Testimonia

Publiek archief van verzamelde en verwerkte bronrecords.
Overzicht / tekstblob

Tekstblob

sha256: 6970f7d12fd7e701b920b962d34b8e799611a7d57749bc8542bc6825449ac92f · 3,059 tekens

Excursus on Usury. The famous canonist Van Espen defines usury thus:  “Usura definitur lucrum ex mutuo exactum aut speratum;”96 and then goes on to defend the proposition that, “Usury is forbid- den by natural, by divine, and by human law.  The first is proved thus.  Natural law, as far as its first principles are concerned, is contained in the decalogue; but usury is prohibited in the decalogue, inasmuch as theft is prohibited; and this is the opinion of the Master of the Sentences, of St. Bonaventura, of St. Thomas and of a host of others:  for by the name of theft in the Law all unlawful taking of another’s goods is prohibited; but usury is an un- lawful, etc.”  For a proof of usury’s being contrary to divine law he cites Ex. xxii. 25, and Deut. xxiii. 29; and from the New Testament Luke vi. 34.  “The third assertion is proved thus.  Usury is forbidden by human law:  The First Council of Nice in Canon VII. deposed from the clergy and from all ecclesiastical rank, clerics who took usury; and the same thing is the case with an infinite number of councils, in fact with nearly all e.g. Elvira, ij, Arles j, Carthage iij, Tours iij, etc.  Nay, even the pagans themselves formerly forbid it by their laws.”  He then quotes Tacitus (Annal. lib. v.), and adds, “with what severe laws the French Kings coerced usurers is evident from the edicts of St. Louis, Philip IV., Charles IX., Henry III., etc.” There can be no doubt that Van Espen in the foregoing has accurately represented and without any exaggeration the universal opinion of all teachers of morals, theologians, doctors, Popes, and Councils of the Christian Church for the first fifteen hundred years.  All interest exacted upon loans of money was looked upon as usury, and its reception was esteemed a form of theft and dishonesty.  Those who wish to read the history of the matter in all its 37 details are referred to Bossuet’s work on the subject, Traité de l’Usure,97 where they will find the old, traditional view of the Christian religion defended by one thoroughly acquainted with all that could be said on the other side. The glory of inventing the new moral code on the subject, by which that which before was looked upon as mortal sin has been transfigured into innocence, if not virtue, belongs to John Calvin!  He made the modern distinction between “interest” and “usury,” and was the first to write in defence of this then new-fangled refinement of casuistry.98  Luther viol- ently opposed him, and Melancthon also kept to the old doctrine, though less violently (as was to be expected); today the whole Christian West, Protestant and Catholic alike, stake their salvation upon the truth of Calvin’s distinction!  Among Roman Catholics the new doctrine began to be defended about the beginning of the eighteenth century, the work of 96 Van Espen, Dissertatio de Usura, Art. I. 97 Bossuet, Œuvres Comp. xxxj. 98 Funk (Zins und Wucher, p. 104) says that Eck and Hoogsträten had already verbally defended this distinction at Bologna. Excursus on Usury. 99 Excursus on Usury.

Alle records · Zoek op deze hash