6. ἑὰν εἴπωμεν] St John considers only the case of professing Christians. In doing this he unites himself with those whom he addresses; and recognises the fact that he no less than his fellow-Christians has to guard against the temptations to which the three types of false doctrine correspond.
The exact form of expression (ἑὰν εἴπωμεν) is found only in this passage (vv. 6, 8, 10; comp. iv. 20 ἑὰν τις εἴπῃ). It contemplates a direct assertion of the several statements, and not simply the mental conception of them.
ὅτι] The particle here and in vv. 8, 10 seems to be recitative. Comp. ii. 4; iv. 20; John i. 20, 32; iv. 17, 25; vi. 14; vii. 12; ix. 9, 23, 41.
κοιν. ἔχομεν μετ' αὐτοῦ] with Him, i.e. with God (the Father), the subject which immediately precedes.
The statement is the simple assertion of the enjoyment of the privileges of the Christian faith, v. 3, note: "If we claim to have reached the end of Christian effort..." καὶ ἐν τῷ σκ. περ.] The compatibility of indifference to moral action with the possession of true faith has been maintained by enthusiasts in all times of religious excitement. Comp. c. ii. 4; iii. 6; 3 John 11.
For early forms of the false teaching see Iren. i. 6, 2; Clem. Alex. Strom. iii. 4 §§ 31 f.; 5 § 40. Comp. Jude v. 4.
ἐν τῷ σκ. περ.] walk in the darkness, choose and use the darkness as our sphere of action. The question is not directly of the specific character of special acts, but of the whole region of life outward and inward. The darkness (τὸ σκότος) is the absolute opposite of 'the light.'
To choose this as our sphere of movement is necessarily to shun fellowship with God. Part of the thought included in 'walking in darkness' may be expressed by saying that we seek to hide part of our lives from ourselves, from our neighbour, from God. Comp. John iii. 20.
For the phrase see Is. ix. 2; John viii. 12 (ἐν τῇ σκοτίᾳ). Comp. Matt. iv. 16; Luke i. 79; Rom. ii. 19. Σκότος occurs in St John only here and John iii. 19 note.
The image of 'walking,' resting on the Old Testament הָלַךְ, ixx. περιπατεῖν, is not found applied to conduct in classical writers, but is common in St John and St Paul. The word is not found in this sense in St James or St Peter, and in the Synoptic group of writings only in Mark vii. 5; Acts xxi. 21. St John, it may be added, does not use ἀναστροφή, ἀναστρέφασθαι, which are common in St Peter and occur in St Paul and St James; nor πορεύεσθαι, which is found in St Luke (Gosp. Acts), St Peter (1, 2), and St Jude. Such 'walking' is not to be limited to mere outward conduct, but covers the whole activity of life.
ψευδόμεθα...οὐ ποιοῦμεν...] The combination of the positive and negative expressions here again (v. 5) presents the two sides of the thought. Men who profess to combine fellowship with God with the choice of darkness as their sphere of life, actively affirm what they know to be false; and on the other hand, they neglect to carry out in deed what they claim to hold. The two clauses (lie...do) correspond with the two which precede (say... walk).
ψευδόμεθα] The assertion is not only false in fact, but known to be false: it is at variance with man's nature. Comp. James iii. 14.
ἐὰν δὲ ἐν τῷ φωτὶ περιπατῶμεν ὡς αὐτὸς ἔστιν ἐν τῷ οὐ ποιῶμεν τὴν ἀλήθειαν] non facimus veritatem V., we do not the truth (syr vg gives do not advance in...). Truth is not only in thought and word, but also in action. 'The Truth' (ἡ ἀλήθεια) which reaches to every part of human nature—the sum of all that 'is'—must find expression in a form answering to the whole man. 'I act,' in the words of Whichcote, 'and therefore I am.' Comp. John iii. 21 note; Neh. ix. 33 (LXX.).
In the Old Testament the phrase 'to do mercy and truth' LXX. occurs not unfrequently: Gen. xlvii. 29; Josh. ii. 14; 2 Sam. ii. 6; xv. 20, &c. Contrast ποιεῖν ψεῦδος, Apoc. xxi. 27.