Leo can never be charged with weakness. His rejection of the canon was absolute and
unequivocal. In writing to the Emperor he says that Anatolius only got the See of Con-
stantinople by his consent, that he should behave himself modestly, and that there is no way
he can make of Constantinople “an Apostolic See,” and adds that “only from love of peace
and for the restoration of the unity of the faith” he has “abstained from annulling this ordin-
ation” (Ep. civ.).
To the Empress he wrote with still greater violence: “As for the resolution of the bishops
which is contrary to the Nicene decree, in union with your faithful piety, I declare it to be
invalid and annul it by the authority of the holy Apostle Peter” (Ep. cv.).
The papal annulling does not appear to have been of much force, for Leo himself con-
fesses, in a letter written about a year later to the Empress Pulcheria (Ep. cxvi.), that the Il-
lyrian bishops had since the council subscribed the xxviiith canon.
The pope had taken occasion in his letter in which he announced his acceptance of the
doctrinal decrees of Chalcedon to go on further and express his rejection of the canons.
This part of the letter was left unread throughout the Greek empire, and Leo complains of
it to Julian of Cos (Ep. cxxvij.).
Leo never gave over his opposition, although the breach was made up between him and
Anatolius by an apparently insincere letter on the part of the latter (Ep. cxxxii.). Leo’s suc-
cessors followed his example in rejecting the canons, both the IIId of Constantinople and
the XXVIIIth of Chalcedon, but as M. l’abbé Duchesne so admirably says: “Mais leur voix
fut peu écoutée; on leur accorda sans doute des satisfactions, mais de pure cérémonie.”296
290
But Justinian acknowledged the Constantinopolitan and Chalcedonian rank of Con-
stantinople in his CXXXIst Novel. (cap. j.), and the Synod in Trullo in canon xxxvj. renewed
exactly canon xxviij. of Chalcedon. Moreover the Seventh Ecumenical with the approval
of the Papal Legates gave a general sanction to all the canons accepted by the Trullan Synod.
And finally in 1215 the Fourth Council of the Lateran in its Vth Canon acknowledged
Constantinople’s rank as immediately after Rome, but this was while Constantinople was
in the hands of the Latins! Subsequently at Florence the second rank, in accordance with
the canons of I. Constantinople and of Chalcedon (which had been annulled by Leo) was
given to the Greek Patriarch of Constantinople, and so the opposition of Rome gave way
after seven centuries and a half, and the Nicene Canon which Leo declared to be “inspired
by the Holy Ghost” and “valid to the end of time” (Ep. cvi.), was set at nought by Leo’s suc-
cessor in the Apostolic See.
From the Acts of the same Holy Synod concerning Photius, Bishop of Tyre, and Eustath-
ius, Bishop of Berytus.
The most magnificent and glorious judges said:
296 Duchesne, Origines du Culte Chrétien, p. 24.
538
Excursus on the Later History of Canon XXVIII.