Now, what we object and oppose to their mindless
opinion about His Mind is this, to put it shortly; for they are almost
alone in the condition which they lay down, as it is through want of
mind that they mutilate His mind. But, that they may not accuse
us of having once accepted but of now repudiating the faith of their
beloved Vitalius Vitalius or Vitalis
was one of the principal followers of Apollinarius, and by him was
consecrated schismatical Bishop of Antioch, where, while yet orthodox,
he had been ordained a priest by Meletius. But he quarrelled with
his Bishop through jealousy of another priest, and then fell under the
influence of Apollinarius. He was summoned to Rome to clear
himself of the charge of heresy; and by a clever manipulation of
language he produced a confession which the Pope, Damasus, accepted as
orthodox; but the Pope remitted the whole case to Paulinus, who was at
that time recognized by the Western Church as rightful Bishop.
Vitalius, however, was unable to accept the test required, and
seceded. On his return from Rome he had visited Nazianzus, where
S. Gregory received him as a brother in the faith, though further
acquaintance compelled him to withdraw from this position.
Vitalius, while admitting that our Lord had both a human body and a
human soul, denied Him a human mind; whose place, according to his
teaching, was supplied by Divinity. which he handed in
in writing at the request of the blessed Bishop Damasus of Rome, I will
give a short explanation on this point also. For these men, when
they are theologizing among their genuine disciples, and those who are
initiated into their secrets, like the Manichæans among those whom
they call the “Elect,” expose the full extent of their
disease, and scarcely allow flesh at all to the Saviour. But when
they are refuted and pressed with the common answers about the
Incarnation which the Scripture presents, they confess indeed the
orthodox words, but they do violence to the sense; for they acknowledge
the Manhood to be neither without soul nor without reason nor without
mind, nor imperfect, but they bring in the Godhead to supply the soul
and reason and mind, as though It had mingled Itself only with His
flesh, and not with the other properties belonging to us men; although
His sinlessness was far above us, and was the cleansing of our
passions.