Although what I have recorded
did not occur to Athanasius and the church of Alexandria, at the same
period of time after the death of Constans, yet I deemed it right, for
the sake of greater clearness, to relate all these events collectively.
The council of Milan
Athan. Hist. Arian. 31–46; Ruf. H.
E. i. 21; Soc. ii. 36; Sulp. Sev. H. S. ii. 39: cf.
Theodoret, H. E. ii. 16, dialogue between the emperor and
Liberius; Am. Marcel. xv. 7.
was dissolved without any business having been transacted, and the
emperor condemned to banishment all those who had opposed the designs
of the enemies of Athanasius. As Constantius wished to establish uniformity of doctrine
throughout the Church, and to unite the priesthood in the maintenance
of the same sentiments, he formed a plan to convene the bishops of
every religion to a council, to be held in the West. He was aware of
the difficulty of carrying this scheme into execution, arising from the
vast extent of land and seas which some of the bishops would have to
traverse, yet he did not altogether despair of success. While this
project was occupying his mind, and before he prepared to make his
triumphal entrance into Rome, he sent for Liberius, the bishop of Rome,
and strove to persuade him to conformity of sentiment with the priests
by whom he was attended, amongst whom was Eudoxius. As Liberius,
however, refused compliance, and protested that he would never yield on
this point, the emperor banished him to Berœa, in Thrace. It is
alleged, that another pretext for the banishment of Liberius was, that
he would not withdraw from communion with Athanasius, but manfully
opposed the emperor, who insisted that Athanasius had injured the
Church, had occasioned the death of the elder of his two brothers,
The dialogue is preserved in Theodoret, H. E.
ii. 16. Cf. Hil. Fragm. v., vi.
and had sown the seeds of enmity between Constans and himself. As the
emperor revived all the decrees which had been enacted against
Athanasius by various councils, and particularly by that of Tyre,
Liberius told him that no regard ought to be paid to edicts which were
issued from motives of hatred, of favor, or of fear. He desired that
the bishops of every region should be made to sign the formulary of
faith compiled at Nicæa, and that those bishops who had been
exiled on account of their adherence to it should be recalled. He
suggested that after these matters were righted all the bishops should,
at their own expense, and without being furnished either with public
conveyances or money, so as not to seem burdensome and destructive,
proceed to Alexandria, and make an accurate test of the truth, which
could be more easily instituted at that city than elsewhere, as the
injured and those who had inflicted injury as well as the confuters of
the charges dwelt there. He then exhibited the letter written by Valens
and Ursacius to Julius, his predecessor in the Roman see, in which they
solicited his forgiveness, and acknowledged that the depositions
brought against Athanasius, at the Mareotis, were false; and he
besought the emperor not to condemn Athanasius during his absence, nor
to give credit to enactments which were evidently obtained by the
machinations of his enemies. With respect to the alleged injuries which
had been inflicted on his two brothers, he entreated the emperor not to
revenge himself by the hands of priests who had been set apart by God,
not for the execution of vengeance, but for sanctification, and the
performance of just and benevolent actions.