Chapter 8.—17. Petilianus said: "We must consider, I say, and declare how far the
treacherous traditor is to be accounted dead while yet in life. Judas was an apostle when
he betrayed Christ; and the same man was already dead, having spiritually lost the office of
an apostle, being destined afterwards to die by hanging himself, as it is written: ‘I have
sinned,’ says he, ‘in that I have betrayed the innocent blood; and he departed, and went and
hanged himself.’1983 The traitor perished by the rope: he left the rope for others like himself,
of whom the Lord Christ cried aloud to the Father, ‘Father, those that Thou gavest me I
have kept, and none of them is lost, but the son of perdition; that the Scripture might be
533
fulfilled.’1984 For David of old had passed this sentence on him who was to betray Christ
to the unbelievers: ‘Let another take his office. Let his children be fatherless, and his wife
a widow.’1985 See how mighty is the spirit of the prophets, that it was able to see all future
things as though they were present, so that a traitor who was to be born hereafter should
be condemned many centuries before. Finally, that the said sentence should be completed,
the holy Matthias received the bishopric of that lost apostle. Let no one be so dull, no one
so faithless, as to dispute this: Matthias won for himself a victory, not a wrong, in that he
carried off the spoils of the traitor from the victory of the Lord Christ. Why then, after this,
do you claim to yourself a bishopric as the heir of a worse traitor? Judas betrayed Christ in
the flesh to the unbelievers; you in the spirit madly betrayed the holy gospel to the flames
of sacrilege. Judas betrayed the Lawgiver to the unbelievers; you, as it were, betraying all
that he had left, gave up the law of God to be destroyed by men. Whilst, had you loved the
law, like the youthful Maccabees, you would have welcomed death for the sake of the laws
of God (if indeed that can be said to be death to men which makes them immortal because
they died for the Lord); for of those brethren we learn that one replied to the sacrilegious
tyrant with these words of faith: ‘Thou like a fury takest us out of this present life; but the
King of the world (who reigns for ever, and of His kingdom there shall be no end) shall raise
us up who have died for His laws, unto everlasting life.’ 1986 If you were to burn with fire
the testament of a dead man, would you not be punished as the falsifier of a will? What
therefore is likely to become of you who have burned the most holy law of our God and
Judge? Judas repented of his deed even in death; you not only do not repent, but stand forth
as a persecutor and butcher of us who keep the law, whilst you are the most wicked of
traditors."
18. Augustin answered: See what a difference there is between your calumnious words
and our truthful assertions. Listen for a little while. See how you have exaggerated the sin
1983 Matt. xxvii. 4, 5.
1984 John xvii. 12.
1985 Ps. cix. 8, 9.
1986 2 Macc. vii. 9. The words in brackets are not in the original Greek.
Chapter 8
1020
Chapter 8