What he says runs
thus:—“As all generation is not protracted to infinity, but
ceases on arriving at some end, those who admit the origination of the
Son are absolutely obliged to say that He then ceased being generated,
and not to look incredulously on the beginning of those things which
cease being generated, and therefore also surely begin: for the
cessation of generation establishes a beginning of begetting and being
begotten: and these facts cannot be disbelieved, on the ground at once
of nature itself and of the Divine laws This
quotation from Eunomius presents some difficulties, but it is quite as
likely that they are due to the obscurity of his style, as that they
are due to corruption of the text..” Now since he endeavours to establish
his point inferentially, laying down his universal proposition
according to the scientific method of those who are skilled in such
matters, and including in the general premise the proof of the
particular, let us first consider his universal, and then proceed to
examine the force of his inferences. Is it a reverent proceeding to
draw from “all generation” evidence even as to the
pre-temporal generation of the Son? and ought we to put forward
ordinary nature as our instructor on the being of the Only-begotten?
For my own part, I should not have expected any one to reach such a
point of madness, that any such idea of the Divine and unsullied
generation should enter his fancy. “All generation,” he
says, “is not protracted to infinity.” What is it that he
understands by “generation”? Is he speaking of fleshly,
bodily birth, or of the formation of inanimate objects? The affections
involved in bodily generation are well known—affections which no
one would think of transferring to the Divine Nature. In order
therefore that our discourse may not, by mentioning the works of nature
at length, be made to appear redundant, we shall pass such matters by
in silence, as I suppose that every sensible man is himself aware of
the causes by which generation is protracted, both in regard to its
beginning and to its cessation: it would be tedious and at the same
time superfluous to express them all minutely, the coming together of
those who generate, the formation in the womb of that which is
generated, travail, birth, place, time, without which the generation of
a body cannot be brought about,—things which are all equally
alien from the Divine generation of the Only-begotten: for if any one
of these things were admitted, the rest will of necessity all enter with
it. That the Divine generation, therefore, may be clear of every idea
connected with passion, we shall avoid conceiving with regard to it
even that extension which is measured by intervals. Now that which
begins and ends is surely regarded as being in a kind of extension, and
all extension is measured by time, and as time (by which we mark both
the end of birth and its beginning) is excluded, it would be vain, in
the case of the uninterrupted generation, to entertain the idea of end
or beginning, since no idea can be formed to mark either the point at
which such generation begins or that at which it ceases. If on the
other hand it is the inanimate creation to which he is looking, even in
this case, in like manner, place, and time, and matter, and
preparation, and power of the artificer, and many like things, concur
to bring the product to perfection. And since time assuredly is
concurrent with all things that are produced, and since with everything
that is created, be it animate or inanimate, there are conceived also
bases of construction relative to the product, we can find in these
cases evident beginnings and endings of the process of formation. For
even the procuring of material is actually the beginning of the fabric,
and is a sign of place, and is logically connected with time. All these
things fix for the products their beginnings and endings; and no one
could say that these things have any participation in the pretemporal
generation of the Only-begotten God, so that, by the aid of the things
now under consideration, we are able to calculate, with regard to that
generation, any beginning or end.