anasius therefore all good Arians bent their energies. They found ready accomplices in the
schismatical Meletians of Egypt, who were bitter enemies of the orthodox church of Alexan-
dria. It was useless to accuse Athanasius of heterodoxy; he was too widely known as the
pillar of the orthodox faith. Charges must be framed of another sort, and of a sort to stir up
the anger of the Emperor against him. The Arians therefore and the Meletians began to
spread the most vile and at the same time absurd stories about Athanasius (see especially
the latter’s Apol. c. Arian. §59 sq.). These at last became so notorious that the Emperor
summoned Athanasius to appear and make his defense before a council of bishops to be
held in Cæsarea (Sozomen, H. E. II. 25; Theodoret, H. E. I. 28). Athanasius, however, fearing
that the Council would be composed wholly of his enemies, and that it would therefore be
impossible to secure fair play, excused himself and remained away. But in the following year
(see Sozomen, H. E. II. 25) he received from the Emperor a summons to appear before a
council at Tyre. The summons was too peremptory to admit of a refusal, and Athanasius
therefore attended, accompanied by many of his devoted adherents (see Sozomen, ib.;
Theodoret, H. E. I. 30; Socrates, H. E. I. 28; Athanasius, Apol. c. Arian. §71 sq.; Eusebius,
Vita Const. IV. 41 sq., and Epiphanius, Hær. LXVIII. 8). After a time, perceiving that he
had no chance of receiving fair play, he suddenly withdrew from the Council and proceeded
directly to Constantinople, in order to lay his case before the Emperor himself, and to induce
the latter to allow him to meet his accusers in his presence, and plead his cause before him.
There was nothing for the Synod to do after his flight but to sustain the charges brought
against him, some of which he had not stayed to refute, and to pass condemnation upon
him. Besides various immoral and sacrilegious deeds of which he was accused, his refusal
23
to appear before the Council of Cæsarea the previous year was made an important item of
the prosecution. It was during this Council that Potamo flung at Eusebius the taunt of
cowardice, to which reference was made above, and which doubtless did much to confirm
Eusebius’ distrust of and hostility to the Athanasian party. Whether Eusebius of Cæsarea,
as is commonly supposed, or Eusebius of Nicomedia, or some other bishop, presided at this
Council we are not able to determine. The account of Epiphanius seems to imply that the
former was presiding at the time that Potamo made his untimely accusation. Our sources
are, most of them, silent on the matter, but according to Valesius, Eusebius of Nicomedia
is named by some of them, but which they are I have not been able to discover. We learn
from Socrates (H. E. I. 28), as well as from other sources, that this Synod of Tyre was held
in the thirtieth year of Constantine’s reign, that is, between July, 334, and July, 335. As the
Council was closed only in time for the bishops to reach Jerusalem by July, 335, it is probable
that it was convened in 335 rather than in 334. From Sozomen (H. E. II. 25) we learn also
that the Synod of Cæsarea had been held the preceding year, therefore in 333 or 334 (the
latter being the date commonly given by historians). While the Council of Tyre was still in
session, the bishops were commanded by Constantine to proceed immediately to Jerusalem
36
Continuance of the Arian Controversy. Eusebius' Relations to the Two Pa…