68. ‘Yet,’ they say, ‘though
the Saviour were a creature, God was able to speak the word only and
undo the curse.’ And so another will tell them in like manner,
‘Without His coming among us at all, God was able just to speak
and undo the curse;’ but we must consider what was expedient for
mankind, and not what simply is possible with God Vid.
also Incarn. 44. In this statement Athan. is supported by Naz.
Orat. 19, 13. Theodor. adv. Gent. vi. p. 876, 7. August.
de Trin. xiii. 13. It is denied in a later age by S. Anselm, but
S. Thomas and the schoolmen side with the Fathers. vid. Petav.
Incarn. ii. 13. However, it will be observed from what follows
that Athan. thought the Incarnation still absolutely essential
for the renewal of human nature in holiness. Cf. de Incarn. 7.
That is, we might have been pardoned, we could not have been new-made,
without the Incarnation; and so supr. 67.. He could have destroyed, before the ark of
Noah, the then transgressors; but He did it after the ark. He could
too, without Moses, have spoken the word only and have brought the
people out of Egypt; but it profited to do it through Moses. And God
was able without the judges to save His people; but it was profitable
for the people that for a season judges should be raised up to them.
The Saviour too might have come among us from the beginning, or on His
coming might not have been delivered to Pilate; but He came ‘at
the fulness of the ages Gal. iv. 4.,’ and when
sought for said, ‘I am He John xviii. 5..’ For
what He does, that is profitable for men, and was not fitting in any
other way; and what is profitable and fitting, for that He provides ‘Was it not in His power, had He wished it, even in a day to
bring on the whole rain [of the deluge]? in a day, nay in a
moment?’ Chrysost. in Gen. Hom. 24, 7. He proceeds to
apply this principle to the pardon of sin. On the subject of
God’s power as contrasted with His acts, Petavius brings together
the statements of the Fathers, de Deo, v. 6.. Accordingly He came, not ‘that He
might be ministered unto, but that He might minister Vid. Matt. xx. 28,’ and might work our salvation.
Certainly He was able to speak the Law from heaven, but He saw that it
was expedient to men for Him to speak from Sinai; and that He has done,
that it might be possible for Moses to go up, and for them hearing the
word near them the rather to believe. Moreover, the good reason of what
He did may be seen thus; if God had but spoken, because it was in His
power, and so the curse had been undone, the power had been shewn of
Him who gave the word, but man had become such as Adam was before the
transgression, having received grace from without Athan. here seems to say that Adam in a state of innocence had but
an external divine assistance, not an habitual grace; this, however, is
contrary to his own statements already referred to, and the general
doctrine of the fathers. vid. e.g. Cyril. in Joan. v. 2.
August. de Corr. et Grat. 31. vid also infr. §76,
note., and not having it united to the body; (for
he was such when he was placed in Paradise) nay, perhaps had become
worse, because he had learned to
transgress. Such then being his condition, had he been seduced by the
serpent, there had been fresh need for God to give command and undo the
curse; and thus the need had become interminable εἰς
ἄπειρον,
de Decr. 8., and men had remained under guilt not less
than before, as being enslaved to sin; and, ever sinning, would have
ever needed one to pardon them, and had never become free, being in
themselves flesh, and ever worsted by the Law because of the infirmity
of the flesh.