Apollinaris was the first to apply the results of the
Nicene controversy to Christology proper, and to call the attention of
the Church to the psychical and pneumatic element in the humanity of
Christ; but in his zeal for the true deity of Christ, and fear of a
double personality, he fell into
the error of a partial denial of his true humanity. Adopting the
psychological trichotomy of Plato (σῶμα ψυχὴ,
πνεῦμα), for which he quoted
1. Thess. v. 23 and Gal. v. 17, he attributed to Christ a human body
(σῶμα) and a
human soul (the ψυχὴ
ἄλογος, the anima animans
which man has in common with the animal), but not a rational spirit
(νοῦς,
πνεῦμα, ψυχὴ
λογικὴ, anima rationalis,)
and put in the place of the latter the divine Logos. In
opposition to the idea of a mere connection of the Logos with the man
Jesus, he wished to secure an organic unity of the two, and so a true
incarnation; but he sought this at the expense of the most important
constituent of man. He reached only a Θεὸς
σαρκοφόρος as
Nestorianism only an ἄνθρωπος
θεοφόρος instead of the
proper θεάνδρωτος
. He appealed to the fact that the Scripture says, “the
Word was made flesh”—not spirit; “God
was manifest in the flesh” etc. To which Gregory
Nazianzen justly replied that in these passages the term σάρξ was used by
synecdoche for the whole human nature. In this way Apollinaris
established so close a connection of the Logos with human flesh, that
all the divine attributes were transferred to the human nature, and all
the human attributes to the divine, and the two merged in one nature in
Christ. Hence he could speak of a crucifixion of the Logos, and a
worship of his flesh. He made Christ a middle being between God
and man, in whom, as it were, one part divine and two parts human were
fused in the unity of a new nature. He even ventured to adduce
created analogies, such as the mule, midway between the horse and the
ass; the grey colour, a mixture of white and black; and spring, in
distinction from winter and summer. Christ, said he, is neither
whole man, nor God, but a mixture (μίξις) of God and man.
On the other hand, he regarded the orthodox view of a union of full
humanity with a full divinity in one person—of two wholes in one
whole—as an absurdity. He called the result of this
construction ἀνθρωπόθεος
, a sort of monstrosity, which he put in the same category with the
mythological figure of the Minotaur. But the Apollinarian idea of
the union of the Logos with a truncated human nature might be itself
more justly compared with this monster. Starting from the Nicene
homoousion as to the Logos, but denying the completeness of
Christ’s humanity, he met Arianism half-way, which likewise put
the divine Logos in the place of the human spirit in Christ. But
he strongly asserted his unchangeableness, while Arians taught his
changeableness (τρεπτότης).