Chapter XX.
Let us see how he continues after this: “These events,” he says, “he predicted as being
a God, and the prediction must by all means come to pass. God, therefore, who above all
others ought to do good to men, and especially to those of his own household, led on his
own disciples and prophets, with whom he was in the habit of eating and drinking, to such
a degree of wickedness, that they became impious and unholy men. Now, of a truth, he
who shared a man’s table would not be guilty of conspiring against him; but after banqueting
with God, he became a conspirator. And, what is still more absurd, God himself plotted
against the members of his own table, by converting them into traitors and villains!” Now,
440
since you wish me to answer even those charges of Celsus which seem to me frivolous, 3272
the following is our reply to such statements. Celsus imagines that an event, predicted
through foreknowledge, comes to pass because it was predicted; but we do not grant this,
maintaining that he who foretold it was not the cause of its happening, because he foretold
it would happen; but the future event itself, which would have taken place though not pre-
dicted, afforded the occasion to him, who was endowed with foreknowledge, of foretelling
its occurrence. Now, certainly this result is present to the foreknowledge of him who predicts
an event, when it is possible that it may or may not happen, viz., that one or other of these
things will take place. For we do not assert that he who foreknows an event, by secretly
taking away the possibility of its happening or not, makes any such declaration as this: “This
shall infallibly happen, and it is impossible that it can be otherwise.” And this remark applies
to all the foreknowledge of events dependent upon ourselves, whether contained in the
sacred Scriptures or in the histories of the Greeks. Now, what is called by logicians an “idle
argument,” 3273 which is a sophism, will be no sophism as far as Celsus can help, but accord-
ing to sound reasoning it is a sophism. And that this may be seen, I shall take from the
Scriptures the predictions regarding Judas, or the foreknowledge of our Saviour regarding
him as the traitor; and from the Greek histories the oracle that was given to Laius, conceding
for the present its truth, since it does not affect the argument. Now, in Ps. cviii., Judas is
spoken of by the mouth of the Saviour, in words beginning thus: “Hold not Thy peace, O
God of my praise; for the mouth of the wicked and the mouth of the deceitful are opened
against me.” Now, if you carefully observe the contents of the psalm, you will find that, as
it was foreknown that he would betray the Saviour, so also was he considered to be himself
the cause of the betrayal, and deserving, on account of his wickedness, of the imprecations
contained in the prophecy. For let him suffer these things, “because,” says the psalmist, “he
remembered not to show mercy, but persecuted the poor and needy man.” Wherefore it
was possible for him to show mercy, and not to persecute him whom he did persecute. But
3272 εὐτελέσι.
3273 ἀργὸς λόγος.
Chapter XX
960
Chapter XX