There is no reason to doubt, as Cornelius does, Novatian’s
sincerity in declaring that he did not seek the office of bishop. Both
Cornelius and Cyprian make his ambition and his jealousy of Cornelius,
the successful candidate, the cause of his schism. But such an
accusation was made against every schismatic, even when there was not a
shadow of support for it, and there is no reason to suppose it nearer
the truth in this than in other cases. In fact, his own protestation,
as recorded here by Cornelius, and as testified to by Dionysius in
chap. 45, as well as the character of the man as revealed in his life
previous to his episcopal ordination (as certified to even by his
enemies), and in his writings, are entirely opposed to the supposition
that he sought the episcopal office and that his schism was a result of
his defeat. We shall do much better to reject entirely this exceedingly
hostile and slanderous account of his enemy Cornelius, and to accept
his own account of the matter as reported by Dionysius in chap. 25. He
was the natural head of the rigoristic party, made such by his
commanding ability, his deep piety, and his ascetic principles of
living; and when Cornelius, the head of the lax party, was made bishop
(in March, 251), the strict party revolted, and it could not be
otherwise than that Novatian should be elected bishop, and that even if
reluctant he should feel compelled to accept the office in order to
assert the principles which he believed vital, and to prevent the
complete ruin of the Church. Cornelius gives a sad story of his
ordination to the episcopate. But one thing is certain, he had with him
for some time a large portion of the best people in the Roman church,
among them Maximus and others of the most influential confessors, who
seem at length to have returned to the Church only because they saw
that the schism was injuring it. Certainly if Novatian had been a
self-seeker, as Cornelius describes him, and if his ordination had been
of such a nature as Cornelius reports, he could never have had the
support of so many earnest and prominent men. It is doubtless true, as
Cornelius states, that Novatian was ordained by three Italian bishops,
very likely bishops of rural and comparatively insignificant sees, and
it is quite possible that one of them, as he also records, afterwards
repented of his act as schismatic, and returned to the Church and
received absolution. But all this does not imply that these three
bishops were deceived by false pretenses on the part of Novatian, or
that they were intoxicated when they performed the service. This, in
fact, may be looked upon as baseless calumny. Novatus, the Carthaginian
agitator who had caused Cyprian so much trouble, took a prominent part
in the Novatian schism, though to make him the author of it, as Cyprian
does, is undoubtedly incorrect (see Lardner, Works, III. p. 94
sq.; London ed. 1829). It was perhaps he (as reported by Eulogius,
according to Photius, Cod. 182, and by Theodoret, Hær.
Fab. III. 5) that found these three bishops to ordain Novatian. It
is not at all improbable, when so many prominent men in the Roman
church favored the stricter principles and supported Novatian, that
bishops could be found in Italy who held the same principles and would
be glad to ordain Novatian as bishop of Rome.