments of the
Apostolic See are canonically and, according to the Church’s discipline, reconsidered, after
deliberation, in a General Council, and judgment passed upon them. After the Legates had
approved the Acts against Nestorius communicated to them, they request that all which
had been read and done at Ephesus from the beginning, should be read afresh in public
375
Historical Introduction.