Essence, substance, οὐσία. Most of
this controversy might have been avoided by agreeing to banish the
word οὐσία entirely
from this sort of connection with the Deity. Even Celsus the
Neo-platonist had said, “God does not partake of substance”
(οὐσίας).
“Exactly,” Origen replies, “God is partaken of, viz.,
by those who have His spirit, rather than partakes of anything Himself.
Indeed, the subject of substance involves questions complicated and
difficult to decide; most especially on this point. Supposing, that is,
an absolute Substance, motionless, incorporeal, is God beyond this
Substance in rank and power, granting a share of it to those to whom
according to His Word He chooses to communicate it? Or is He Himself
this Substance, though described as invisible in that passage about the
Saviour (Coloss. i. 15) ‘Who is the
image of the invisible God,’ where invisible means incorporeal?
Another point is this: is the Only-Begotten and First-Born of all
Creatures to be pronounced the Substance of substances, the Original
Idea of all ideas, while the Father God Himself is beyond all
these?” (c. Cels. vi. 64). (Such a question as this last,
however, could not have been asked a century later, when Athanasius had
dispelled all traces of Neo-platonic subordination from the Christian
Faith. Uncreated Spirit, not Invisible First Substance, is the mark of
all in the Triune-God. But the effort of Neo-platonism to rise above
every term that might seem to include the Deity had not been
thrown away. Even “God is Spirit” is only a
conception, not a definition, of the Deity; while “God is
substance” ought to be regarded as an actual contradiction in
terms.)