19. The Council vid.
ad. Afr. 5. wishing to do
away with the irreligious phrases of the Arians, and to use instead the
acknowledged words of the Scriptures, that the Son is not from nothing
but ‘from God,’ and is ‘Word’ and
‘Wisdom,’ and not creature or work, but a proper offspring
from the Father, Eusebius and his fellows, led by their inveterate
heterodoxy, understood the phrase ‘from God’ as belonging
to us, as if in respect to it the Word of God differed nothing from us,
and that because it is written, ‘There is one God, from whom, all
things 1 Cor. viii.
6.;’ and again, ‘Old things are
passed away, behold, all things are become new, and all things are from
God 2 Cor. v. 17..’ But the Fathers, perceiving their
craft and the cunning of their irreligion, were forced to express more
distinctly the sense of the words ‘from God.’ Accordingly,
they wrote ‘from the essence of God Hence
it stands in the Creed, ‘from the Father, that is, from
the essence of the Father.’ vid. Eusebius’s Letter,
infr. According to the received doctrine of the Church all
rational beings, and in one sense all beings whatever, are ‘from
God,’ over and above the fact of their creation; and of this
truth the Arians made use to deny our Lord’s proper divinity.
Athan. lays down elsewhere that nothing remains in consistence and
life, except from a participation of the Word, which is to be
considered a gift from Him, additional to that of creation, and
separable in idea from it; vid. above, §17, note 5. contr.
Gent. 42. de Incarn. 5. Man thus considered is, in his first
estate, a son of God and born of God, or, to use the term which occurs
so frequently in the Arian controversy, in the number, not only of the
creatures, but of things generate, γεννητά. This was the sense in which the Arians said that our Lord was
Son of God; whereas, as Athan. says, ‘things originate, being
works, cannot be called generate, except so far as, after their
making, they partake of the begotten Son, and are therefore said to
have been generated also; not at all in their own nature, but because
of their participation of the Son in the Spirit.’ Orat. i.
56. The question then was, as to the distinction of the
Son’s divine generation over that of holy men; and the Catholics
answered that He was ἐξ
οὐσίας, from
the essence of God; not by participation of grace, not by resemblance,
not in a limited sense, but really and simply, and therefore by an
internal divine act. vid. below, §22. and infr. §31.
[The above note has been modified so as to eliminate the erroneous
identification of γεννητὸς and γενητός.],’ in order that ‘from God’
might not be considered common and equal in the Son and in things
originate, but that all others might be acknowledged as creatures, and
the Word alone as from the Father. For though all things be said to be
from God, yet this is not in the sense in which the Son is from Him;
for as to the creatures, ‘of God’ is said of them on this
account, in that they exist not at random or spontaneously, nor come to
be by chance Cf.
de Syn. §35., according to those philosophers who
refer them to the combination of atoms, and to elements of similar
structure,—nor as certain heretics speak of a distinct
Framer,—nor as others again say that the constitution of all things is from certain
Angels;—but in that (whereas God is), it was by Him that all
things were brought into being, not being before, through His Word; but
as to the Word, since He is not a creature, He alone is both called and
is ‘from the Father;’ and it is significant of this sense
to say that the Son is ‘from the essence of the Father,’
for to nothing originate does this attach. In truth, when Paul says
that ‘all things are from God,’ he immediately adds,
‘and one Lord Jesus Christ, through whom all things 1 Cor. viii.
6.,’ in order to shew all men, that the
Son is other than all these things which came to be from God (for the
things which came to be from God, came to be through His Son); and that
he had used his foregoing words with reference to the world as framed
by God When
characteristic attributes and prerogatives are ascribed to God, or to
the Father, this is done only to the exclusion of creatures, or of
false gods, not to the exclusion of His Son who is implied in the
mention of Himself. Thus when God is called only wise, or the Father
the only God, or God is said to be unoriginate, ἀγένητος, this is not in contrast to the Son, but to all things which are
distinct from God. vid. Orat. iii. 8. Naz. Orat. 30, 13.
Cyril. Thesaur. p 142. ‘The words “one” and
“only” ascribed to God in Scripture,’ says S. Basil,
‘are not used in contrast to the Son or the Holy Spirit, but with
reference to those who are not God, and falsely called so.’
Ep. 8. n. 3. On the other hand, when the Father is mentioned,
the other Divine Persons are implied in Him, ‘The Blessed and
Holy Trinity,’ says S. Athan. ‘is indivisible and one in
itself; and when the Father is mentioned, His Word is added, and the
Spirit in the Son; and if the Son is named, in the Son is the Father,
and the Spirit is not external to the Word.’ ad Serap. i.
14., and not as if all things were from the
Father as the Son is. For neither are other things as the Son, nor is
the Word one among others, for He is Lord and Framer of all; and on
this account did the Holy Council declare expressly that He was of the
essence Vid.
also ad Afros. 4. Again, ‘“I am,” τὸ ὂν, is really proper to God and is a whole, bounded or mutilated
neither by aught before Him, nor after Him, for He neither was, nor
shall be.’ Naz. Orat. 30. 18 fin. Also Cyril Dial.
i. p. 392. Damasc. Fid. Orth. i. 9. and the Semiarians at
Ancyra, Epiph. Hær. 73. 12 init. By the
‘essence,’ however, or, ‘substance’ of God, the
Council did not mean any thing distinct from God, vid. note 3
infr. but God Himself viewed in His self-existing nature (vid.
Tert. in Hermog, 3.), nay, it expressly meant to negative the
contrary notion of the Arians, that our Lord was from something
distinct from God, and in consequence of created substance. Moreover
the term expresses the idea of God positively, in
contradistinction to negative epithets, such as infinite, immense,
eternal, &c. Damasc. Fid. Orthod. i. 4. and as little
implies any thing distinct from God as those epithets do. of the Father, that we might believe the Word
to be other than the nature of things originate, being alone truly from
God; and that no subterfuge should be left open to the irreligious.
This then was the reason why the Council wrote ‘of the
essence.’