2. Origen is a heretic, true; but what does that take
from me who do not deny that on very many points he is heretical? He
has erred concerning the resurrection of the body, he has erred
concerning the condition of souls, he has erred by supposing it possible that the
devil may repent, and—an error more important than these—he
has declared in his commentary upon Isaiah that the Seraphim mentioned
by the prophet Isa. vi. 2. See Letter XVIII. are the divine Son
and the Holy Ghost. If I did not allow that he has erred or if I did
not daily anathematize his errors I should be partaker of his fault.
For while we receive what is good in his writings we must on no account
bind ourselves to accept also what is evil. Still in many passages he
has interpreted the scriptures well, has explained obscure places in
the prophets, and has brought to light very great mysteries, both in
the old and in the new testament. If then I have taken over what is
good in him and have either cut away or altered or ignored what is
evil, am I to be regarded as guilty on the score that through my agency
those who read Latin receive the good in his writings without knowing
anything of the bad? If this be a crime the confessor Hilary must be
convicted; for he has rendered from Greek into Latin Origen’s
Explanation of the Psalms and his Homilies on Job.
Eusebius of Vercellæ, who witnessed a like confession, must also
be held in fault; for he has translated into our tongue the
Commentaries upon all the Psalms of his heretical namesake,
omitting however the unsound portions and rendering only those parts
which are profitable. I say nothing of Victorinus of Petavium and
others who have merely followed and expanded Origen in their
explanation of the scriptures. Were I to do so, I might seem less
anxious to defend myself than to find for myself companions in guilt. I
will come to your own case: Why do you keep copies of his treatises on
Job? In these, while arguing against the devil and concerning the stars
and heavens, he has said certain things which the Church does not
receive. Is it for you alone, with that very wise head of yours, to
pass sentence upon all writers Greek and Latin, with a wave of your
censor’s wand to eject some from our libraries and to admit
others, and as the whim takes you to pronounce me either a Catholic or
a heretic? And am I to be forbidden to reject things which are wrong
and to condemn what I have often condemned already? Read what I have
written upon the epistle to the Ephesians, read my other works,
particularly my commentary upon Ecclesiastes, and you will clearly see
that from my youth up I have never been terrified by any man’s
influence into acquiescence in heretical pravity.