57. And as to His saying, ‘If it be
possible, let the cup pass,’ observe how, though He thus spake,
He rebuked Matt. xvi. 23, cf.
§§40, 41. Peter, saying, ‘Thou savourest
not the things that be of God, but those that be of men.’ For He
willed [The
human will of the Saviour is in absolute harmony with the Divine,
though psychologically distinct.] Cf. Anast. Hodeg. i. p.
12. what He deprecated, for therefore had
He come; but His was the willing (for for it He came), but the terror
belonged to the flesh. Wherefore as man He utters this speech also, and
yet both were said by the Same, to shew that He was God, willing in
Himself, but when He had become man, having a flesh that was in terror.
For the sake of this flesh He combined His own will with human
weakness It is
observable that, as elsewhere we have seen Athan. speak of the
nature of the Word, and of, not the nature of man as
united to Him, but of flesh, humanity, &c. (vid. Or.
ii. 45, n. 2.) so here, instead of speaking of two wills, he speaks of
the Word’s willing and human weakness, terror,
&c. In another place he says still more pointedly, ‘The
will was of the Godhead alone; since the whole nature of
the Word was manifested in the second Adam’s human form
and visible flesh.’ contr. Apoll. ii. 10. Cf. S.
Leo on the same passage: ‘The first request is one of infirmity,
the second of power; the first He asked in our [character], the second
in His own.…The inferior will give way to the superior,’
&c. Serm. 56, 2. vid. a similar passage in Nyssen.
Antirrh. adv. Apol. 32. vid. also 31. An obvious objection may
be drawn from such passages, as if the will ‘of the flesh’
were represented as contrary (vid. foregoing note) to the will of the
Word. The whole of our Lord’s prayer is offered by Him as man,
because it is a prayer; the first part is not from Him as man, but the
second, which corrects it, from Him as God [i.e. the first part is not
human as contrasted with the second]; but the former part is
from the sinless infirmity of our nature, the latter from His human
will expressing its acquiescence in His Father’s, that is, in His
Divine Will. ‘His Will,’ says S. Greg. Naz. ‘was not
contrary to God, being all deified, θεωθὲν
ὅλον.’, that destroying this affection He
might in turn make man undaunted in face of death. Behold then a thing
strange indeed! He to whom Christ’s enemies impute words of
terror, He by that so-called νομιζομένῃ, vid. Orat. i. 10. tenor renders men
undaunted and fearless. And so the Blessed Apostles after Him from such
words of His conceived so great a contempt of death, as not even to
care for those who questioned them, but to answer, ‘We ought to
obey God rather than men Acts v. 29..’ And the
other Holy Martyrs were so bold, as to think that they were rather
passing to life than undergoing death. Is it not extravagant then, to
admire the courage of the servants of the Word, yet to say that the
Word Himself was in terror, through whom they despised death? But from
that most enduring purpose and courage of the Holy Martyrs is shewn,
that the Godhead was not in terror, but the Saviour took away our
terror. For as He abolished death by death, and by human means all
human evils, so by this so-called terror did He remove our terror, and
brought about that never more should men fear death. His word and deed
go together. For human were the sayings, ‘Let the cup
pass,’ and ‘Why hast Thou forsaken Me?’ and divine
the act whereby the Same did cause the sun to fail and the dead to
rise. Again He said humanly, ‘Now is My soul troubled;’ and
He said divinely, ‘I have power to lay down My life, and power to
take it again John xii. 27; x.
18..’ For to be
troubled was proper to the flesh,
and to have power to lay down His life This
might be taken as an illustration of the ut voluit supr. Or. i.
44, n. 11. And so the expressions in the Evangelists, ‘Into Thy
hands I commend My Spirit,’ ‘He bowed the
head,’ ‘He gave up the ghost,’ are taken
to imply that His death was His free act. vid. Ambros. in loc.
Luc. Hieron. in loc. Matt. also Athan. Serm. Maj. de
Fid. 4. It is Catholic doctrine that our Lord, as man, submitted to
death of His free will, and not as obeying an express command of the
Father. Cf. S. Chrysostom on John x. 18. Theophylact. in Hebr.
xii. 2; Aug. de Trin. iv. 16.
and take it again, when He will, was no property of men but of the
Word’s power. For man dies, not by his own power, but by
necessity of nature and against his will; but the Lord, being Himself
immortal, but having a mortal flesh, had power, as God, to become
separate from the body and to take it again, when He would. Concerning
this too speaks David in the Psalm, ‘Thou shalt not leave My soul
in hades, neither shalt Thou suffer Thy Holy One to see corruption Ps. xvi. 10..’ For it beseemed that the flesh,
corruptible as it was, should no longer after its own nature remain
mortal, but because of the Word who had put it on, should abide
incorruptible. For as He, having come in our body, was conformed to our
condition, so we, receiving Him, partake of the immortality that is
from Him.